text photos on Flickr

Recently I wrote an article expressing my displeasure over not being able to photograph Jack Kerouac's classic manuscript "On the Road," currently on display at the San Francisco Public (sic) Library. The current owner of the document, Indianapolis Colt's owner Jim Irsay, has publicly stated his opinion that the scroll "belongs to the people." Still, irrespective of this "belongs to the people" assertion, you, as the organizer of the current tour of the scroll, apparently have decided not to allow photography of the document.

You have responded to my original article claiming that although Mr. Irsay owns the manuscript, he does not own the "copyright" to On The Road. This argument is hollow and does not ring true and well wouldn't Jack be proud. You go on to say that "therefore," you "had to work with the lawyers representing the holders of the copyright and that is why the photography policy was set." That's good information to consider, as I'm sure Jack would have been sure to consult with the attorneys of the railroad cars that he would hop back when he was alive.

Your copyright argument is flawed. I'm not sure how familiar you are with cameras these days, but as a photographer I can assure you that as the scroll is presently displayed, no one would be able to take more than a snippet of text, and only with a macro lens at best. You cannot shoot the words of the scroll clearly underneath the plexi-glass that you have over the document and to shoot through the glass would require sitting a lens on the glass which rests less than a foot from the document itself.

Although you cite "copyright" as your objection I would remind you of the general concept of "fair use," Nolo Press has a nice write up on it. "Fair use is based on the belief that the public is entitled to freely use portions of copyrighted materials for purposes of commentary and criticism. The fair use privilege is perhaps the most significant limitation on a copyright owner's exclusive rights." Further, taking snippets of text from copyrighted materials and quoting them is in fact fair use.

As you are well aware, it would be difficult if not impossible to copy large portions of the text of this document. Further, someone possessing photographs of the document still in no way reduces the copyright holders rights. The copyright on this document is not on the document itself but on the words contained therin. It would be no different than if I quoted from a paperback version or took a photograph of a paperback version of Jack's classic text.

So in the spirit of fair use I have decided to disregard your and the San Francisco Public Library's "no photography" policy and have in fact taken photos of your closely guarded scroll that per Irsay "belongs to the people." As I'm sure Jack didn't heed the no jumping rail cars signs I'll also disregard your "no photography allowed" signs. If, as you suggest, your copyright argument holds I'm sure that I'll be hearing from your lawyers shortly regarding my illegal use of copyrighted material. That's what I thought.

click here for the rest: thomashawk.com/2006/01/open-letter-to-myra-borshoff-cook-...

Analog vs digital by Karol

30 5

Macro Mondays theme #Opposites

by Brittney Borowski

44 8

I'm not really in the photo taking mood lately :/

By the way, i love listening to Christian music and water coloring if you can't tell :)

Give me your eyes for just one second

Give me your eyes so i can see

Everything that i keep missing

Give me your love for humanity

Give me your arms for the broken hearted

The ones that are far beyond my reach?

Give me your heart for the one's forgotten

Give me your eyes so i can see

Philadelphia Trump/GOP Protest-IMG_5105ps by David Huisken

12 2

Protesters came out in huge numbers to protest Trump who joined GOP members who were In Philadelphia to formulate their legislative agenda.

BUDAPEST III. by Zsolt Vidak

17 9

Typebars I - Incoming! by Domiriel

86 9

First image on Explore! Thanks, guys!

by patty jansen

1

0145 by Tomás M.Duval

10 2

Computer Desk Chair by William

96 14

Collage lll by Ken-Zan

14 2

by Mitt Romney

1

Big Kahuna Burger [47/365 2017] by It's Steven with a V

51 5

Had the idea of placing a ring in the centrefold of a book and photographing the heart shaped shadow it creates. But I got bored trying to set the shot up, so pulled out this old book that was my Grandads in the late 1920s.

Based on the text in the photo you'd think it was the screenplay for Pulp Fiction, but I couldn't find any reference in it to a Big Kahuna Burger.

by Ciro Miguel

16

Nos falta tiempo... by INTERMEDIA_A

9 2

by kewlio

59

Text by John St John

53 4

Train 1162, NJ Transit.

Texting by jeff Clouet

491 22

Paris, France

_DCS5397.jpg by Picture This Photography KS

Torre Solaria (BW) by Filippo Bianchi

1.3K 98

Torre Solaria in Milan, the tallest italian residential building.

Getty Images / 500px / Flickr Hive Mind / Fluidr / Flickeflu / Rvision

Please don't post on your comments your images or photostreams page or links to blogs, websites or flickriver: it will be deleted
Per favore non aggiungete vostre foto ai commenti, grazie: saranno cancellati

Explore: #18

12-05-2015

1212 Bogotá simultánea by César Guillermo Castro Gómez

10 4

Knaresborough Castle Door by Stephen Bowler

101 10

With sun bleached wood and old iron fittings, this door could be hundreds of years old.

Fire by SAN89

7 2

Ders RT by Lee 102

13 2

Southbank 11