View allAll Photos Tagged baretti

Il 26 luglio del 1873, Martino Baretti con la guida Giuseppe Cibrario, detta Vulpot ed un alpigiano detto Pertus come portatore, raggiunge la vera vetta dell’Uja Bessanese 3604 m, fino ad allora giudicata troppo difficile da scalare. Al tempo ci si fermava al segnale Tonini 3592 m, dal nome del primo salitore, dove oggi è posta una statua della Madonna.

 

Sulla Guida dei Monti d’Italia si trova una descrizione della salita fatta dal Baretti troppo colorita ed esilarante per non riportarne un breve stralcio :

“ Il Vulpot si porta innanzi, fa levare le scarpa al Pertus e lo spinge in alto per le parti nobili che presentano ampia superficie, mentre quest’ultimo punta i piedi nudi contro la roccia; sollevato ad una certa altezza arriva ad aggrapparsi ad un qualche cosa che gli sembra solido, e , sempre sospinto dal Vulpot viene a porre il ginocchio sul ciglione superiore del canale; il Pertus si è coricato sul dorso, solidamente ancorato sporgendo i piedi dal margine superiore del canale; il Vulpot mi spinge in alto “ut supra”, punto i piedi, mi aggrappo rapidamente prima ai piedi poi alle gambe del Pertus, ed eccomi in alto….tremo dall’emozione, il sangue mi bolle, i polmoni si dilatano quasi a far scoppiare la cavità toracica,, non attendo più i compagni, arrivo all’ultimo ciglione, ed un urlo indescrivibile mi erompe dal petto, è l’urlo del selvaggio sul caduto nemico, è l’urlo del soldato quando supera la breccia; in questo grido tutte le speranze, tutti gli sconforti dell’alpinista, tutte le gioie dell’amor proprio soddisfatto; è l’urrà della vittoria !”

 

Altri tempi.....il nostro arrivo in vetta è stato molto meno funambolico, ma la soddisfazione e l’emozione sono state comunque davvero grandi.

 

En Junio del 2015 volví a recorrer el Tour Du Mont-Blanc con 2 amigos como entrenamiento antes del reto montañero del año.

En 4 dias y medio hicimos los 160km con 10000 metros de desnivel positivo.

 

Killian Jornet recorrió la UTMB (170km) en 2008 en tan solo 20 horas.

 

En la imagen vemos lo que queda del Glaciar de Miage entre la Punta Baretti a la derecha y la Aiguilles de la Trélatête a la derecha. El glaciar desciende de la Aiguille de Bionnassay.

 

Esta foto fue tomada con la GoPro HERO4, Junio 2015.

 

*Artist of the Year*~L4 Double Platinum~

Pick of the Week - 12 Oct 2017

 

500px

facebook

Instagram

 

The novel "Cuore" written by Edmondo De Amicis is undoubtedly one of the masterpieces of Italian literature.

The novel is written in the form of a diary, written by the young protagonist Enrico Bottini, known as "Cuore". Bottini recounts the daily experiences of his classmates, each of whom represents a different aspect of Italian society at the end of the nineteenth century.

Enrico narrates the daily experiences of his classmates, each representing a different aspect of Italian society at that time. The main themes of the novel are: the importance of education, friendship and solidarity, patriotism as a national identity, which can be summarized in the importance of moral values and a sense of duty.

  

Cámara:Canon EOS 5D Mark

Lente: 24-70mm 2.8

Modo: Bulbe

Exposición:718 ( 12minutos)

Aperturef/3.2

Lente34 mm

Velocidad ISO:400

Tendencia de exposición:0 EV

FlashOff, Did not fire

Larga exposición de 12 minutos

Lugar de captura: Monument Valley, Utah,USA

Por: Cimarron mayor Panta.

 

NO ME CREERAN, NO ME IMPORTA!!

 

EL GRAN GALILEO GALILEI( EL HOMBRE QUE PARO EL SOL PARA MOVER LA TIERRA) FUE CONDENADO UN 21 DE JUNIO en el convento romano de Santa Maria sopra Minerva, le es leída la sentencia, donde se le condena a prisión perpetua, y se le conmina a abjurar de sus ideas, cosa que hace seguidamente. Tras la abjuración el Papa conmuta la prisión por arresto domiciliario de por vida.

 

Giuseppe Baretti afirmó que después de la abjuración Galileo dijo la famosa frase «Eppur si muove» («Y sin embargo se mueve»), pero según Stillman Drake Galileo no pronunció la famosa frase en ese momento ya que no se encontraba en situación de libertad y sin duda era desafiante hacerlo ante el tribunal de cardenales de la Inquisición.

A mi no me importa si Galileo pronunció o no la frase, para mi esto es una aurora boreal y hay que majarme los mellizos de Minnesota para demostrarme que no jajajaja.

 

Aurora polar (o aurora polaris) es un fenómeno en forma de brillo o luminiscencia de color verde que aparece en el cielo nocturno, actualmente en zonas polares, aunque puede aparecer en otras partes del mundo por cortos períodos. En el hemisferio norte se conoce como aurora boreal, y en el hemisferio sur como aurora austral, cuyo nombre proviene de Aurora, la diosa romana del amanecer, y de la palabra griega Bóreas, que significa norte; debido a que en Europa comúnmente aparece en el horizonte con un tono rojizo, como si el sol emergiera de una dirección inusual.

La aurora boreal es visible de septiembre a marzo, aunque en ciertas ocasiones hace su aparición durante el transcurso de otros meses, siempre y cuando la temperatura atmosférica sea lo suficientemente baja. Los mejores meses para verla son enero y febrero, ya que es en estos meses donde las temperaturas son más bajas!

 

Tenía todas las condiciones a mi favor.

Era medianoche con un cielo limpio y estrellado a pedir de boca.

Temperaturas muy bajas

Y el mes ideal para que ocurriese este fenómeno tan espectacular!

 

Créanme o no aquí está!

 

Gran resto de domingo amigos!!

 

Cimarron mayor Panta

Sta tutto rint' all'anema, sta tutto rint' all'aria

stà tutto rint' 'a musica, sta tutte cose ccà

(99 posse)

Cámara:Canon EOS 5D Mark

Lente: 24-70mm 2.8

Modo: Bulbe

Exposición:718 ( 12minutos)

Aperturef/3.2

Lente 25 mm

Velocidad ISO:400

Tendencia de exposición:0 EV

FlashOff, Did not fire

Larga exposición de 15 minutos

Lugar de captura: Monument Valley Utah, USA

Por: Cimarron mayor Panta.

 

NO ME CREERAN, NO ME IMPORTA!!

 

EL GRAN GALILEO GALILEI( EL HOMBRE QUE PARO EL SOL PARA MOVER LA TIERRA) FUE CONDENADO UN 21 E JUNIO en el convento romano de Santa Maria sopra Minerva, le es leída la sentencia, donde se le condena a prisión perpetua, y se le conmina a abjurar de sus ideas, cosa que hace seguidamente. Tras la abjuración el Papa conmuta la prisión por arresto domiciliario de por vida.

 

Giuseppe Baretti afirmó que después de la abjuración Galileo dijo la famosa frase «Eppur si muove» («Y sin embargo se mueve»), pero según Stillman Drake Galileo no pronunció la famosa frase en ese momento ya que no se encontraba en situación de libertad y sin duda era desafiante hacerlo ante el tribunal de cardenales de la Inquisición.

A mi no me importa si Galileo pronunció o no la frase, para mi esto es una aurora boreal y hay que majarme los mellizos de Minnesota para demostrarme que no jajajaja.

 

Aurora polar (o aurora polaris) es un fenómeno en forma de brillo o luminiscencia que aparece en el cielo nocturno, actualmente en zonas polares, aunque puede aparecer en otras partes del mundo por cortos períodos. En el hemisferio norte se conoce como aurora boreal, y en el hemisferio sur como aurora austral, cuyo nombre proviene de Aurora, la diosa romana del amanecer, y de la palabra griega Bóreas, que significa norte; debido a que en Europa comúnmente aparece en el horizonte con un tono rojizo, como si el sol emergiera de una dirección inusual.

La aurora boreal es visible de septiembre a marzo, aunque en ciertas ocasiones hace su aparición durante el transcurso de otros meses, siempre y cuando la temperatura atmosférica sea lo suficientemente baja. Los mejores meses para verla son enero y febrero, ya que es en estos meses donde las temperaturas son más bajas!

 

Tenía todas las condiciones a mi favor.

Era medianoche

Temperaturas muy bajas

Y el mes ideal para que ocurriese este fenómeno tan espectacular!

 

Créanme o no aquí está!

 

Gran resto de domingo amigos!!

 

Cimarron mayor Panta

 

Teatro Baretti

Musiche classiche e tradizionali cinesi per p’i-p’a

Liu Fang, p’i-p’a

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

West Building, Main Floor—Gallery 59

 

•Date: 1782

•Medium: Oil on Canvas

•Dimensions:

oOverall: 245.5 × 147.4 cm (96⅝ × 58 1/16 in.)

oFramed: 274.3 × 177.2 × 9.5 cm (108 × 69¾ × 3¾ in.)

•Credit Line: Andrew W. Mellon Collection

•Accession Number: 1950.18.1

•Artists/Makers

oPainter: Gilbert Stuart, American, 1755-1828

 

Overview

 

In 1775, Gilbert Stuart set sail for London where Benjamin West welcomed the destitute young man into his home. The Skater marks the end of his five-year apprenticeship to West. Stuart’s first effort at full-length portraiture, its originality brought the artist so much notice at the 1782 Royal Academy exhibition that he soon set up his own studio.

 

The unorthodox motif of skating—indeed, any presentation of vigorous movement at all—had absolutely no precedent in Britain’s “Grand Manner” tradition of life-size society portraiture. The painter recalled that when William Grant, from Congalton near Edinburgh, arrived to have his picture painted, the Scottish sitter remarked that, “on account of the excessive coldness of the weather … the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait.” Thus artist and sitter went off to skate on the Serpentine River in Hyde Park. When he returned to West’s studio with Grant, Stuart conceived the idea of portraying his subject on ice skates in a winter landscape, with the twin towers of Westminster Abbey far in the distance.

 

In this innovative design, Grant glides effortlessly forward with arms crossed over his chest in typical eighteenth-century skating form. Except for his folded arms, the figure’s stance derives from an ancient Roman statue, the Apollo Belvedere, a cast of which stood in the corner of West’s studio.

 

Provenance

 

The sitter, William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son, William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter, Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];[1] her son, Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;[2] his widow, Elizabeth Pelham-Clinton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter, Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Clinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913] London; sold 1950 to the NGA.

 

[1]The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke’s Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Peerage, Baronetage and Knightage, Privy Council and Order of Precedence, 101st ed., London, 1956: 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Clinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Clinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

[2]According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA curatorial file), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

 

Associated Names

 

•Clinton, Pelham, Miss

•Grant, William

•Grant, William

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton, Mrs.

•Pelham-Clinton, Elizabeth

 

Exhibition History

 

•1782—Royal Academy, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating

•1878—Exhibition of Works by Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough

•1946—American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206

•1963—Style, Truth, and the Portrait, Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38

•1967—Gilbert Stuart, Portraitist of the Young Republic, 1755-1828, National Gallery of Art; Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design, Providence, 1967, no. 8

•1976—American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44

•1981—American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; National Portrait Gallery, Washington, D.C., 1981-1982, no. 21.

•2001—Great British Paintings from American Collections: Holbein to Hockney, Yale Center for British Art, New Haven; The Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens, San Marino, 2001-2002, no. 35, repro.

•2004—Gilbert Stuart, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; National Gallery of Art (for the National Portrait Gallery), Washington, D.C., 2004-2005, no. 6, repro.

 

Bibliography

 

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (9 May 1782): 2.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (30 April 1782): 3.

•1816—Jouett, Matthew Harris. “Notes Taken by M. H. Jouett while in Boston from Conversations on painting with Gilbert Stuart Esqr.” Manuscript, published in Gilbert Stuart and His Pupils, by John Hill Morgan. New York, 1816: 86, 87.

•1846—Lester, C. Edwards. The Artists of America. New York, 1846: 126.

•1869—Dunlap, William. A History of the Rise and Progress of The Arts of Design in the United States. 2 vols. Reprinted in 3. New York, 1969 (1834): 1:183-184.

•1877—Stuart, Jane. “The Youth of Gilbert Stuart.” Scribner’s Monthly 13, no. 5 (March 1877): 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (January 19, 1878): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (January 26, 1878): 91.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (January 12, 1878): 50.

•1879—Mason, George C. The Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1879: 187-190.

•1880—”Portraits Painted by Stuart...taken from Mason’s Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart.” In Exhibition of Portraits Painted by Gilbert Stuart. Exh. cat. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 1880: 41, no. 268.

•1883—Quincy, Josiah. Figures of the Past from the Leaves of Old Journals. 4th ed. Boston, 1883: 84.

•1926—Park 1926, 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley, William T. Artists and Their Friends in England, 1700-1800. 2 vols. London and Boston, 1928: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley, William T. Gilbert Stuart. Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1932: 15, 31-36.

•1952 Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds., Great Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1952: 138, color repro., as The Skater.

•1956 Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1956: 50, color repro., as The Skater.

•1957—Shapley, Fern Rusk. Comparisons in Art: A Companion to the National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. London, 1957 (reprinted 1959): pl. 91.

•1961—Oswald, Arthur. “Our Ancestors on the Ice.” Country Life 129 (9 February 1961): 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount, Charles Merrill. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1964: 69-74.

•1966—Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds. A Pageant of Painting from the National Gallery of Art. 2 vols. New York, 1966: 2:380, color repro.

•1969—Novak, Barbara. American Painting of the Nineteenth Century: Realism, Idealism, and the American Experience. 2nd ed. New York, 1979: 32, fig. 1.17.

•1969—Prown, Jules David. American Painting, From its Beginnings to the Armory Show. Geneva, 1969: 47-48.

•1970—American Paintings and Sculpture: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1970: 106, repro., as The Skater.

•1973—Button, Dick. “The Art of Skating.” Antiques 103, no. 2 (February 1973): 351-362, color repro. on cover.

•1973—Finley, David Edward. A Standard of Excellence: Andrew W. Mellon Founds the National Gallery of Art at Washington. Washington, 1973: 135.

•1975—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1975: 380, color repro. 381.

•1978—King, Marian. Adventures in Art: National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C. New York, 1978: 54, pl. 31.

•1980—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1980: 234, repro.

•1980—Evans, Dorinda. Benjamin West and His American Students. Exh. cat. National Portrait Gallery, Washington; Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, Philadelphia. Washington, 1980: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1980: 10, no. 6, color repro.

•1981—Waterson, Merlin. “Hissing Along the Polished Ice.” Country Life 169 (2 April 1981): repro. 872.

•1981—Williams, William James. A Heritage of American Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1981: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. Rev. ed. New York, 1984: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986 McLanathan, Richard. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1986: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1986—Pressly, William L. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater: An Essay in Romantic Melancholy.” American Art Journal 18, no. 1, 1986: 42-51, fig. 1.

•1987—Pearson, Andrea G. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater (Portrait of William Grant) and Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker, D.D., Skating on Duddington Loch: A Study of Sources.” Rutgers Art Review 8 (1987): 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. Rev. ed. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1988: 58-59, no. 6, color repro.

•1990—Crean, Hugh R. Gilbert Stuart and the politics of fine arts patronage in Ireland, 1787-1793; A social and cultural study. Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1990: 55-62.

•1992—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 345, repro.

•1992—National Gallery of Art, Washington. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 214, repro.

•1995—Miles, Ellen G. American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century. The Collections of the National Gallery of Art Systematic Catalogue. Washington, D.C., 1995: 162-169, color repro. 165.

•1997—Hughes, Robert. American Visions: The Epic History of Art in America. New York, 1997: 128, color fig. 81.

•1997—Thomson, Duncan. Raeburn: The Art of Sir Henry Raeburn 1756-1823, Exh. cat. Scottish National Portrait Gallery at the Royal Scottish Academy, Edinburgh; National Portrait Gallery, London, 1997-1998, p. 90, no. 61, repro.

•1998—Mandel, Corinne. “Melancholy.” In Encyclopedia of Comparative Iconography: Themes Depicted in Works of Art, edited by Helene E. Roberts. 2 vols. Chicago, 1998: 2:586-588.

•2004—Hand, John Oliver. National Gallery of Art: Master Paintings from the Collection. Washington and New York, 2004: 294-295, no. 240, color repro.

•2011—Gopnik, Adam. Winter: Four Windows on the Season. Toronto, 2011: 142-143, color repro.

•2013—Evans, Dorinda. Gilbert Stuart and the Impact of Manic Depression. Burlington, 2013: 162-164, 168 nn. 36 and 37, fig. 11.

•2016—Rather, Susan. The American School: Artists and Status in the Late Colonial and Early National Era. New Haven, 2016: 171-172, color fig. 125.

  

From American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century:

 

1950.18.1 (1051)

 

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

•1782

•Oil on Canvas, 244.5 × 147.4 (96¼ × 58)

•Andrew W. Mellon Collection

 

Technical Notes

 

The support is a finely woven twill fabric. The top and bottom tacking edges have been unfolded and add about 6 cm to the painting’s height. The lateral tacking margins have been cropped, but cusping remains along these edges. The thin white ground extends to cover the tacking margins, suggesting that the canvas was pre-primed. Much of the preliminary drawing, done loosely with paint and brush, is visible on the surface, having been incorporated into the painting. The paint is thinly applied, except in the sitter’s upper body, face, and collar, and in the sky around his head, where the paint is thicker and its handling more controlled. Many pentimenti are evident, including changes in the figure’s hat, shoulders, tail of the coat on the viewer’s right, and the sitter’s right leg.

 

Abrasion is found in the ice at the sitter’s feet. Crackle is more pronounced near the head, where the paint is thicker, and is especially pronounced to the right of the skater’s thigh. There are pinpoint losses throughout. The painting was lined prior to 1950.

 

Provenance

 

William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];1 her son Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;2 his widow Elizabeth Pelham-Clin ton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Glinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913], London.

 

Exhibited

 

Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating. Exhibition of Works by the Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James3s Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough.3 American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206. Style, Truth and the Portrait, The Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38. Gilbert Stuart, NGA; RISD, 1967, no. 8. American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, YUAG; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44. American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; NGA, 1981-1982, no. 21.

 

In 1782 Gilbert Stuart, a young painter in London, was “suddenly lifted into fame by the exhibition of a single picture,”4 his full-length of William Grant called Portrait of a Gentleman Skating. (The painting was given its present title of The Skater m 1946.) Stuart devised the theme after an outing on the Serpentine river in Hyde Park with Grant, a young Scottish lawyer, who had come for a sitting for a full-length portrait. According to American artist William Dunlap, who heard the story from miniaturist Charles Fraser,

 

Stuart said that he felt great diffidence in undertaking a whole length; but that there must be a beginning, and a day was accordingly appointed for Mr. Grant to sit. On entering the artist’s room, he regretted the appointment, on account of the excessive coldness of the weather, and observed to Stuart, that the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait. To this the painter assented, and they both sallied out to their morning’s amusement. Stuart said that early practice had made him very expert in skating. His celerity and activity accordingly attracted crowds on the Serpentine river—which was the scene of their sport. His companion, although a well-made and graceful man, was not as active as himself; and there being a crack in the ice, which made it dangerous to continue their amusement, he told Mr. Grant to hold the skirt of his coat, and follow him off the field. They returned to Mr. Stuart’s rooms, where it occurred to him to paint Mr. Grant in the attitude of skating, with the appendage of a winter scene, in the back ground.5

 

The setting for the portrait is the Serpentine, a popular skating spot in London that was created when Kensington Gardens was landscaped during the reign of George II.6 Grant is dressed completely in black, from his hat and the fur-lined lapels of his coat to his breeches, stockings, and shoes. Behind him to the right two skaters sit at the edge of the ice, putting on their skates, while two other men stand under a tree. In the left background two skaters perform the Salutation, also known as the Serpentine Greeting, while others watch.7 The painting offers a balance of black, gray, and off-white, with slight touches of red on the clothing of the background figures. Stuart’s pupil Matthew Harris Jouett later described the portrait as a “fine contrast of Grant in full black to the snow & grey chilly background.”8 The young lawyer William Grant (d. 1821) was the son of Ludovick Grant of Edinburgh.9 Why he chose Stuart to paint his portrait is not known ; perhaps he was a friend or a distant relative of Stuart’s early London patron Alexander Grant, also a Scot.10 Moderately wealthy, Grant was fond of portraits. George Romney painted him in 1781 and again in 1787, and in 1794 he painted “ Mrs. Grant, “ perhaps Grant’s wife Dorothea Dalrymple, whom he married that year. Grant’s children were painted by John Opie (LaSalle University Art Museum, Philadelphia).11 At his death in 1821, Grant left his heirs a large estate called Congalton, in Scotland, as well as stock in the Bank of England and the Royal Bank of Scotland.

 

The portrait, Stuart’s first full-length, showed his ability to invent new compositions within the tradition of English portraiture, in which standing cross-legged poses had been popular for men’s portraits since the 17405. Its success made it possible for Stuart to move from West’s studio into one of his own. Comparisons between the two American artists by contemporaries were inevitable. When Giuseppi Baretti, an Italian-born lexicographer, author, and friend of Sir Joshua Reynolds, saw the painting at West’s before its exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts, he commented, according to Dunlap, “What a charming picture ! Who but the great West could have painted such a one ! “ Later, seeing Stuart at work on the painting, he exclaimed, “What, young man, does Mr. West permit you to touch his pictures?” Stuart replied that it was his own painting. Baretti is supposed to have said, “Why, it is almost as good as Mr. West can paint.”12 The close association of the two men’s work is revealed by an undated chalk drawing by West titled Skateing. West, like Stuart, enjoyed a reputation as a good skater, and in this chalk drawing depicted skaters and spectators on the ice at the Serpentine. A skater in the center foreground turns toward the man behind him, who lies on the ice after a fall. To the left, two figures who perform the Serpentine Greeting are virtually identical to the two skaters in the background of Stuart’s portrait of Grant. To the right is a small figure whose pose seems similar to Grant’s; the figure is very sketchy.

 

A reviewer noted Stuart’s relationship to Benjamin West when Stuart exhibited the painting with three others at the Royal Academy of Arts in 1782.

 

Mr. Stuart is in Partnership with Mr. West; where it is not uncommon for Wits to divert themselves with Applications for Things they do not immediately want; because they are told by Mr. West that Mr. Stuart is the only Portrait Painter in the World; and by Mr. Stuart that no Man has any Pretensions in History Painting but Mr. West. After such Authority what can we say of Mr. Stuart’s Painting.13

 

The portrait enchanted visitors who attended the Academy’s exhibition. Horace Walpole, author of Anecdotes of Painting in England (1762-1771), the first history of British art, wrote “very good” next to the entry for the portrait in his copy of the catalogue.14 Stuart overheard the Duke of Rutland on opening day, urging Sir Joshua Reynolds, “I wish you would go to the exhibition with me, for there is a portrait there which you must see, every body is enchanted with it.” When Sir Joshua asked who painted it, the Duke replied, “A young man by the name of Stuart. “15 Visitors and reviewers praised the portrait’s unusual pose and Stuart’s ability with likeness. Sir John Cullum commented on the novelty of the theme in his letter of 1 May 1782 to Frederick Hervey, Bishop of Derry and Earl of Bristol. “One would have thought that almost every attitude of a single Figure had long been exhausted in this land of portrait painting but one is now exhibited which I recollect not before—it is that of Skating. There is a noble portrait large as life thus exhibited and which produces the most powerful effect.”16 A reviewer for the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser commented on 30 April that “Stuart and Opie, whose merits were not so generally known, have proved themselves able artists” and praised Stuart for his “striking likenesses.”17 Stuart’s ability to capture a likeness was borne out by Charles Fraser’s later comment to artist William Dunlap that the picture attracted so much comment that Stuart was “afraid to go to the academy to meet the looks and answer the inquiries of the multitude. Mr. Grant went one day to the exhibition, dressed as his portrait represented him; the original was immediately recognized, when the crowd followed him so closely that he was compelled to make his retreat, for every one was exclaiming, ‘There he is, there is the gentleman.’”18

 

Opinion was divided on the technique of the painting. One reviewer said that “Mr. Stuart seldom fails of a Likeness; but wants Freedom of Pencil, and Elegance of Taste.”19 However, the author of a letter in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser noted, “ Mr. Stuart… may be said to be an acquisition to the public; his Gentleman seating, No. 190, is reposed, animated and well drawn.”20 And a critic in the London Courant commented on the portrait as Stuart’s first attempt at a full-length. “If we have been informed aright this is the gentleman’s first essay in this branch of the art ; at all events it does honour to his pencil, from the novelty of the design and the neatness of the execution.”21 A commentator in 1795 wrote about Stuart’s early difficulty with a portrait of this size.

 

It is now some years since Stuart the portrait painter … painted a portrait of a Mr. Grant in the action of skating; this portrait was given in so spirited an attitude and with so appropriate a character that when it was exhibited, it established the fame of the artist, of whom his brethren had before that time said he made a tolerable likeness of a face, but as to the figure he could not get below the fifth button.22

 

The combination of the full-length portrait with the act of skating was indeed a novel theme. Stuart appropriately portrayed Grant as a figure skater, the version of the sport popular in England, which emphasized graceful and refined movements, instead of as a Scottish speed skater, which encouraged skill, speed, and competition. Grant wears skates designed for the “small pivots and graceful maneuvers which were essential to the art of figure skating.”23 Robert Jones, in his influential Treatise on Skating (London, 1772), recommended a similar crossedarm pose as “a proper attitude for genteel rolling” (Figure 2).24 Matthew HarrisJouett in 1816 quoted Stuart on “the importance of keeping the figure in its circle of motion, “ giving the example of “his famous skaiting picture of Grant as contrasted with Buckminster Preble who turns his body one way his neck another and his eyes another…. “25

 

The painting is unlike other images of skaters, which belong to the tradition of sporting scenes. They include Irish painter Robert Healy’s Tom Conolly and his Friends Skating (1768, private collection, Ireland), Sir Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker Skating on Duddingston Loch (c. 1784, National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh), Thomas Rowlandson’s watercolor Skaters on the Serpentine of 1784 (National Museum of Wales, Cardiff), and a view by Julius Caesar Ibbetson engraved in 1787 as Winter Amusement; A View in Hyde Park from the Moated Housed Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg’s A Winter Morning, with a Party Skating of 1776 is particularly close to Stuart’s and West’s images in that it shows skating figures similar to those who perform the Serpentine Greeting. And like de Loutherbourg’s scene, Benjamin West’s undated drawing Skateing focuses its action on the popular Serpentine river. In the background is a structure similar to the Cheesecake House, a refreshment lodge that is also seen in the images by Rowlandson and Ibbetson. De Loutherbourg’s scene, which includes portraits of the artist and his wife, the artist’s partner V.M. Picot and others, was the best known of the various images of skaters made before or at the time that Stuart painted his portrait of Grant. It was reproduced by Matthew Boulton’s picture manufactory in Birmingham, England, between 1776 and 1780 by an unusual reproductive process that replicated paintings with their original coloring. In the mid-1780s a cloth merchant and amateur painter named Joseph Booth revived the idea of reproducing the painting by using a “polygraph process.” Numerous color reproductions of de Loutherbourg’s Winter Morning survive.27

 

Art historian William Pressly has proposed an interpretation of The Skater as expressing the theme of melancholy. To Pressly, the “recently revived tradition of the melancholy hero” explains the somber coloration of the painting, the darkly shaded eyes of the skater, and the use of a crossed-arm pose. In this view the painting becomes a self-portrait of Stuart’s own tendency toward melancholy. The snowy setting is appropriate in this theory, since winter was traditionally associated with melancholia.28 One might even suggest that Stuart included himself as the man on the right who stands under a tree. The physiognomy of this spectator, with his long nose and angular chin, closely resembles Stuart’s self-portrait of around 1786. Whether the association of the mood and the season necessarily points to melancholy as the subject of the painting is uncertain, even though the connection of the two was well known at the time and had been developed in verse many years earlier by the English poet James Thomson in his poem “Winter” in The Seasons (1730). “Winter” itself could be the theme, rather than “melancholy.” As Jules Prown has pointed out, “The skater evokes an allegorical image of Winter as one of the Four Seasons. “29 Lines from Thomson’s “Winter” form the caption for a late eighteenth-century English mezzotint titled “Winter,” which shows three warmly dressed figures walking near the Serpentine, where skaters can be seen in the background. “While every work of man is laid at rest, “ they “swoop on sounding skates a thousand different ways” and the “land is madden’d all to joy” (“Winter,” verses 761, 769, 771).30 The allusion to the mood of the season indicates that Stuart had absorbed the highly sophisticated London practice of borrowing from literary works for the subject matter of portraits.

 

Stuart was also absorbing lessons on technique. The portrait is a masterpiece of the late eighteenth-century British style of portraiture, which focuses on the figure, particularly the face, by painting the background with less detail. X-radiography shows that Stuart, when painting Grant’s face, had not yet developed the fully calligraphic brushwork for which he is known in his later paintings. Here he shaped the eyes, nose, mouth, and shadow of the nose by drawing the features with the brush. Later he would not follow the outline of the individual features as closely. Stuart also used more white pigment in the transitional flesh tones than he would in later works. X-radiography suggests, not surprisingly, that Stuart painted the background after completing the figure; the brushstrokes of the clouds mark the outer edges of the hat, face, and shoulders, which were already blocked out and painted. In addition, close examination of the painting reveals changes, or pentimenti, in the hat, shoulders, tail of the coat, and sitter’s right leg, indicating that Stuart did indeed struggle with the challenge inherent in a full-length, a size he rarely agreed to use again in his long career.

 

EGM

 

Notes

 

1.The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke 1956, 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Glinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Glinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

2.According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

3.Royal Academy 1878, unpaginated; Graves 1913, 1:383,3:1275; Graves 1905,71296. For a discussion of the attribution of the portrait in 1878 to Gainsborough, and the Grant family’s research to determine Stuart’s authorship, see Whitley 1932,33-36.

4.Quincy 1883,84, who does not identify the picture.

5.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Fraser heard the story from Stuart. John Gait had by then published his story about Benjamin West as a skater; see Gait 1820, 2:26-31. Gait told how, when West was a young artist in London in the 17605, his skating skills had brought him to the attention of the English aristocracy. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the similarity of the two anecdotes.

6.Hayes 1990, 64.

7.Button 1973, 354.

8.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87; since Jouett never saw the portrait, his description must be a quotation from Stuart.

9.Faculty of Advocates 1944, 90, courtesy of Dr. Louise Yeoman, Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh.

10.Alexander Grant is mentioned in Stuart 1877, 642; see also Stuart 1967,14.

11.Ward and Roberts 1904, 2:63-64. The earlier portrait of Grant by Romney was sold by Georgiana Bordewich, former owner of The Skater, at Christie’s on 22 March 1974 (lot 96) and bought by Léger Galleries; see Léger Galleries 1975, unpaginated, no. 5. Mrs. Bordewich also sold a portrait said to be of Grant by Thomas Hudson (lot 94), 127 by 101.6 cm (50 by 40 inches), and the portrait of his four eldest children, attributed to Opie (lot 95). The portrait of Mrs. Grant remained in Romney’s studio and was sold at Romney’s sale in 1807.

12.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Jouett referred to Baretti’s “mistaking it for Wests best production” when he recorded Stuart’s comments about painting in 1816; see Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87.

13.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

14.Whitley 1932,32.

15.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

16.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, and Pressly 1986, 44, from Childe-Pemberton 1925,1:284.

17.“Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition,” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser, 30 April 1782, 3.

18.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

19.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

20.The letter from the correspondent, identified as “Candid,” was published in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser on 9 May 1782, 2.

21.Quoted in Whitley 1932, 33, from an unidentified issue.

22.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, from an unidentified source.

23.Pearson 1987, 59.

24.Pressly 1986, 48; Pearson 1987, 60, 62, fig. 8.

25.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 86.

26.For three of these paintings see Hayes 1990, 64-66, no. 19, color repro.; and Pearson 1987, 57 fig. 2 and 61 fig. 7.

27.de Loutherbourg 1973, unpaginated, cat. no. 22. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the significance of this image for Stuart’s and West’s works.

28.Pressly 1986, 42-51.

29.Prown 1969, 48.

30.Quoted in Button 1973, 355, fig. 4.

 

References

 

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 30 April: 3.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post. 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 9 May: 2.

•1816—Jouett: 86, 87.

•1834—Dunlap: 1:183-184.

•1846—Lester: 126.

•1877—Stuart: 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (12 January): 50.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (19 January): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (26 January): 91.

•1879—Mason: 187-190.

•1880—MFA: 41, no.268.

•1883—Quincy: 84.

•1926—Park: 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley: 15, 31-36.

•1961—Oswald: 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount: 69-74.

•1969—Prown: 47-48.

•1973—Button: 351-3 62, color cover repro.

•1980—Evans: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding: 50, color repro .51.

•1981—Waterson: 872 repro.

•1981—Williams: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986—Pressly: 42-51, fig.1.

•1986—McLanathan: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1987—Pearson: 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding: 58-59, color repro.

•1990—Crean: 55-62.

Lauri Allan Törni (from 1954 Larry A. Thorne) 28 May 1919 Viipuri - 18 October 1965 Vietnam.

 

Shout! Lauri Törni’s name,

A soldier of 3 armies knows the game

Deeds that echo from the past

Rise! from beyond your grave,

Son of Finland and a green beret

May you rest in peace at last

Lauri Allan Törni

 

[Sabaton : Soldier of 3 Armies]

••••••••

Lauri Allan Törni (vuodesta 1954 Larry A. Thorne) 28.5.1919 Viipuri - 18.10.1965 Vietnam.

 

Huuda! Lauri Törnin nimeä

Kolmen armeijan sotilas tietää pelin

Urotyöt kaikuvat menneisyydestä

Nouse! Haudan tuolta puolen

Suomen poika ja vihreä baretti

Saat vihdoin levätä rauhassa

Lauri Allan Törni

 

[Sabaton : Soldier of 3 Armies]

••••••••

[Kuva : Lauri Törni perinnekilta]

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

West Building, Main Floor—Gallery 59

 

•Date: 1782

•Medium: Oil on Canvas

•Dimensions:

oOverall: 245.5 × 147.4 cm (96⅝ × 58 1/16 in.)

oFramed: 274.3 × 177.2 × 9.5 cm (108 × 69¾ × 3¾ in.)

•Credit Line: Andrew W. Mellon Collection

•Accession Number: 1950.18.1

•Artists/Makers

oPainter: Gilbert Stuart, American, 1755-1828

 

Overview

 

In 1775, Gilbert Stuart set sail for London where Benjamin West welcomed the destitute young man into his home. The Skater marks the end of his five-year apprenticeship to West. Stuart’s first effort at full-length portraiture, its originality brought the artist so much notice at the 1782 Royal Academy exhibition that he soon set up his own studio.

 

The unorthodox motif of skating—indeed, any presentation of vigorous movement at all—had absolutely no precedent in Britain’s “Grand Manner” tradition of life-size society portraiture. The painter recalled that when William Grant, from Congalton near Edinburgh, arrived to have his picture painted, the Scottish sitter remarked that, “on account of the excessive coldness of the weather … the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait.” Thus artist and sitter went off to skate on the Serpentine River in Hyde Park. When he returned to West’s studio with Grant, Stuart conceived the idea of portraying his subject on ice skates in a winter landscape, with the twin towers of Westminster Abbey far in the distance.

 

In this innovative design, Grant glides effortlessly forward with arms crossed over his chest in typical eighteenth-century skating form. Except for his folded arms, the figure’s stance derives from an ancient Roman statue, the Apollo Belvedere, a cast of which stood in the corner of West’s studio.

 

Provenance

 

The sitter, William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son, William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter, Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];[1] her son, Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;[2] his widow, Elizabeth Pelham-Clinton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter, Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Clinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913] London; sold 1950 to the NGA.

 

[1]The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke’s Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Peerage, Baronetage and Knightage, Privy Council and Order of Precedence, 101st ed., London, 1956: 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Clinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Clinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

[2]According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA curatorial file), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

 

Associated Names

 

•Clinton, Pelham, Miss

•Grant, William

•Grant, William

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton, Mrs.

•Pelham-Clinton, Elizabeth

 

Exhibition History

 

•1782—Royal Academy, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating

•1878—Exhibition of Works by Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough

•1946—American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206

•1963—Style, Truth, and the Portrait, Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38

•1967—Gilbert Stuart, Portraitist of the Young Republic, 1755-1828, National Gallery of Art; Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design, Providence, 1967, no. 8

•1976—American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44

•1981—American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; National Portrait Gallery, Washington, D.C., 1981-1982, no. 21.

•2001—Great British Paintings from American Collections: Holbein to Hockney, Yale Center for British Art, New Haven; The Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens, San Marino, 2001-2002, no. 35, repro.

•2004—Gilbert Stuart, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; National Gallery of Art (for the National Portrait Gallery), Washington, D.C., 2004-2005, no. 6, repro.

 

Bibliography

 

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (9 May 1782): 2.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (30 April 1782): 3.

•1816—Jouett, Matthew Harris. “Notes Taken by M. H. Jouett while in Boston from Conversations on painting with Gilbert Stuart Esqr.” Manuscript, published in Gilbert Stuart and His Pupils, by John Hill Morgan. New York, 1816: 86, 87.

•1846—Lester, C. Edwards. The Artists of America. New York, 1846: 126.

•1869—Dunlap, William. A History of the Rise and Progress of The Arts of Design in the United States. 2 vols. Reprinted in 3. New York, 1969 (1834): 1:183-184.

•1877—Stuart, Jane. “The Youth of Gilbert Stuart.” Scribner’s Monthly 13, no. 5 (March 1877): 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (January 19, 1878): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (January 26, 1878): 91.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (January 12, 1878): 50.

•1879—Mason, George C. The Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1879: 187-190.

•1880—”Portraits Painted by Stuart...taken from Mason’s Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart.” In Exhibition of Portraits Painted by Gilbert Stuart. Exh. cat. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 1880: 41, no. 268.

•1883—Quincy, Josiah. Figures of the Past from the Leaves of Old Journals. 4th ed. Boston, 1883: 84.

•1926—Park 1926, 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley, William T. Artists and Their Friends in England, 1700-1800. 2 vols. London and Boston, 1928: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley, William T. Gilbert Stuart. Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1932: 15, 31-36.

•1952 Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds., Great Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1952: 138, color repro., as The Skater.

•1956 Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1956: 50, color repro., as The Skater.

•1957—Shapley, Fern Rusk. Comparisons in Art: A Companion to the National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. London, 1957 (reprinted 1959): pl. 91.

•1961—Oswald, Arthur. “Our Ancestors on the Ice.” Country Life 129 (9 February 1961): 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount, Charles Merrill. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1964: 69-74.

•1966—Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds. A Pageant of Painting from the National Gallery of Art. 2 vols. New York, 1966: 2:380, color repro.

•1969—Novak, Barbara. American Painting of the Nineteenth Century: Realism, Idealism, and the American Experience. 2nd ed. New York, 1979: 32, fig. 1.17.

•1969—Prown, Jules David. American Painting, From its Beginnings to the Armory Show. Geneva, 1969: 47-48.

•1970—American Paintings and Sculpture: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1970: 106, repro., as The Skater.

•1973—Button, Dick. “The Art of Skating.” Antiques 103, no. 2 (February 1973): 351-362, color repro. on cover.

•1973—Finley, David Edward. A Standard of Excellence: Andrew W. Mellon Founds the National Gallery of Art at Washington. Washington, 1973: 135.

•1975—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1975: 380, color repro. 381.

•1978—King, Marian. Adventures in Art: National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C. New York, 1978: 54, pl. 31.

•1980—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1980: 234, repro.

•1980—Evans, Dorinda. Benjamin West and His American Students. Exh. cat. National Portrait Gallery, Washington; Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, Philadelphia. Washington, 1980: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1980: 10, no. 6, color repro.

•1981—Waterson, Merlin. “Hissing Along the Polished Ice.” Country Life 169 (2 April 1981): repro. 872.

•1981—Williams, William James. A Heritage of American Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1981: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. Rev. ed. New York, 1984: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986 McLanathan, Richard. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1986: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1986—Pressly, William L. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater: An Essay in Romantic Melancholy.” American Art Journal 18, no. 1, 1986: 42-51, fig. 1.

•1987—Pearson, Andrea G. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater (Portrait of William Grant) and Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker, D.D., Skating on Duddington Loch: A Study of Sources.” Rutgers Art Review 8 (1987): 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. Rev. ed. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1988: 58-59, no. 6, color repro.

•1990—Crean, Hugh R. Gilbert Stuart and the politics of fine arts patronage in Ireland, 1787-1793; A social and cultural study. Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1990: 55-62.

•1992—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 345, repro.

•1992—National Gallery of Art, Washington. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 214, repro.

•1995—Miles, Ellen G. American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century. The Collections of the National Gallery of Art Systematic Catalogue. Washington, D.C., 1995: 162-169, color repro. 165.

•1997—Hughes, Robert. American Visions: The Epic History of Art in America. New York, 1997: 128, color fig. 81.

•1997—Thomson, Duncan. Raeburn: The Art of Sir Henry Raeburn 1756-1823, Exh. cat. Scottish National Portrait Gallery at the Royal Scottish Academy, Edinburgh; National Portrait Gallery, London, 1997-1998, p. 90, no. 61, repro.

•1998—Mandel, Corinne. “Melancholy.” In Encyclopedia of Comparative Iconography: Themes Depicted in Works of Art, edited by Helene E. Roberts. 2 vols. Chicago, 1998: 2:586-588.

•2004—Hand, John Oliver. National Gallery of Art: Master Paintings from the Collection. Washington and New York, 2004: 294-295, no. 240, color repro.

•2011—Gopnik, Adam. Winter: Four Windows on the Season. Toronto, 2011: 142-143, color repro.

•2013—Evans, Dorinda. Gilbert Stuart and the Impact of Manic Depression. Burlington, 2013: 162-164, 168 nn. 36 and 37, fig. 11.

•2016—Rather, Susan. The American School: Artists and Status in the Late Colonial and Early National Era. New Haven, 2016: 171-172, color fig. 125.

  

From American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century:

 

1950.18.1 (1051)

 

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

•1782

•Oil on Canvas, 244.5 × 147.4 (96¼ × 58)

•Andrew W. Mellon Collection

 

Technical Notes

 

The support is a finely woven twill fabric. The top and bottom tacking edges have been unfolded and add about 6 cm to the painting’s height. The lateral tacking margins have been cropped, but cusping remains along these edges. The thin white ground extends to cover the tacking margins, suggesting that the canvas was pre-primed. Much of the preliminary drawing, done loosely with paint and brush, is visible on the surface, having been incorporated into the painting. The paint is thinly applied, except in the sitter’s upper body, face, and collar, and in the sky around his head, where the paint is thicker and its handling more controlled. Many pentimenti are evident, including changes in the figure’s hat, shoulders, tail of the coat on the viewer’s right, and the sitter’s right leg.

 

Abrasion is found in the ice at the sitter’s feet. Crackle is more pronounced near the head, where the paint is thicker, and is especially pronounced to the right of the skater’s thigh. There are pinpoint losses throughout. The painting was lined prior to 1950.

 

Provenance

 

William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];1 her son Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;2 his widow Elizabeth Pelham-Clin ton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Glinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913], London.

 

Exhibited

 

Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating. Exhibition of Works by the Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James3s Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough.3 American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206. Style, Truth and the Portrait, The Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38. Gilbert Stuart, NGA; RISD, 1967, no. 8. American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, YUAG; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44. American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; NGA, 1981-1982, no. 21.

 

In 1782 Gilbert Stuart, a young painter in London, was “suddenly lifted into fame by the exhibition of a single picture,”4 his full-length of William Grant called Portrait of a Gentleman Skating. (The painting was given its present title of The Skater m 1946.) Stuart devised the theme after an outing on the Serpentine river in Hyde Park with Grant, a young Scottish lawyer, who had come for a sitting for a full-length portrait. According to American artist William Dunlap, who heard the story from miniaturist Charles Fraser,

 

Stuart said that he felt great diffidence in undertaking a whole length; but that there must be a beginning, and a day was accordingly appointed for Mr. Grant to sit. On entering the artist’s room, he regretted the appointment, on account of the excessive coldness of the weather, and observed to Stuart, that the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait. To this the painter assented, and they both sallied out to their morning’s amusement. Stuart said that early practice had made him very expert in skating. His celerity and activity accordingly attracted crowds on the Serpentine river—which was the scene of their sport. His companion, although a well-made and graceful man, was not as active as himself; and there being a crack in the ice, which made it dangerous to continue their amusement, he told Mr. Grant to hold the skirt of his coat, and follow him off the field. They returned to Mr. Stuart’s rooms, where it occurred to him to paint Mr. Grant in the attitude of skating, with the appendage of a winter scene, in the back ground.5

 

The setting for the portrait is the Serpentine, a popular skating spot in London that was created when Kensington Gardens was landscaped during the reign of George II.6 Grant is dressed completely in black, from his hat and the fur-lined lapels of his coat to his breeches, stockings, and shoes. Behind him to the right two skaters sit at the edge of the ice, putting on their skates, while two other men stand under a tree. In the left background two skaters perform the Salutation, also known as the Serpentine Greeting, while others watch.7 The painting offers a balance of black, gray, and off-white, with slight touches of red on the clothing of the background figures. Stuart’s pupil Matthew Harris Jouett later described the portrait as a “fine contrast of Grant in full black to the snow & grey chilly background.”8 The young lawyer William Grant (d. 1821) was the son of Ludovick Grant of Edinburgh.9 Why he chose Stuart to paint his portrait is not known ; perhaps he was a friend or a distant relative of Stuart’s early London patron Alexander Grant, also a Scot.10 Moderately wealthy, Grant was fond of portraits. George Romney painted him in 1781 and again in 1787, and in 1794 he painted “ Mrs. Grant, “ perhaps Grant’s wife Dorothea Dalrymple, whom he married that year. Grant’s children were painted by John Opie (LaSalle University Art Museum, Philadelphia).11 At his death in 1821, Grant left his heirs a large estate called Congalton, in Scotland, as well as stock in the Bank of England and the Royal Bank of Scotland.

 

The portrait, Stuart’s first full-length, showed his ability to invent new compositions within the tradition of English portraiture, in which standing cross-legged poses had been popular for men’s portraits since the 17405. Its success made it possible for Stuart to move from West’s studio into one of his own. Comparisons between the two American artists by contemporaries were inevitable. When Giuseppi Baretti, an Italian-born lexicographer, author, and friend of Sir Joshua Reynolds, saw the painting at West’s before its exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts, he commented, according to Dunlap, “What a charming picture ! Who but the great West could have painted such a one ! “ Later, seeing Stuart at work on the painting, he exclaimed, “What, young man, does Mr. West permit you to touch his pictures?” Stuart replied that it was his own painting. Baretti is supposed to have said, “Why, it is almost as good as Mr. West can paint.”12 The close association of the two men’s work is revealed by an undated chalk drawing by West titled Skateing. West, like Stuart, enjoyed a reputation as a good skater, and in this chalk drawing depicted skaters and spectators on the ice at the Serpentine. A skater in the center foreground turns toward the man behind him, who lies on the ice after a fall. To the left, two figures who perform the Serpentine Greeting are virtually identical to the two skaters in the background of Stuart’s portrait of Grant. To the right is a small figure whose pose seems similar to Grant’s; the figure is very sketchy.

 

A reviewer noted Stuart’s relationship to Benjamin West when Stuart exhibited the painting with three others at the Royal Academy of Arts in 1782.

 

Mr. Stuart is in Partnership with Mr. West; where it is not uncommon for Wits to divert themselves with Applications for Things they do not immediately want; because they are told by Mr. West that Mr. Stuart is the only Portrait Painter in the World; and by Mr. Stuart that no Man has any Pretensions in History Painting but Mr. West. After such Authority what can we say of Mr. Stuart’s Painting.13

 

The portrait enchanted visitors who attended the Academy’s exhibition. Horace Walpole, author of Anecdotes of Painting in England (1762-1771), the first history of British art, wrote “very good” next to the entry for the portrait in his copy of the catalogue.14 Stuart overheard the Duke of Rutland on opening day, urging Sir Joshua Reynolds, “I wish you would go to the exhibition with me, for there is a portrait there which you must see, every body is enchanted with it.” When Sir Joshua asked who painted it, the Duke replied, “A young man by the name of Stuart. “15 Visitors and reviewers praised the portrait’s unusual pose and Stuart’s ability with likeness. Sir John Cullum commented on the novelty of the theme in his letter of 1 May 1782 to Frederick Hervey, Bishop of Derry and Earl of Bristol. “One would have thought that almost every attitude of a single Figure had long been exhausted in this land of portrait painting but one is now exhibited which I recollect not before—it is that of Skating. There is a noble portrait large as life thus exhibited and which produces the most powerful effect.”16 A reviewer for the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser commented on 30 April that “Stuart and Opie, whose merits were not so generally known, have proved themselves able artists” and praised Stuart for his “striking likenesses.”17 Stuart’s ability to capture a likeness was borne out by Charles Fraser’s later comment to artist William Dunlap that the picture attracted so much comment that Stuart was “afraid to go to the academy to meet the looks and answer the inquiries of the multitude. Mr. Grant went one day to the exhibition, dressed as his portrait represented him; the original was immediately recognized, when the crowd followed him so closely that he was compelled to make his retreat, for every one was exclaiming, ‘There he is, there is the gentleman.’”18

 

Opinion was divided on the technique of the painting. One reviewer said that “Mr. Stuart seldom fails of a Likeness; but wants Freedom of Pencil, and Elegance of Taste.”19 However, the author of a letter in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser noted, “ Mr. Stuart… may be said to be an acquisition to the public; his Gentleman seating, No. 190, is reposed, animated and well drawn.”20 And a critic in the London Courant commented on the portrait as Stuart’s first attempt at a full-length. “If we have been informed aright this is the gentleman’s first essay in this branch of the art ; at all events it does honour to his pencil, from the novelty of the design and the neatness of the execution.”21 A commentator in 1795 wrote about Stuart’s early difficulty with a portrait of this size.

 

It is now some years since Stuart the portrait painter … painted a portrait of a Mr. Grant in the action of skating; this portrait was given in so spirited an attitude and with so appropriate a character that when it was exhibited, it established the fame of the artist, of whom his brethren had before that time said he made a tolerable likeness of a face, but as to the figure he could not get below the fifth button.22

 

The combination of the full-length portrait with the act of skating was indeed a novel theme. Stuart appropriately portrayed Grant as a figure skater, the version of the sport popular in England, which emphasized graceful and refined movements, instead of as a Scottish speed skater, which encouraged skill, speed, and competition. Grant wears skates designed for the “small pivots and graceful maneuvers which were essential to the art of figure skating.”23 Robert Jones, in his influential Treatise on Skating (London, 1772), recommended a similar crossedarm pose as “a proper attitude for genteel rolling” (Figure 2).24 Matthew HarrisJouett in 1816 quoted Stuart on “the importance of keeping the figure in its circle of motion, “ giving the example of “his famous skaiting picture of Grant as contrasted with Buckminster Preble who turns his body one way his neck another and his eyes another…. “25

 

The painting is unlike other images of skaters, which belong to the tradition of sporting scenes. They include Irish painter Robert Healy’s Tom Conolly and his Friends Skating (1768, private collection, Ireland), Sir Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker Skating on Duddingston Loch (c. 1784, National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh), Thomas Rowlandson’s watercolor Skaters on the Serpentine of 1784 (National Museum of Wales, Cardiff), and a view by Julius Caesar Ibbetson engraved in 1787 as Winter Amusement; A View in Hyde Park from the Moated Housed Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg’s A Winter Morning, with a Party Skating of 1776 is particularly close to Stuart’s and West’s images in that it shows skating figures similar to those who perform the Serpentine Greeting. And like de Loutherbourg’s scene, Benjamin West’s undated drawing Skateing focuses its action on the popular Serpentine river. In the background is a structure similar to the Cheesecake House, a refreshment lodge that is also seen in the images by Rowlandson and Ibbetson. De Loutherbourg’s scene, which includes portraits of the artist and his wife, the artist’s partner V.M. Picot and others, was the best known of the various images of skaters made before or at the time that Stuart painted his portrait of Grant. It was reproduced by Matthew Boulton’s picture manufactory in Birmingham, England, between 1776 and 1780 by an unusual reproductive process that replicated paintings with their original coloring. In the mid-1780s a cloth merchant and amateur painter named Joseph Booth revived the idea of reproducing the painting by using a “polygraph process.” Numerous color reproductions of de Loutherbourg’s Winter Morning survive.27

 

Art historian William Pressly has proposed an interpretation of The Skater as expressing the theme of melancholy. To Pressly, the “recently revived tradition of the melancholy hero” explains the somber coloration of the painting, the darkly shaded eyes of the skater, and the use of a crossed-arm pose. In this view the painting becomes a self-portrait of Stuart’s own tendency toward melancholy. The snowy setting is appropriate in this theory, since winter was traditionally associated with melancholia.28 One might even suggest that Stuart included himself as the man on the right who stands under a tree. The physiognomy of this spectator, with his long nose and angular chin, closely resembles Stuart’s self-portrait of around 1786. Whether the association of the mood and the season necessarily points to melancholy as the subject of the painting is uncertain, even though the connection of the two was well known at the time and had been developed in verse many years earlier by the English poet James Thomson in his poem “Winter” in The Seasons (1730). “Winter” itself could be the theme, rather than “melancholy.” As Jules Prown has pointed out, “The skater evokes an allegorical image of Winter as one of the Four Seasons. “29 Lines from Thomson’s “Winter” form the caption for a late eighteenth-century English mezzotint titled “Winter,” which shows three warmly dressed figures walking near the Serpentine, where skaters can be seen in the background. “While every work of man is laid at rest, “ they “swoop on sounding skates a thousand different ways” and the “land is madden’d all to joy” (“Winter,” verses 761, 769, 771).30 The allusion to the mood of the season indicates that Stuart had absorbed the highly sophisticated London practice of borrowing from literary works for the subject matter of portraits.

 

Stuart was also absorbing lessons on technique. The portrait is a masterpiece of the late eighteenth-century British style of portraiture, which focuses on the figure, particularly the face, by painting the background with less detail. X-radiography shows that Stuart, when painting Grant’s face, had not yet developed the fully calligraphic brushwork for which he is known in his later paintings. Here he shaped the eyes, nose, mouth, and shadow of the nose by drawing the features with the brush. Later he would not follow the outline of the individual features as closely. Stuart also used more white pigment in the transitional flesh tones than he would in later works. X-radiography suggests, not surprisingly, that Stuart painted the background after completing the figure; the brushstrokes of the clouds mark the outer edges of the hat, face, and shoulders, which were already blocked out and painted. In addition, close examination of the painting reveals changes, or pentimenti, in the hat, shoulders, tail of the coat, and sitter’s right leg, indicating that Stuart did indeed struggle with the challenge inherent in a full-length, a size he rarely agreed to use again in his long career.

 

EGM

 

Notes

 

1.The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke 1956, 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Glinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Glinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

2.According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

3.Royal Academy 1878, unpaginated; Graves 1913, 1:383,3:1275; Graves 1905,71296. For a discussion of the attribution of the portrait in 1878 to Gainsborough, and the Grant family’s research to determine Stuart’s authorship, see Whitley 1932,33-36.

4.Quincy 1883,84, who does not identify the picture.

5.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Fraser heard the story from Stuart. John Gait had by then published his story about Benjamin West as a skater; see Gait 1820, 2:26-31. Gait told how, when West was a young artist in London in the 17605, his skating skills had brought him to the attention of the English aristocracy. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the similarity of the two anecdotes.

6.Hayes 1990, 64.

7.Button 1973, 354.

8.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87; since Jouett never saw the portrait, his description must be a quotation from Stuart.

9.Faculty of Advocates 1944, 90, courtesy of Dr. Louise Yeoman, Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh.

10.Alexander Grant is mentioned in Stuart 1877, 642; see also Stuart 1967,14.

11.Ward and Roberts 1904, 2:63-64. The earlier portrait of Grant by Romney was sold by Georgiana Bordewich, former owner of The Skater, at Christie’s on 22 March 1974 (lot 96) and bought by Léger Galleries; see Léger Galleries 1975, unpaginated, no. 5. Mrs. Bordewich also sold a portrait said to be of Grant by Thomas Hudson (lot 94), 127 by 101.6 cm (50 by 40 inches), and the portrait of his four eldest children, attributed to Opie (lot 95). The portrait of Mrs. Grant remained in Romney’s studio and was sold at Romney’s sale in 1807.

12.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Jouett referred to Baretti’s “mistaking it for Wests best production” when he recorded Stuart’s comments about painting in 1816; see Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87.

13.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

14.Whitley 1932,32.

15.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

16.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, and Pressly 1986, 44, from Childe-Pemberton 1925,1:284.

17.“Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition,” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser, 30 April 1782, 3.

18.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

19.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

20.The letter from the correspondent, identified as “Candid,” was published in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser on 9 May 1782, 2.

21.Quoted in Whitley 1932, 33, from an unidentified issue.

22.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, from an unidentified source.

23.Pearson 1987, 59.

24.Pressly 1986, 48; Pearson 1987, 60, 62, fig. 8.

25.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 86.

26.For three of these paintings see Hayes 1990, 64-66, no. 19, color repro.; and Pearson 1987, 57 fig. 2 and 61 fig. 7.

27.de Loutherbourg 1973, unpaginated, cat. no. 22. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the significance of this image for Stuart’s and West’s works.

28.Pressly 1986, 42-51.

29.Prown 1969, 48.

30.Quoted in Button 1973, 355, fig. 4.

 

References

 

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 30 April: 3.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post. 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 9 May: 2.

•1816—Jouett: 86, 87.

•1834—Dunlap: 1:183-184.

•1846—Lester: 126.

•1877—Stuart: 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (12 January): 50.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (19 January): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (26 January): 91.

•1879—Mason: 187-190.

•1880—MFA: 41, no.268.

•1883—Quincy: 84.

•1926—Park: 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley: 15, 31-36.

•1961—Oswald: 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount: 69-74.

•1969—Prown: 47-48.

•1973—Button: 351-3 62, color cover repro.

•1980—Evans: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding: 50, color repro .51.

•1981—Waterson: 872 repro.

•1981—Williams: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986—Pressly: 42-51, fig.1.

•1986—McLanathan: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1987—Pearson: 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding: 58-59, color repro.

•1990—Crean: 55-62.

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

West Building, Main Floor—Gallery 59

 

•Date: 1782

•Medium: Oil on Canvas

•Dimensions:

oOverall: 245.5 × 147.4 cm (96⅝ × 58 1/16 in.)

oFramed: 274.3 × 177.2 × 9.5 cm (108 × 69¾ × 3¾ in.)

•Credit Line: Andrew W. Mellon Collection

•Accession Number: 1950.18.1

•Artists/Makers

oPainter: Gilbert Stuart, American, 1755-1828

 

Overview

 

In 1775, Gilbert Stuart set sail for London where Benjamin West welcomed the destitute young man into his home. The Skater marks the end of his five-year apprenticeship to West. Stuart’s first effort at full-length portraiture, its originality brought the artist so much notice at the 1782 Royal Academy exhibition that he soon set up his own studio.

 

The unorthodox motif of skating—indeed, any presentation of vigorous movement at all—had absolutely no precedent in Britain’s “Grand Manner” tradition of life-size society portraiture. The painter recalled that when William Grant, from Congalton near Edinburgh, arrived to have his picture painted, the Scottish sitter remarked that, “on account of the excessive coldness of the weather … the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait.” Thus artist and sitter went off to skate on the Serpentine River in Hyde Park. When he returned to West’s studio with Grant, Stuart conceived the idea of portraying his subject on ice skates in a winter landscape, with the twin towers of Westminster Abbey far in the distance.

 

In this innovative design, Grant glides effortlessly forward with arms crossed over his chest in typical eighteenth-century skating form. Except for his folded arms, the figure’s stance derives from an ancient Roman statue, the Apollo Belvedere, a cast of which stood in the corner of West’s studio.

 

Provenance

 

The sitter, William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son, William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter, Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];[1] her son, Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;[2] his widow, Elizabeth Pelham-Clinton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter, Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Clinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913] London; sold 1950 to the NGA.

 

[1]The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke’s Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Peerage, Baronetage and Knightage, Privy Council and Order of Precedence, 101st ed., London, 1956: 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Clinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Clinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

[2]According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA curatorial file), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

 

Associated Names

 

•Clinton, Pelham, Miss

•Grant, William

•Grant, William

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton, Mrs.

•Pelham-Clinton, Elizabeth

 

Exhibition History

 

•1782—Royal Academy, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating

•1878—Exhibition of Works by Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough

•1946—American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206

•1963—Style, Truth, and the Portrait, Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38

•1967—Gilbert Stuart, Portraitist of the Young Republic, 1755-1828, National Gallery of Art; Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design, Providence, 1967, no. 8

•1976—American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44

•1981—American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; National Portrait Gallery, Washington, D.C., 1981-1982, no. 21.

•2001—Great British Paintings from American Collections: Holbein to Hockney, Yale Center for British Art, New Haven; The Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens, San Marino, 2001-2002, no. 35, repro.

•2004—Gilbert Stuart, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; National Gallery of Art (for the National Portrait Gallery), Washington, D.C., 2004-2005, no. 6, repro.

 

Bibliography

 

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (9 May 1782): 2.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (30 April 1782): 3.

•1816—Jouett, Matthew Harris. “Notes Taken by M. H. Jouett while in Boston from Conversations on painting with Gilbert Stuart Esqr.” Manuscript, published in Gilbert Stuart and His Pupils, by John Hill Morgan. New York, 1816: 86, 87.

•1846—Lester, C. Edwards. The Artists of America. New York, 1846: 126.

•1869—Dunlap, William. A History of the Rise and Progress of The Arts of Design in the United States. 2 vols. Reprinted in 3. New York, 1969 (1834): 1:183-184.

•1877—Stuart, Jane. “The Youth of Gilbert Stuart.” Scribner’s Monthly 13, no. 5 (March 1877): 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (January 19, 1878): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (January 26, 1878): 91.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (January 12, 1878): 50.

•1879—Mason, George C. The Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1879: 187-190.

•1880—”Portraits Painted by Stuart...taken from Mason’s Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart.” In Exhibition of Portraits Painted by Gilbert Stuart. Exh. cat. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 1880: 41, no. 268.

•1883—Quincy, Josiah. Figures of the Past from the Leaves of Old Journals. 4th ed. Boston, 1883: 84.

•1926—Park 1926, 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley, William T. Artists and Their Friends in England, 1700-1800. 2 vols. London and Boston, 1928: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley, William T. Gilbert Stuart. Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1932: 15, 31-36.

•1952 Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds., Great Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1952: 138, color repro., as The Skater.

•1956 Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1956: 50, color repro., as The Skater.

•1957—Shapley, Fern Rusk. Comparisons in Art: A Companion to the National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. London, 1957 (reprinted 1959): pl. 91.

•1961—Oswald, Arthur. “Our Ancestors on the Ice.” Country Life 129 (9 February 1961): 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount, Charles Merrill. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1964: 69-74.

•1966—Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds. A Pageant of Painting from the National Gallery of Art. 2 vols. New York, 1966: 2:380, color repro.

•1969—Novak, Barbara. American Painting of the Nineteenth Century: Realism, Idealism, and the American Experience. 2nd ed. New York, 1979: 32, fig. 1.17.

•1969—Prown, Jules David. American Painting, From its Beginnings to the Armory Show. Geneva, 1969: 47-48.

•1970—American Paintings and Sculpture: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1970: 106, repro., as The Skater.

•1973—Button, Dick. “The Art of Skating.” Antiques 103, no. 2 (February 1973): 351-362, color repro. on cover.

•1973—Finley, David Edward. A Standard of Excellence: Andrew W. Mellon Founds the National Gallery of Art at Washington. Washington, 1973: 135.

•1975—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1975: 380, color repro. 381.

•1978—King, Marian. Adventures in Art: National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C. New York, 1978: 54, pl. 31.

•1980—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1980: 234, repro.

•1980—Evans, Dorinda. Benjamin West and His American Students. Exh. cat. National Portrait Gallery, Washington; Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, Philadelphia. Washington, 1980: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1980: 10, no. 6, color repro.

•1981—Waterson, Merlin. “Hissing Along the Polished Ice.” Country Life 169 (2 April 1981): repro. 872.

•1981—Williams, William James. A Heritage of American Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1981: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. Rev. ed. New York, 1984: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986 McLanathan, Richard. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1986: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1986—Pressly, William L. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater: An Essay in Romantic Melancholy.” American Art Journal 18, no. 1, 1986: 42-51, fig. 1.

•1987—Pearson, Andrea G. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater (Portrait of William Grant) and Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker, D.D., Skating on Duddington Loch: A Study of Sources.” Rutgers Art Review 8 (1987): 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. Rev. ed. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1988: 58-59, no. 6, color repro.

•1990—Crean, Hugh R. Gilbert Stuart and the politics of fine arts patronage in Ireland, 1787-1793; A social and cultural study. Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1990: 55-62.

•1992—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 345, repro.

•1992—National Gallery of Art, Washington. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 214, repro.

•1995—Miles, Ellen G. American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century. The Collections of the National Gallery of Art Systematic Catalogue. Washington, D.C., 1995: 162-169, color repro. 165.

•1997—Hughes, Robert. American Visions: The Epic History of Art in America. New York, 1997: 128, color fig. 81.

•1997—Thomson, Duncan. Raeburn: The Art of Sir Henry Raeburn 1756-1823, Exh. cat. Scottish National Portrait Gallery at the Royal Scottish Academy, Edinburgh; National Portrait Gallery, London, 1997-1998, p. 90, no. 61, repro.

•1998—Mandel, Corinne. “Melancholy.” In Encyclopedia of Comparative Iconography: Themes Depicted in Works of Art, edited by Helene E. Roberts. 2 vols. Chicago, 1998: 2:586-588.

•2004—Hand, John Oliver. National Gallery of Art: Master Paintings from the Collection. Washington and New York, 2004: 294-295, no. 240, color repro.

•2011—Gopnik, Adam. Winter: Four Windows on the Season. Toronto, 2011: 142-143, color repro.

•2013—Evans, Dorinda. Gilbert Stuart and the Impact of Manic Depression. Burlington, 2013: 162-164, 168 nn. 36 and 37, fig. 11.

•2016—Rather, Susan. The American School: Artists and Status in the Late Colonial and Early National Era. New Haven, 2016: 171-172, color fig. 125.

  

From American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century:

 

1950.18.1 (1051)

 

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

•1782

•Oil on Canvas, 244.5 × 147.4 (96¼ × 58)

•Andrew W. Mellon Collection

 

Technical Notes

 

The support is a finely woven twill fabric. The top and bottom tacking edges have been unfolded and add about 6 cm to the painting’s height. The lateral tacking margins have been cropped, but cusping remains along these edges. The thin white ground extends to cover the tacking margins, suggesting that the canvas was pre-primed. Much of the preliminary drawing, done loosely with paint and brush, is visible on the surface, having been incorporated into the painting. The paint is thinly applied, except in the sitter’s upper body, face, and collar, and in the sky around his head, where the paint is thicker and its handling more controlled. Many pentimenti are evident, including changes in the figure’s hat, shoulders, tail of the coat on the viewer’s right, and the sitter’s right leg.

 

Abrasion is found in the ice at the sitter’s feet. Crackle is more pronounced near the head, where the paint is thicker, and is especially pronounced to the right of the skater’s thigh. There are pinpoint losses throughout. The painting was lined prior to 1950.

 

Provenance

 

William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];1 her son Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;2 his widow Elizabeth Pelham-Clin ton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Glinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913], London.

 

Exhibited

 

Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating. Exhibition of Works by the Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James3s Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough.3 American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206. Style, Truth and the Portrait, The Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38. Gilbert Stuart, NGA; RISD, 1967, no. 8. American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, YUAG; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44. American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; NGA, 1981-1982, no. 21.

 

In 1782 Gilbert Stuart, a young painter in London, was “suddenly lifted into fame by the exhibition of a single picture,”4 his full-length of William Grant called Portrait of a Gentleman Skating. (The painting was given its present title of The Skater m 1946.) Stuart devised the theme after an outing on the Serpentine river in Hyde Park with Grant, a young Scottish lawyer, who had come for a sitting for a full-length portrait. According to American artist William Dunlap, who heard the story from miniaturist Charles Fraser,

 

Stuart said that he felt great diffidence in undertaking a whole length; but that there must be a beginning, and a day was accordingly appointed for Mr. Grant to sit. On entering the artist’s room, he regretted the appointment, on account of the excessive coldness of the weather, and observed to Stuart, that the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait. To this the painter assented, and they both sallied out to their morning’s amusement. Stuart said that early practice had made him very expert in skating. His celerity and activity accordingly attracted crowds on the Serpentine river—which was the scene of their sport. His companion, although a well-made and graceful man, was not as active as himself; and there being a crack in the ice, which made it dangerous to continue their amusement, he told Mr. Grant to hold the skirt of his coat, and follow him off the field. They returned to Mr. Stuart’s rooms, where it occurred to him to paint Mr. Grant in the attitude of skating, with the appendage of a winter scene, in the back ground.5

 

The setting for the portrait is the Serpentine, a popular skating spot in London that was created when Kensington Gardens was landscaped during the reign of George II.6 Grant is dressed completely in black, from his hat and the fur-lined lapels of his coat to his breeches, stockings, and shoes. Behind him to the right two skaters sit at the edge of the ice, putting on their skates, while two other men stand under a tree. In the left background two skaters perform the Salutation, also known as the Serpentine Greeting, while others watch.7 The painting offers a balance of black, gray, and off-white, with slight touches of red on the clothing of the background figures. Stuart’s pupil Matthew Harris Jouett later described the portrait as a “fine contrast of Grant in full black to the snow & grey chilly background.”8 The young lawyer William Grant (d. 1821) was the son of Ludovick Grant of Edinburgh.9 Why he chose Stuart to paint his portrait is not known ; perhaps he was a friend or a distant relative of Stuart’s early London patron Alexander Grant, also a Scot.10 Moderately wealthy, Grant was fond of portraits. George Romney painted him in 1781 and again in 1787, and in 1794 he painted “ Mrs. Grant, “ perhaps Grant’s wife Dorothea Dalrymple, whom he married that year. Grant’s children were painted by John Opie (LaSalle University Art Museum, Philadelphia).11 At his death in 1821, Grant left his heirs a large estate called Congalton, in Scotland, as well as stock in the Bank of England and the Royal Bank of Scotland.

 

The portrait, Stuart’s first full-length, showed his ability to invent new compositions within the tradition of English portraiture, in which standing cross-legged poses had been popular for men’s portraits since the 17405. Its success made it possible for Stuart to move from West’s studio into one of his own. Comparisons between the two American artists by contemporaries were inevitable. When Giuseppi Baretti, an Italian-born lexicographer, author, and friend of Sir Joshua Reynolds, saw the painting at West’s before its exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts, he commented, according to Dunlap, “What a charming picture ! Who but the great West could have painted such a one ! “ Later, seeing Stuart at work on the painting, he exclaimed, “What, young man, does Mr. West permit you to touch his pictures?” Stuart replied that it was his own painting. Baretti is supposed to have said, “Why, it is almost as good as Mr. West can paint.”12 The close association of the two men’s work is revealed by an undated chalk drawing by West titled Skateing. West, like Stuart, enjoyed a reputation as a good skater, and in this chalk drawing depicted skaters and spectators on the ice at the Serpentine. A skater in the center foreground turns toward the man behind him, who lies on the ice after a fall. To the left, two figures who perform the Serpentine Greeting are virtually identical to the two skaters in the background of Stuart’s portrait of Grant. To the right is a small figure whose pose seems similar to Grant’s; the figure is very sketchy.

 

A reviewer noted Stuart’s relationship to Benjamin West when Stuart exhibited the painting with three others at the Royal Academy of Arts in 1782.

 

Mr. Stuart is in Partnership with Mr. West; where it is not uncommon for Wits to divert themselves with Applications for Things they do not immediately want; because they are told by Mr. West that Mr. Stuart is the only Portrait Painter in the World; and by Mr. Stuart that no Man has any Pretensions in History Painting but Mr. West. After such Authority what can we say of Mr. Stuart’s Painting.13

 

The portrait enchanted visitors who attended the Academy’s exhibition. Horace Walpole, author of Anecdotes of Painting in England (1762-1771), the first history of British art, wrote “very good” next to the entry for the portrait in his copy of the catalogue.14 Stuart overheard the Duke of Rutland on opening day, urging Sir Joshua Reynolds, “I wish you would go to the exhibition with me, for there is a portrait there which you must see, every body is enchanted with it.” When Sir Joshua asked who painted it, the Duke replied, “A young man by the name of Stuart. “15 Visitors and reviewers praised the portrait’s unusual pose and Stuart’s ability with likeness. Sir John Cullum commented on the novelty of the theme in his letter of 1 May 1782 to Frederick Hervey, Bishop of Derry and Earl of Bristol. “One would have thought that almost every attitude of a single Figure had long been exhausted in this land of portrait painting but one is now exhibited which I recollect not before—it is that of Skating. There is a noble portrait large as life thus exhibited and which produces the most powerful effect.”16 A reviewer for the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser commented on 30 April that “Stuart and Opie, whose merits were not so generally known, have proved themselves able artists” and praised Stuart for his “striking likenesses.”17 Stuart’s ability to capture a likeness was borne out by Charles Fraser’s later comment to artist William Dunlap that the picture attracted so much comment that Stuart was “afraid to go to the academy to meet the looks and answer the inquiries of the multitude. Mr. Grant went one day to the exhibition, dressed as his portrait represented him; the original was immediately recognized, when the crowd followed him so closely that he was compelled to make his retreat, for every one was exclaiming, ‘There he is, there is the gentleman.’”18

 

Opinion was divided on the technique of the painting. One reviewer said that “Mr. Stuart seldom fails of a Likeness; but wants Freedom of Pencil, and Elegance of Taste.”19 However, the author of a letter in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser noted, “ Mr. Stuart… may be said to be an acquisition to the public; his Gentleman seating, No. 190, is reposed, animated and well drawn.”20 And a critic in the London Courant commented on the portrait as Stuart’s first attempt at a full-length. “If we have been informed aright this is the gentleman’s first essay in this branch of the art ; at all events it does honour to his pencil, from the novelty of the design and the neatness of the execution.”21 A commentator in 1795 wrote about Stuart’s early difficulty with a portrait of this size.

 

It is now some years since Stuart the portrait painter … painted a portrait of a Mr. Grant in the action of skating; this portrait was given in so spirited an attitude and with so appropriate a character that when it was exhibited, it established the fame of the artist, of whom his brethren had before that time said he made a tolerable likeness of a face, but as to the figure he could not get below the fifth button.22

 

The combination of the full-length portrait with the act of skating was indeed a novel theme. Stuart appropriately portrayed Grant as a figure skater, the version of the sport popular in England, which emphasized graceful and refined movements, instead of as a Scottish speed skater, which encouraged skill, speed, and competition. Grant wears skates designed for the “small pivots and graceful maneuvers which were essential to the art of figure skating.”23 Robert Jones, in his influential Treatise on Skating (London, 1772), recommended a similar crossedarm pose as “a proper attitude for genteel rolling” (Figure 2).24 Matthew HarrisJouett in 1816 quoted Stuart on “the importance of keeping the figure in its circle of motion, “ giving the example of “his famous skaiting picture of Grant as contrasted with Buckminster Preble who turns his body one way his neck another and his eyes another…. “25

 

The painting is unlike other images of skaters, which belong to the tradition of sporting scenes. They include Irish painter Robert Healy’s Tom Conolly and his Friends Skating (1768, private collection, Ireland), Sir Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker Skating on Duddingston Loch (c. 1784, National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh), Thomas Rowlandson’s watercolor Skaters on the Serpentine of 1784 (National Museum of Wales, Cardiff), and a view by Julius Caesar Ibbetson engraved in 1787 as Winter Amusement; A View in Hyde Park from the Moated Housed Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg’s A Winter Morning, with a Party Skating of 1776 is particularly close to Stuart’s and West’s images in that it shows skating figures similar to those who perform the Serpentine Greeting. And like de Loutherbourg’s scene, Benjamin West’s undated drawing Skateing focuses its action on the popular Serpentine river. In the background is a structure similar to the Cheesecake House, a refreshment lodge that is also seen in the images by Rowlandson and Ibbetson. De Loutherbourg’s scene, which includes portraits of the artist and his wife, the artist’s partner V.M. Picot and others, was the best known of the various images of skaters made before or at the time that Stuart painted his portrait of Grant. It was reproduced by Matthew Boulton’s picture manufactory in Birmingham, England, between 1776 and 1780 by an unusual reproductive process that replicated paintings with their original coloring. In the mid-1780s a cloth merchant and amateur painter named Joseph Booth revived the idea of reproducing the painting by using a “polygraph process.” Numerous color reproductions of de Loutherbourg’s Winter Morning survive.27

 

Art historian William Pressly has proposed an interpretation of The Skater as expressing the theme of melancholy. To Pressly, the “recently revived tradition of the melancholy hero” explains the somber coloration of the painting, the darkly shaded eyes of the skater, and the use of a crossed-arm pose. In this view the painting becomes a self-portrait of Stuart’s own tendency toward melancholy. The snowy setting is appropriate in this theory, since winter was traditionally associated with melancholia.28 One might even suggest that Stuart included himself as the man on the right who stands under a tree. The physiognomy of this spectator, with his long nose and angular chin, closely resembles Stuart’s self-portrait of around 1786. Whether the association of the mood and the season necessarily points to melancholy as the subject of the painting is uncertain, even though the connection of the two was well known at the time and had been developed in verse many years earlier by the English poet James Thomson in his poem “Winter” in The Seasons (1730). “Winter” itself could be the theme, rather than “melancholy.” As Jules Prown has pointed out, “The skater evokes an allegorical image of Winter as one of the Four Seasons. “29 Lines from Thomson’s “Winter” form the caption for a late eighteenth-century English mezzotint titled “Winter,” which shows three warmly dressed figures walking near the Serpentine, where skaters can be seen in the background. “While every work of man is laid at rest, “ they “swoop on sounding skates a thousand different ways” and the “land is madden’d all to joy” (“Winter,” verses 761, 769, 771).30 The allusion to the mood of the season indicates that Stuart had absorbed the highly sophisticated London practice of borrowing from literary works for the subject matter of portraits.

 

Stuart was also absorbing lessons on technique. The portrait is a masterpiece of the late eighteenth-century British style of portraiture, which focuses on the figure, particularly the face, by painting the background with less detail. X-radiography shows that Stuart, when painting Grant’s face, had not yet developed the fully calligraphic brushwork for which he is known in his later paintings. Here he shaped the eyes, nose, mouth, and shadow of the nose by drawing the features with the brush. Later he would not follow the outline of the individual features as closely. Stuart also used more white pigment in the transitional flesh tones than he would in later works. X-radiography suggests, not surprisingly, that Stuart painted the background after completing the figure; the brushstrokes of the clouds mark the outer edges of the hat, face, and shoulders, which were already blocked out and painted. In addition, close examination of the painting reveals changes, or pentimenti, in the hat, shoulders, tail of the coat, and sitter’s right leg, indicating that Stuart did indeed struggle with the challenge inherent in a full-length, a size he rarely agreed to use again in his long career.

 

EGM

 

Notes

 

1.The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke 1956, 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Glinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Glinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

2.According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

3.Royal Academy 1878, unpaginated; Graves 1913, 1:383,3:1275; Graves 1905,71296. For a discussion of the attribution of the portrait in 1878 to Gainsborough, and the Grant family’s research to determine Stuart’s authorship, see Whitley 1932,33-36.

4.Quincy 1883,84, who does not identify the picture.

5.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Fraser heard the story from Stuart. John Gait had by then published his story about Benjamin West as a skater; see Gait 1820, 2:26-31. Gait told how, when West was a young artist in London in the 17605, his skating skills had brought him to the attention of the English aristocracy. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the similarity of the two anecdotes.

6.Hayes 1990, 64.

7.Button 1973, 354.

8.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87; since Jouett never saw the portrait, his description must be a quotation from Stuart.

9.Faculty of Advocates 1944, 90, courtesy of Dr. Louise Yeoman, Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh.

10.Alexander Grant is mentioned in Stuart 1877, 642; see also Stuart 1967,14.

11.Ward and Roberts 1904, 2:63-64. The earlier portrait of Grant by Romney was sold by Georgiana Bordewich, former owner of The Skater, at Christie’s on 22 March 1974 (lot 96) and bought by Léger Galleries; see Léger Galleries 1975, unpaginated, no. 5. Mrs. Bordewich also sold a portrait said to be of Grant by Thomas Hudson (lot 94), 127 by 101.6 cm (50 by 40 inches), and the portrait of his four eldest children, attributed to Opie (lot 95). The portrait of Mrs. Grant remained in Romney’s studio and was sold at Romney’s sale in 1807.

12.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Jouett referred to Baretti’s “mistaking it for Wests best production” when he recorded Stuart’s comments about painting in 1816; see Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87.

13.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

14.Whitley 1932,32.

15.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

16.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, and Pressly 1986, 44, from Childe-Pemberton 1925,1:284.

17.“Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition,” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser, 30 April 1782, 3.

18.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

19.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

20.The letter from the correspondent, identified as “Candid,” was published in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser on 9 May 1782, 2.

21.Quoted in Whitley 1932, 33, from an unidentified issue.

22.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, from an unidentified source.

23.Pearson 1987, 59.

24.Pressly 1986, 48; Pearson 1987, 60, 62, fig. 8.

25.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 86.

26.For three of these paintings see Hayes 1990, 64-66, no. 19, color repro.; and Pearson 1987, 57 fig. 2 and 61 fig. 7.

27.de Loutherbourg 1973, unpaginated, cat. no. 22. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the significance of this image for Stuart’s and West’s works.

28.Pressly 1986, 42-51.

29.Prown 1969, 48.

30.Quoted in Button 1973, 355, fig. 4.

 

References

 

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 30 April: 3.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post. 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 9 May: 2.

•1816—Jouett: 86, 87.

•1834—Dunlap: 1:183-184.

•1846—Lester: 126.

•1877—Stuart: 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (12 January): 50.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (19 January): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (26 January): 91.

•1879—Mason: 187-190.

•1880—MFA: 41, no.268.

•1883—Quincy: 84.

•1926—Park: 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley: 15, 31-36.

•1961—Oswald: 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount: 69-74.

•1969—Prown: 47-48.

•1973—Button: 351-3 62, color cover repro.

•1980—Evans: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding: 50, color repro .51.

•1981—Waterson: 872 repro.

•1981—Williams: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986—Pressly: 42-51, fig.1.

•1986—McLanathan: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1987—Pearson: 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding: 58-59, color repro.

•1990—Crean: 55-62.

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

West Building, Main Floor—Gallery 59

 

•Date: 1782

•Medium: Oil on Canvas

•Dimensions:

oOverall: 245.5 × 147.4 cm (96⅝ × 58 1/16 in.)

oFramed: 274.3 × 177.2 × 9.5 cm (108 × 69¾ × 3¾ in.)

•Credit Line: Andrew W. Mellon Collection

•Accession Number: 1950.18.1

•Artists/Makers

oPainter: Gilbert Stuart, American, 1755-1828

 

Overview

 

In 1775, Gilbert Stuart set sail for London where Benjamin West welcomed the destitute young man into his home. The Skater marks the end of his five-year apprenticeship to West. Stuart’s first effort at full-length portraiture, its originality brought the artist so much notice at the 1782 Royal Academy exhibition that he soon set up his own studio.

 

The unorthodox motif of skating—indeed, any presentation of vigorous movement at all—had absolutely no precedent in Britain’s “Grand Manner” tradition of life-size society portraiture. The painter recalled that when William Grant, from Congalton near Edinburgh, arrived to have his picture painted, the Scottish sitter remarked that, “on account of the excessive coldness of the weather … the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait.” Thus artist and sitter went off to skate on the Serpentine River in Hyde Park. When he returned to West’s studio with Grant, Stuart conceived the idea of portraying his subject on ice skates in a winter landscape, with the twin towers of Westminster Abbey far in the distance.

 

In this innovative design, Grant glides effortlessly forward with arms crossed over his chest in typical eighteenth-century skating form. Except for his folded arms, the figure’s stance derives from an ancient Roman statue, the Apollo Belvedere, a cast of which stood in the corner of West’s studio.

 

Provenance

 

The sitter, William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son, William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter, Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];[1] her son, Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;[2] his widow, Elizabeth Pelham-Clinton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter, Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Clinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913] London; sold 1950 to the NGA.

 

[1]The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke’s Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Peerage, Baronetage and Knightage, Privy Council and Order of Precedence, 101st ed., London, 1956: 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Clinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Clinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

[2]According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA curatorial file), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

 

Associated Names

 

•Clinton, Pelham, Miss

•Grant, William

•Grant, William

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton, Mrs.

•Pelham-Clinton, Elizabeth

 

Exhibition History

 

•1782—Royal Academy, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating

•1878—Exhibition of Works by Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough

•1946—American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206

•1963—Style, Truth, and the Portrait, Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38

•1967—Gilbert Stuart, Portraitist of the Young Republic, 1755-1828, National Gallery of Art; Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design, Providence, 1967, no. 8

•1976—American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44

•1981—American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; National Portrait Gallery, Washington, D.C., 1981-1982, no. 21.

•2001—Great British Paintings from American Collections: Holbein to Hockney, Yale Center for British Art, New Haven; The Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens, San Marino, 2001-2002, no. 35, repro.

•2004—Gilbert Stuart, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; National Gallery of Art (for the National Portrait Gallery), Washington, D.C., 2004-2005, no. 6, repro.

 

Bibliography

 

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (9 May 1782): 2.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (30 April 1782): 3.

•1816—Jouett, Matthew Harris. “Notes Taken by M. H. Jouett while in Boston from Conversations on painting with Gilbert Stuart Esqr.” Manuscript, published in Gilbert Stuart and His Pupils, by John Hill Morgan. New York, 1816: 86, 87.

•1846—Lester, C. Edwards. The Artists of America. New York, 1846: 126.

•1869—Dunlap, William. A History of the Rise and Progress of The Arts of Design in the United States. 2 vols. Reprinted in 3. New York, 1969 (1834): 1:183-184.

•1877—Stuart, Jane. “The Youth of Gilbert Stuart.” Scribner’s Monthly 13, no. 5 (March 1877): 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (January 19, 1878): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (January 26, 1878): 91.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (January 12, 1878): 50.

•1879—Mason, George C. The Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1879: 187-190.

•1880—”Portraits Painted by Stuart...taken from Mason’s Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart.” In Exhibition of Portraits Painted by Gilbert Stuart. Exh. cat. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 1880: 41, no. 268.

•1883—Quincy, Josiah. Figures of the Past from the Leaves of Old Journals. 4th ed. Boston, 1883: 84.

•1926—Park 1926, 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley, William T. Artists and Their Friends in England, 1700-1800. 2 vols. London and Boston, 1928: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley, William T. Gilbert Stuart. Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1932: 15, 31-36.

•1952 Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds., Great Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1952: 138, color repro., as The Skater.

•1956 Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1956: 50, color repro., as The Skater.

•1957—Shapley, Fern Rusk. Comparisons in Art: A Companion to the National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. London, 1957 (reprinted 1959): pl. 91.

•1961—Oswald, Arthur. “Our Ancestors on the Ice.” Country Life 129 (9 February 1961): 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount, Charles Merrill. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1964: 69-74.

•1966—Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds. A Pageant of Painting from the National Gallery of Art. 2 vols. New York, 1966: 2:380, color repro.

•1969—Novak, Barbara. American Painting of the Nineteenth Century: Realism, Idealism, and the American Experience. 2nd ed. New York, 1979: 32, fig. 1.17.

•1969—Prown, Jules David. American Painting, From its Beginnings to the Armory Show. Geneva, 1969: 47-48.

•1970—American Paintings and Sculpture: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1970: 106, repro., as The Skater.

•1973—Button, Dick. “The Art of Skating.” Antiques 103, no. 2 (February 1973): 351-362, color repro. on cover.

•1973—Finley, David Edward. A Standard of Excellence: Andrew W. Mellon Founds the National Gallery of Art at Washington. Washington, 1973: 135.

•1975—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1975: 380, color repro. 381.

•1978—King, Marian. Adventures in Art: National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C. New York, 1978: 54, pl. 31.

•1980—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1980: 234, repro.

•1980—Evans, Dorinda. Benjamin West and His American Students. Exh. cat. National Portrait Gallery, Washington; Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, Philadelphia. Washington, 1980: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1980: 10, no. 6, color repro.

•1981—Waterson, Merlin. “Hissing Along the Polished Ice.” Country Life 169 (2 April 1981): repro. 872.

•1981—Williams, William James. A Heritage of American Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1981: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. Rev. ed. New York, 1984: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986 McLanathan, Richard. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1986: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1986—Pressly, William L. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater: An Essay in Romantic Melancholy.” American Art Journal 18, no. 1, 1986: 42-51, fig. 1.

•1987—Pearson, Andrea G. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater (Portrait of William Grant) and Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker, D.D., Skating on Duddington Loch: A Study of Sources.” Rutgers Art Review 8 (1987): 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. Rev. ed. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1988: 58-59, no. 6, color repro.

•1990—Crean, Hugh R. Gilbert Stuart and the politics of fine arts patronage in Ireland, 1787-1793; A social and cultural study. Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1990: 55-62.

•1992—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 345, repro.

•1992—National Gallery of Art, Washington. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 214, repro.

•1995—Miles, Ellen G. American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century. The Collections of the National Gallery of Art Systematic Catalogue. Washington, D.C., 1995: 162-169, color repro. 165.

•1997—Hughes, Robert. American Visions: The Epic History of Art in America. New York, 1997: 128, color fig. 81.

•1997—Thomson, Duncan. Raeburn: The Art of Sir Henry Raeburn 1756-1823, Exh. cat. Scottish National Portrait Gallery at the Royal Scottish Academy, Edinburgh; National Portrait Gallery, London, 1997-1998, p. 90, no. 61, repro.

•1998—Mandel, Corinne. “Melancholy.” In Encyclopedia of Comparative Iconography: Themes Depicted in Works of Art, edited by Helene E. Roberts. 2 vols. Chicago, 1998: 2:586-588.

•2004—Hand, John Oliver. National Gallery of Art: Master Paintings from the Collection. Washington and New York, 2004: 294-295, no. 240, color repro.

•2011—Gopnik, Adam. Winter: Four Windows on the Season. Toronto, 2011: 142-143, color repro.

•2013—Evans, Dorinda. Gilbert Stuart and the Impact of Manic Depression. Burlington, 2013: 162-164, 168 nn. 36 and 37, fig. 11.

•2016—Rather, Susan. The American School: Artists and Status in the Late Colonial and Early National Era. New Haven, 2016: 171-172, color fig. 125.

  

From American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century:

 

1950.18.1 (1051)

 

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

•1782

•Oil on Canvas, 244.5 × 147.4 (96¼ × 58)

•Andrew W. Mellon Collection

 

Technical Notes

 

The support is a finely woven twill fabric. The top and bottom tacking edges have been unfolded and add about 6 cm to the painting’s height. The lateral tacking margins have been cropped, but cusping remains along these edges. The thin white ground extends to cover the tacking margins, suggesting that the canvas was pre-primed. Much of the preliminary drawing, done loosely with paint and brush, is visible on the surface, having been incorporated into the painting. The paint is thinly applied, except in the sitter’s upper body, face, and collar, and in the sky around his head, where the paint is thicker and its handling more controlled. Many pentimenti are evident, including changes in the figure’s hat, shoulders, tail of the coat on the viewer’s right, and the sitter’s right leg.

 

Abrasion is found in the ice at the sitter’s feet. Crackle is more pronounced near the head, where the paint is thicker, and is especially pronounced to the right of the skater’s thigh. There are pinpoint losses throughout. The painting was lined prior to 1950.

 

Provenance

 

William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];1 her son Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;2 his widow Elizabeth Pelham-Clin ton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Glinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913], London.

 

Exhibited

 

Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating. Exhibition of Works by the Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James3s Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough.3 American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206. Style, Truth and the Portrait, The Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38. Gilbert Stuart, NGA; RISD, 1967, no. 8. American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, YUAG; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44. American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; NGA, 1981-1982, no. 21.

 

In 1782 Gilbert Stuart, a young painter in London, was “suddenly lifted into fame by the exhibition of a single picture,”4 his full-length of William Grant called Portrait of a Gentleman Skating. (The painting was given its present title of The Skater m 1946.) Stuart devised the theme after an outing on the Serpentine river in Hyde Park with Grant, a young Scottish lawyer, who had come for a sitting for a full-length portrait. According to American artist William Dunlap, who heard the story from miniaturist Charles Fraser,

 

Stuart said that he felt great diffidence in undertaking a whole length; but that there must be a beginning, and a day was accordingly appointed for Mr. Grant to sit. On entering the artist’s room, he regretted the appointment, on account of the excessive coldness of the weather, and observed to Stuart, that the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait. To this the painter assented, and they both sallied out to their morning’s amusement. Stuart said that early practice had made him very expert in skating. His celerity and activity accordingly attracted crowds on the Serpentine river—which was the scene of their sport. His companion, although a well-made and graceful man, was not as active as himself; and there being a crack in the ice, which made it dangerous to continue their amusement, he told Mr. Grant to hold the skirt of his coat, and follow him off the field. They returned to Mr. Stuart’s rooms, where it occurred to him to paint Mr. Grant in the attitude of skating, with the appendage of a winter scene, in the back ground.5

 

The setting for the portrait is the Serpentine, a popular skating spot in London that was created when Kensington Gardens was landscaped during the reign of George II.6 Grant is dressed completely in black, from his hat and the fur-lined lapels of his coat to his breeches, stockings, and shoes. Behind him to the right two skaters sit at the edge of the ice, putting on their skates, while two other men stand under a tree. In the left background two skaters perform the Salutation, also known as the Serpentine Greeting, while others watch.7 The painting offers a balance of black, gray, and off-white, with slight touches of red on the clothing of the background figures. Stuart’s pupil Matthew Harris Jouett later described the portrait as a “fine contrast of Grant in full black to the snow & grey chilly background.”8 The young lawyer William Grant (d. 1821) was the son of Ludovick Grant of Edinburgh.9 Why he chose Stuart to paint his portrait is not known ; perhaps he was a friend or a distant relative of Stuart’s early London patron Alexander Grant, also a Scot.10 Moderately wealthy, Grant was fond of portraits. George Romney painted him in 1781 and again in 1787, and in 1794 he painted “ Mrs. Grant, “ perhaps Grant’s wife Dorothea Dalrymple, whom he married that year. Grant’s children were painted by John Opie (LaSalle University Art Museum, Philadelphia).11 At his death in 1821, Grant left his heirs a large estate called Congalton, in Scotland, as well as stock in the Bank of England and the Royal Bank of Scotland.

 

The portrait, Stuart’s first full-length, showed his ability to invent new compositions within the tradition of English portraiture, in which standing cross-legged poses had been popular for men’s portraits since the 17405. Its success made it possible for Stuart to move from West’s studio into one of his own. Comparisons between the two American artists by contemporaries were inevitable. When Giuseppi Baretti, an Italian-born lexicographer, author, and friend of Sir Joshua Reynolds, saw the painting at West’s before its exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts, he commented, according to Dunlap, “What a charming picture ! Who but the great West could have painted such a one ! “ Later, seeing Stuart at work on the painting, he exclaimed, “What, young man, does Mr. West permit you to touch his pictures?” Stuart replied that it was his own painting. Baretti is supposed to have said, “Why, it is almost as good as Mr. West can paint.”12 The close association of the two men’s work is revealed by an undated chalk drawing by West titled Skateing. West, like Stuart, enjoyed a reputation as a good skater, and in this chalk drawing depicted skaters and spectators on the ice at the Serpentine. A skater in the center foreground turns toward the man behind him, who lies on the ice after a fall. To the left, two figures who perform the Serpentine Greeting are virtually identical to the two skaters in the background of Stuart’s portrait of Grant. To the right is a small figure whose pose seems similar to Grant’s; the figure is very sketchy.

 

A reviewer noted Stuart’s relationship to Benjamin West when Stuart exhibited the painting with three others at the Royal Academy of Arts in 1782.

 

Mr. Stuart is in Partnership with Mr. West; where it is not uncommon for Wits to divert themselves with Applications for Things they do not immediately want; because they are told by Mr. West that Mr. Stuart is the only Portrait Painter in the World; and by Mr. Stuart that no Man has any Pretensions in History Painting but Mr. West. After such Authority what can we say of Mr. Stuart’s Painting.13

 

The portrait enchanted visitors who attended the Academy’s exhibition. Horace Walpole, author of Anecdotes of Painting in England (1762-1771), the first history of British art, wrote “very good” next to the entry for the portrait in his copy of the catalogue.14 Stuart overheard the Duke of Rutland on opening day, urging Sir Joshua Reynolds, “I wish you would go to the exhibition with me, for there is a portrait there which you must see, every body is enchanted with it.” When Sir Joshua asked who painted it, the Duke replied, “A young man by the name of Stuart. “15 Visitors and reviewers praised the portrait’s unusual pose and Stuart’s ability with likeness. Sir John Cullum commented on the novelty of the theme in his letter of 1 May 1782 to Frederick Hervey, Bishop of Derry and Earl of Bristol. “One would have thought that almost every attitude of a single Figure had long been exhausted in this land of portrait painting but one is now exhibited which I recollect not before—it is that of Skating. There is a noble portrait large as life thus exhibited and which produces the most powerful effect.”16 A reviewer for the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser commented on 30 April that “Stuart and Opie, whose merits were not so generally known, have proved themselves able artists” and praised Stuart for his “striking likenesses.”17 Stuart’s ability to capture a likeness was borne out by Charles Fraser’s later comment to artist William Dunlap that the picture attracted so much comment that Stuart was “afraid to go to the academy to meet the looks and answer the inquiries of the multitude. Mr. Grant went one day to the exhibition, dressed as his portrait represented him; the original was immediately recognized, when the crowd followed him so closely that he was compelled to make his retreat, for every one was exclaiming, ‘There he is, there is the gentleman.’”18

 

Opinion was divided on the technique of the painting. One reviewer said that “Mr. Stuart seldom fails of a Likeness; but wants Freedom of Pencil, and Elegance of Taste.”19 However, the author of a letter in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser noted, “ Mr. Stuart… may be said to be an acquisition to the public; his Gentleman seating, No. 190, is reposed, animated and well drawn.”20 And a critic in the London Courant commented on the portrait as Stuart’s first attempt at a full-length. “If we have been informed aright this is the gentleman’s first essay in this branch of the art ; at all events it does honour to his pencil, from the novelty of the design and the neatness of the execution.”21 A commentator in 1795 wrote about Stuart’s early difficulty with a portrait of this size.

 

It is now some years since Stuart the portrait painter … painted a portrait of a Mr. Grant in the action of skating; this portrait was given in so spirited an attitude and with so appropriate a character that when it was exhibited, it established the fame of the artist, of whom his brethren had before that time said he made a tolerable likeness of a face, but as to the figure he could not get below the fifth button.22

 

The combination of the full-length portrait with the act of skating was indeed a novel theme. Stuart appropriately portrayed Grant as a figure skater, the version of the sport popular in England, which emphasized graceful and refined movements, instead of as a Scottish speed skater, which encouraged skill, speed, and competition. Grant wears skates designed for the “small pivots and graceful maneuvers which were essential to the art of figure skating.”23 Robert Jones, in his influential Treatise on Skating (London, 1772), recommended a similar crossedarm pose as “a proper attitude for genteel rolling” (Figure 2).24 Matthew HarrisJouett in 1816 quoted Stuart on “the importance of keeping the figure in its circle of motion, “ giving the example of “his famous skaiting picture of Grant as contrasted with Buckminster Preble who turns his body one way his neck another and his eyes another…. “25

 

The painting is unlike other images of skaters, which belong to the tradition of sporting scenes. They include Irish painter Robert Healy’s Tom Conolly and his Friends Skating (1768, private collection, Ireland), Sir Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker Skating on Duddingston Loch (c. 1784, National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh), Thomas Rowlandson’s watercolor Skaters on the Serpentine of 1784 (National Museum of Wales, Cardiff), and a view by Julius Caesar Ibbetson engraved in 1787 as Winter Amusement; A View in Hyde Park from the Moated Housed Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg’s A Winter Morning, with a Party Skating of 1776 is particularly close to Stuart’s and West’s images in that it shows skating figures similar to those who perform the Serpentine Greeting. And like de Loutherbourg’s scene, Benjamin West’s undated drawing Skateing focuses its action on the popular Serpentine river. In the background is a structure similar to the Cheesecake House, a refreshment lodge that is also seen in the images by Rowlandson and Ibbetson. De Loutherbourg’s scene, which includes portraits of the artist and his wife, the artist’s partner V.M. Picot and others, was the best known of the various images of skaters made before or at the time that Stuart painted his portrait of Grant. It was reproduced by Matthew Boulton’s picture manufactory in Birmingham, England, between 1776 and 1780 by an unusual reproductive process that replicated paintings with their original coloring. In the mid-1780s a cloth merchant and amateur painter named Joseph Booth revived the idea of reproducing the painting by using a “polygraph process.” Numerous color reproductions of de Loutherbourg’s Winter Morning survive.27

 

Art historian William Pressly has proposed an interpretation of The Skater as expressing the theme of melancholy. To Pressly, the “recently revived tradition of the melancholy hero” explains the somber coloration of the painting, the darkly shaded eyes of the skater, and the use of a crossed-arm pose. In this view the painting becomes a self-portrait of Stuart’s own tendency toward melancholy. The snowy setting is appropriate in this theory, since winter was traditionally associated with melancholia.28 One might even suggest that Stuart included himself as the man on the right who stands under a tree. The physiognomy of this spectator, with his long nose and angular chin, closely resembles Stuart’s self-portrait of around 1786. Whether the association of the mood and the season necessarily points to melancholy as the subject of the painting is uncertain, even though the connection of the two was well known at the time and had been developed in verse many years earlier by the English poet James Thomson in his poem “Winter” in The Seasons (1730). “Winter” itself could be the theme, rather than “melancholy.” As Jules Prown has pointed out, “The skater evokes an allegorical image of Winter as one of the Four Seasons. “29 Lines from Thomson’s “Winter” form the caption for a late eighteenth-century English mezzotint titled “Winter,” which shows three warmly dressed figures walking near the Serpentine, where skaters can be seen in the background. “While every work of man is laid at rest, “ they “swoop on sounding skates a thousand different ways” and the “land is madden’d all to joy” (“Winter,” verses 761, 769, 771).30 The allusion to the mood of the season indicates that Stuart had absorbed the highly sophisticated London practice of borrowing from literary works for the subject matter of portraits.

 

Stuart was also absorbing lessons on technique. The portrait is a masterpiece of the late eighteenth-century British style of portraiture, which focuses on the figure, particularly the face, by painting the background with less detail. X-radiography shows that Stuart, when painting Grant’s face, had not yet developed the fully calligraphic brushwork for which he is known in his later paintings. Here he shaped the eyes, nose, mouth, and shadow of the nose by drawing the features with the brush. Later he would not follow the outline of the individual features as closely. Stuart also used more white pigment in the transitional flesh tones than he would in later works. X-radiography suggests, not surprisingly, that Stuart painted the background after completing the figure; the brushstrokes of the clouds mark the outer edges of the hat, face, and shoulders, which were already blocked out and painted. In addition, close examination of the painting reveals changes, or pentimenti, in the hat, shoulders, tail of the coat, and sitter’s right leg, indicating that Stuart did indeed struggle with the challenge inherent in a full-length, a size he rarely agreed to use again in his long career.

 

EGM

 

Notes

 

1.The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke 1956, 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Glinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Glinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

2.According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

3.Royal Academy 1878, unpaginated; Graves 1913, 1:383,3:1275; Graves 1905,71296. For a discussion of the attribution of the portrait in 1878 to Gainsborough, and the Grant family’s research to determine Stuart’s authorship, see Whitley 1932,33-36.

4.Quincy 1883,84, who does not identify the picture.

5.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Fraser heard the story from Stuart. John Gait had by then published his story about Benjamin West as a skater; see Gait 1820, 2:26-31. Gait told how, when West was a young artist in London in the 17605, his skating skills had brought him to the attention of the English aristocracy. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the similarity of the two anecdotes.

6.Hayes 1990, 64.

7.Button 1973, 354.

8.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87; since Jouett never saw the portrait, his description must be a quotation from Stuart.

9.Faculty of Advocates 1944, 90, courtesy of Dr. Louise Yeoman, Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh.

10.Alexander Grant is mentioned in Stuart 1877, 642; see also Stuart 1967,14.

11.Ward and Roberts 1904, 2:63-64. The earlier portrait of Grant by Romney was sold by Georgiana Bordewich, former owner of The Skater, at Christie’s on 22 March 1974 (lot 96) and bought by Léger Galleries; see Léger Galleries 1975, unpaginated, no. 5. Mrs. Bordewich also sold a portrait said to be of Grant by Thomas Hudson (lot 94), 127 by 101.6 cm (50 by 40 inches), and the portrait of his four eldest children, attributed to Opie (lot 95). The portrait of Mrs. Grant remained in Romney’s studio and was sold at Romney’s sale in 1807.

12.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Jouett referred to Baretti’s “mistaking it for Wests best production” when he recorded Stuart’s comments about painting in 1816; see Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87.

13.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

14.Whitley 1932,32.

15.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

16.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, and Pressly 1986, 44, from Childe-Pemberton 1925,1:284.

17.“Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition,” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser, 30 April 1782, 3.

18.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

19.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

20.The letter from the correspondent, identified as “Candid,” was published in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser on 9 May 1782, 2.

21.Quoted in Whitley 1932, 33, from an unidentified issue.

22.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, from an unidentified source.

23.Pearson 1987, 59.

24.Pressly 1986, 48; Pearson 1987, 60, 62, fig. 8.

25.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 86.

26.For three of these paintings see Hayes 1990, 64-66, no. 19, color repro.; and Pearson 1987, 57 fig. 2 and 61 fig. 7.

27.de Loutherbourg 1973, unpaginated, cat. no. 22. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the significance of this image for Stuart’s and West’s works.

28.Pressly 1986, 42-51.

29.Prown 1969, 48.

30.Quoted in Button 1973, 355, fig. 4.

 

References

 

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 30 April: 3.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post. 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 9 May: 2.

•1816—Jouett: 86, 87.

•1834—Dunlap: 1:183-184.

•1846—Lester: 126.

•1877—Stuart: 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (12 January): 50.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (19 January): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (26 January): 91.

•1879—Mason: 187-190.

•1880—MFA: 41, no.268.

•1883—Quincy: 84.

•1926—Park: 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley: 15, 31-36.

•1961—Oswald: 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount: 69-74.

•1969—Prown: 47-48.

•1973—Button: 351-3 62, color cover repro.

•1980—Evans: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding: 50, color repro .51.

•1981—Waterson: 872 repro.

•1981—Williams: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986—Pressly: 42-51, fig.1.

•1986—McLanathan: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1987—Pearson: 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding: 58-59, color repro.

•1990—Crean: 55-62.

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

West Building, Main Floor—Gallery 59

 

•Date: 1782

•Medium: Oil on Canvas

•Dimensions:

oOverall: 245.5 × 147.4 cm (96⅝ × 58 1/16 in.)

oFramed: 274.3 × 177.2 × 9.5 cm (108 × 69¾ × 3¾ in.)

•Credit Line: Andrew W. Mellon Collection

•Accession Number: 1950.18.1

•Artists/Makers

oPainter: Gilbert Stuart, American, 1755-1828

 

Overview

 

In 1775, Gilbert Stuart set sail for London where Benjamin West welcomed the destitute young man into his home. The Skater marks the end of his five-year apprenticeship to West. Stuart’s first effort at full-length portraiture, its originality brought the artist so much notice at the 1782 Royal Academy exhibition that he soon set up his own studio.

 

The unorthodox motif of skating—indeed, any presentation of vigorous movement at all—had absolutely no precedent in Britain’s “Grand Manner” tradition of life-size society portraiture. The painter recalled that when William Grant, from Congalton near Edinburgh, arrived to have his picture painted, the Scottish sitter remarked that, “on account of the excessive coldness of the weather … the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait.” Thus artist and sitter went off to skate on the Serpentine River in Hyde Park. When he returned to West’s studio with Grant, Stuart conceived the idea of portraying his subject on ice skates in a winter landscape, with the twin towers of Westminster Abbey far in the distance.

 

In this innovative design, Grant glides effortlessly forward with arms crossed over his chest in typical eighteenth-century skating form. Except for his folded arms, the figure’s stance derives from an ancient Roman statue, the Apollo Belvedere, a cast of which stood in the corner of West’s studio.

 

Provenance

 

The sitter, William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son, William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter, Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];[1] her son, Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;[2] his widow, Elizabeth Pelham-Clinton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter, Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Clinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913] London; sold 1950 to the NGA.

 

[1]The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke’s Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Peerage, Baronetage and Knightage, Privy Council and Order of Precedence, 101st ed., London, 1956: 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Clinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Clinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

[2]According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA curatorial file), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

 

Associated Names

 

•Clinton, Pelham, Miss

•Grant, William

•Grant, William

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton, Mrs.

•Pelham-Clinton, Elizabeth

 

Exhibition History

 

•1782—Royal Academy, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating

•1878—Exhibition of Works by Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough

•1946—American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206

•1963—Style, Truth, and the Portrait, Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38

•1967—Gilbert Stuart, Portraitist of the Young Republic, 1755-1828, National Gallery of Art; Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design, Providence, 1967, no. 8

•1976—American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44

•1981—American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; National Portrait Gallery, Washington, D.C., 1981-1982, no. 21.

•2001—Great British Paintings from American Collections: Holbein to Hockney, Yale Center for British Art, New Haven; The Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens, San Marino, 2001-2002, no. 35, repro.

•2004—Gilbert Stuart, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; National Gallery of Art (for the National Portrait Gallery), Washington, D.C., 2004-2005, no. 6, repro.

 

Bibliography

 

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (9 May 1782): 2.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (30 April 1782): 3.

•1816—Jouett, Matthew Harris. “Notes Taken by M. H. Jouett while in Boston from Conversations on painting with Gilbert Stuart Esqr.” Manuscript, published in Gilbert Stuart and His Pupils, by John Hill Morgan. New York, 1816: 86, 87.

•1846—Lester, C. Edwards. The Artists of America. New York, 1846: 126.

•1869—Dunlap, William. A History of the Rise and Progress of The Arts of Design in the United States. 2 vols. Reprinted in 3. New York, 1969 (1834): 1:183-184.

•1877—Stuart, Jane. “The Youth of Gilbert Stuart.” Scribner’s Monthly 13, no. 5 (March 1877): 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (January 19, 1878): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (January 26, 1878): 91.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (January 12, 1878): 50.

•1879—Mason, George C. The Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1879: 187-190.

•1880—”Portraits Painted by Stuart...taken from Mason’s Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart.” In Exhibition of Portraits Painted by Gilbert Stuart. Exh. cat. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 1880: 41, no. 268.

•1883—Quincy, Josiah. Figures of the Past from the Leaves of Old Journals. 4th ed. Boston, 1883: 84.

•1926—Park 1926, 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley, William T. Artists and Their Friends in England, 1700-1800. 2 vols. London and Boston, 1928: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley, William T. Gilbert Stuart. Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1932: 15, 31-36.

•1952 Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds., Great Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1952: 138, color repro., as The Skater.

•1956 Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1956: 50, color repro., as The Skater.

•1957—Shapley, Fern Rusk. Comparisons in Art: A Companion to the National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. London, 1957 (reprinted 1959): pl. 91.

•1961—Oswald, Arthur. “Our Ancestors on the Ice.” Country Life 129 (9 February 1961): 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount, Charles Merrill. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1964: 69-74.

•1966—Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds. A Pageant of Painting from the National Gallery of Art. 2 vols. New York, 1966: 2:380, color repro.

•1969—Novak, Barbara. American Painting of the Nineteenth Century: Realism, Idealism, and the American Experience. 2nd ed. New York, 1979: 32, fig. 1.17.

•1969—Prown, Jules David. American Painting, From its Beginnings to the Armory Show. Geneva, 1969: 47-48.

•1970—American Paintings and Sculpture: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1970: 106, repro., as The Skater.

•1973—Button, Dick. “The Art of Skating.” Antiques 103, no. 2 (February 1973): 351-362, color repro. on cover.

•1973—Finley, David Edward. A Standard of Excellence: Andrew W. Mellon Founds the National Gallery of Art at Washington. Washington, 1973: 135.

•1975—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1975: 380, color repro. 381.

•1978—King, Marian. Adventures in Art: National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C. New York, 1978: 54, pl. 31.

•1980—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1980: 234, repro.

•1980—Evans, Dorinda. Benjamin West and His American Students. Exh. cat. National Portrait Gallery, Washington; Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, Philadelphia. Washington, 1980: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1980: 10, no. 6, color repro.

•1981—Waterson, Merlin. “Hissing Along the Polished Ice.” Country Life 169 (2 April 1981): repro. 872.

•1981—Williams, William James. A Heritage of American Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1981: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. Rev. ed. New York, 1984: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986 McLanathan, Richard. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1986: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1986—Pressly, William L. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater: An Essay in Romantic Melancholy.” American Art Journal 18, no. 1, 1986: 42-51, fig. 1.

•1987—Pearson, Andrea G. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater (Portrait of William Grant) and Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker, D.D., Skating on Duddington Loch: A Study of Sources.” Rutgers Art Review 8 (1987): 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. Rev. ed. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1988: 58-59, no. 6, color repro.

•1990—Crean, Hugh R. Gilbert Stuart and the politics of fine arts patronage in Ireland, 1787-1793; A social and cultural study. Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1990: 55-62.

•1992—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 345, repro.

•1992—National Gallery of Art, Washington. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 214, repro.

•1995—Miles, Ellen G. American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century. The Collections of the National Gallery of Art Systematic Catalogue. Washington, D.C., 1995: 162-169, color repro. 165.

•1997—Hughes, Robert. American Visions: The Epic History of Art in America. New York, 1997: 128, color fig. 81.

•1997—Thomson, Duncan. Raeburn: The Art of Sir Henry Raeburn 1756-1823, Exh. cat. Scottish National Portrait Gallery at the Royal Scottish Academy, Edinburgh; National Portrait Gallery, London, 1997-1998, p. 90, no. 61, repro.

•1998—Mandel, Corinne. “Melancholy.” In Encyclopedia of Comparative Iconography: Themes Depicted in Works of Art, edited by Helene E. Roberts. 2 vols. Chicago, 1998: 2:586-588.

•2004—Hand, John Oliver. National Gallery of Art: Master Paintings from the Collection. Washington and New York, 2004: 294-295, no. 240, color repro.

•2011—Gopnik, Adam. Winter: Four Windows on the Season. Toronto, 2011: 142-143, color repro.

•2013—Evans, Dorinda. Gilbert Stuart and the Impact of Manic Depression. Burlington, 2013: 162-164, 168 nn. 36 and 37, fig. 11.

•2016—Rather, Susan. The American School: Artists and Status in the Late Colonial and Early National Era. New Haven, 2016: 171-172, color fig. 125.

  

From American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century:

 

1950.18.1 (1051)

 

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

•1782

•Oil on Canvas, 244.5 × 147.4 (96¼ × 58)

•Andrew W. Mellon Collection

 

Technical Notes

 

The support is a finely woven twill fabric. The top and bottom tacking edges have been unfolded and add about 6 cm to the painting’s height. The lateral tacking margins have been cropped, but cusping remains along these edges. The thin white ground extends to cover the tacking margins, suggesting that the canvas was pre-primed. Much of the preliminary drawing, done loosely with paint and brush, is visible on the surface, having been incorporated into the painting. The paint is thinly applied, except in the sitter’s upper body, face, and collar, and in the sky around his head, where the paint is thicker and its handling more controlled. Many pentimenti are evident, including changes in the figure’s hat, shoulders, tail of the coat on the viewer’s right, and the sitter’s right leg.

 

Abrasion is found in the ice at the sitter’s feet. Crackle is more pronounced near the head, where the paint is thicker, and is especially pronounced to the right of the skater’s thigh. There are pinpoint losses throughout. The painting was lined prior to 1950.

 

Provenance

 

William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];1 her son Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;2 his widow Elizabeth Pelham-Clin ton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Glinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913], London.

 

Exhibited

 

Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating. Exhibition of Works by the Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James3s Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough.3 American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206. Style, Truth and the Portrait, The Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38. Gilbert Stuart, NGA; RISD, 1967, no. 8. American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, YUAG; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44. American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; NGA, 1981-1982, no. 21.

 

In 1782 Gilbert Stuart, a young painter in London, was “suddenly lifted into fame by the exhibition of a single picture,”4 his full-length of William Grant called Portrait of a Gentleman Skating. (The painting was given its present title of The Skater m 1946.) Stuart devised the theme after an outing on the Serpentine river in Hyde Park with Grant, a young Scottish lawyer, who had come for a sitting for a full-length portrait. According to American artist William Dunlap, who heard the story from miniaturist Charles Fraser,

 

Stuart said that he felt great diffidence in undertaking a whole length; but that there must be a beginning, and a day was accordingly appointed for Mr. Grant to sit. On entering the artist’s room, he regretted the appointment, on account of the excessive coldness of the weather, and observed to Stuart, that the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait. To this the painter assented, and they both sallied out to their morning’s amusement. Stuart said that early practice had made him very expert in skating. His celerity and activity accordingly attracted crowds on the Serpentine river—which was the scene of their sport. His companion, although a well-made and graceful man, was not as active as himself; and there being a crack in the ice, which made it dangerous to continue their amusement, he told Mr. Grant to hold the skirt of his coat, and follow him off the field. They returned to Mr. Stuart’s rooms, where it occurred to him to paint Mr. Grant in the attitude of skating, with the appendage of a winter scene, in the back ground.5

 

The setting for the portrait is the Serpentine, a popular skating spot in London that was created when Kensington Gardens was landscaped during the reign of George II.6 Grant is dressed completely in black, from his hat and the fur-lined lapels of his coat to his breeches, stockings, and shoes. Behind him to the right two skaters sit at the edge of the ice, putting on their skates, while two other men stand under a tree. In the left background two skaters perform the Salutation, also known as the Serpentine Greeting, while others watch.7 The painting offers a balance of black, gray, and off-white, with slight touches of red on the clothing of the background figures. Stuart’s pupil Matthew Harris Jouett later described the portrait as a “fine contrast of Grant in full black to the snow & grey chilly background.”8 The young lawyer William Grant (d. 1821) was the son of Ludovick Grant of Edinburgh.9 Why he chose Stuart to paint his portrait is not known ; perhaps he was a friend or a distant relative of Stuart’s early London patron Alexander Grant, also a Scot.10 Moderately wealthy, Grant was fond of portraits. George Romney painted him in 1781 and again in 1787, and in 1794 he painted “ Mrs. Grant, “ perhaps Grant’s wife Dorothea Dalrymple, whom he married that year. Grant’s children were painted by John Opie (LaSalle University Art Museum, Philadelphia).11 At his death in 1821, Grant left his heirs a large estate called Congalton, in Scotland, as well as stock in the Bank of England and the Royal Bank of Scotland.

 

The portrait, Stuart’s first full-length, showed his ability to invent new compositions within the tradition of English portraiture, in which standing cross-legged poses had been popular for men’s portraits since the 17405. Its success made it possible for Stuart to move from West’s studio into one of his own. Comparisons between the two American artists by contemporaries were inevitable. When Giuseppi Baretti, an Italian-born lexicographer, author, and friend of Sir Joshua Reynolds, saw the painting at West’s before its exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts, he commented, according to Dunlap, “What a charming picture ! Who but the great West could have painted such a one ! “ Later, seeing Stuart at work on the painting, he exclaimed, “What, young man, does Mr. West permit you to touch his pictures?” Stuart replied that it was his own painting. Baretti is supposed to have said, “Why, it is almost as good as Mr. West can paint.”12 The close association of the two men’s work is revealed by an undated chalk drawing by West titled Skateing. West, like Stuart, enjoyed a reputation as a good skater, and in this chalk drawing depicted skaters and spectators on the ice at the Serpentine. A skater in the center foreground turns toward the man behind him, who lies on the ice after a fall. To the left, two figures who perform the Serpentine Greeting are virtually identical to the two skaters in the background of Stuart’s portrait of Grant. To the right is a small figure whose pose seems similar to Grant’s; the figure is very sketchy.

 

A reviewer noted Stuart’s relationship to Benjamin West when Stuart exhibited the painting with three others at the Royal Academy of Arts in 1782.

 

Mr. Stuart is in Partnership with Mr. West; where it is not uncommon for Wits to divert themselves with Applications for Things they do not immediately want; because they are told by Mr. West that Mr. Stuart is the only Portrait Painter in the World; and by Mr. Stuart that no Man has any Pretensions in History Painting but Mr. West. After such Authority what can we say of Mr. Stuart’s Painting.13

 

The portrait enchanted visitors who attended the Academy’s exhibition. Horace Walpole, author of Anecdotes of Painting in England (1762-1771), the first history of British art, wrote “very good” next to the entry for the portrait in his copy of the catalogue.14 Stuart overheard the Duke of Rutland on opening day, urging Sir Joshua Reynolds, “I wish you would go to the exhibition with me, for there is a portrait there which you must see, every body is enchanted with it.” When Sir Joshua asked who painted it, the Duke replied, “A young man by the name of Stuart. “15 Visitors and reviewers praised the portrait’s unusual pose and Stuart’s ability with likeness. Sir John Cullum commented on the novelty of the theme in his letter of 1 May 1782 to Frederick Hervey, Bishop of Derry and Earl of Bristol. “One would have thought that almost every attitude of a single Figure had long been exhausted in this land of portrait painting but one is now exhibited which I recollect not before—it is that of Skating. There is a noble portrait large as life thus exhibited and which produces the most powerful effect.”16 A reviewer for the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser commented on 30 April that “Stuart and Opie, whose merits were not so generally known, have proved themselves able artists” and praised Stuart for his “striking likenesses.”17 Stuart’s ability to capture a likeness was borne out by Charles Fraser’s later comment to artist William Dunlap that the picture attracted so much comment that Stuart was “afraid to go to the academy to meet the looks and answer the inquiries of the multitude. Mr. Grant went one day to the exhibition, dressed as his portrait represented him; the original was immediately recognized, when the crowd followed him so closely that he was compelled to make his retreat, for every one was exclaiming, ‘There he is, there is the gentleman.’”18

 

Opinion was divided on the technique of the painting. One reviewer said that “Mr. Stuart seldom fails of a Likeness; but wants Freedom of Pencil, and Elegance of Taste.”19 However, the author of a letter in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser noted, “ Mr. Stuart… may be said to be an acquisition to the public; his Gentleman seating, No. 190, is reposed, animated and well drawn.”20 And a critic in the London Courant commented on the portrait as Stuart’s first attempt at a full-length. “If we have been informed aright this is the gentleman’s first essay in this branch of the art ; at all events it does honour to his pencil, from the novelty of the design and the neatness of the execution.”21 A commentator in 1795 wrote about Stuart’s early difficulty with a portrait of this size.

 

It is now some years since Stuart the portrait painter … painted a portrait of a Mr. Grant in the action of skating; this portrait was given in so spirited an attitude and with so appropriate a character that when it was exhibited, it established the fame of the artist, of whom his brethren had before that time said he made a tolerable likeness of a face, but as to the figure he could not get below the fifth button.22

 

The combination of the full-length portrait with the act of skating was indeed a novel theme. Stuart appropriately portrayed Grant as a figure skater, the version of the sport popular in England, which emphasized graceful and refined movements, instead of as a Scottish speed skater, which encouraged skill, speed, and competition. Grant wears skates designed for the “small pivots and graceful maneuvers which were essential to the art of figure skating.”23 Robert Jones, in his influential Treatise on Skating (London, 1772), recommended a similar crossedarm pose as “a proper attitude for genteel rolling” (Figure 2).24 Matthew HarrisJouett in 1816 quoted Stuart on “the importance of keeping the figure in its circle of motion, “ giving the example of “his famous skaiting picture of Grant as contrasted with Buckminster Preble who turns his body one way his neck another and his eyes another…. “25

 

The painting is unlike other images of skaters, which belong to the tradition of sporting scenes. They include Irish painter Robert Healy’s Tom Conolly and his Friends Skating (1768, private collection, Ireland), Sir Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker Skating on Duddingston Loch (c. 1784, National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh), Thomas Rowlandson’s watercolor Skaters on the Serpentine of 1784 (National Museum of Wales, Cardiff), and a view by Julius Caesar Ibbetson engraved in 1787 as Winter Amusement; A View in Hyde Park from the Moated Housed Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg’s A Winter Morning, with a Party Skating of 1776 is particularly close to Stuart’s and West’s images in that it shows skating figures similar to those who perform the Serpentine Greeting. And like de Loutherbourg’s scene, Benjamin West’s undated drawing Skateing focuses its action on the popular Serpentine river. In the background is a structure similar to the Cheesecake House, a refreshment lodge that is also seen in the images by Rowlandson and Ibbetson. De Loutherbourg’s scene, which includes portraits of the artist and his wife, the artist’s partner V.M. Picot and others, was the best known of the various images of skaters made before or at the time that Stuart painted his portrait of Grant. It was reproduced by Matthew Boulton’s picture manufactory in Birmingham, England, between 1776 and 1780 by an unusual reproductive process that replicated paintings with their original coloring. In the mid-1780s a cloth merchant and amateur painter named Joseph Booth revived the idea of reproducing the painting by using a “polygraph process.” Numerous color reproductions of de Loutherbourg’s Winter Morning survive.27

 

Art historian William Pressly has proposed an interpretation of The Skater as expressing the theme of melancholy. To Pressly, the “recently revived tradition of the melancholy hero” explains the somber coloration of the painting, the darkly shaded eyes of the skater, and the use of a crossed-arm pose. In this view the painting becomes a self-portrait of Stuart’s own tendency toward melancholy. The snowy setting is appropriate in this theory, since winter was traditionally associated with melancholia.28 One might even suggest that Stuart included himself as the man on the right who stands under a tree. The physiognomy of this spectator, with his long nose and angular chin, closely resembles Stuart’s self-portrait of around 1786. Whether the association of the mood and the season necessarily points to melancholy as the subject of the painting is uncertain, even though the connection of the two was well known at the time and had been developed in verse many years earlier by the English poet James Thomson in his poem “Winter” in The Seasons (1730). “Winter” itself could be the theme, rather than “melancholy.” As Jules Prown has pointed out, “The skater evokes an allegorical image of Winter as one of the Four Seasons. “29 Lines from Thomson’s “Winter” form the caption for a late eighteenth-century English mezzotint titled “Winter,” which shows three warmly dressed figures walking near the Serpentine, where skaters can be seen in the background. “While every work of man is laid at rest, “ they “swoop on sounding skates a thousand different ways” and the “land is madden’d all to joy” (“Winter,” verses 761, 769, 771).30 The allusion to the mood of the season indicates that Stuart had absorbed the highly sophisticated London practice of borrowing from literary works for the subject matter of portraits.

 

Stuart was also absorbing lessons on technique. The portrait is a masterpiece of the late eighteenth-century British style of portraiture, which focuses on the figure, particularly the face, by painting the background with less detail. X-radiography shows that Stuart, when painting Grant’s face, had not yet developed the fully calligraphic brushwork for which he is known in his later paintings. Here he shaped the eyes, nose, mouth, and shadow of the nose by drawing the features with the brush. Later he would not follow the outline of the individual features as closely. Stuart also used more white pigment in the transitional flesh tones than he would in later works. X-radiography suggests, not surprisingly, that Stuart painted the background after completing the figure; the brushstrokes of the clouds mark the outer edges of the hat, face, and shoulders, which were already blocked out and painted. In addition, close examination of the painting reveals changes, or pentimenti, in the hat, shoulders, tail of the coat, and sitter’s right leg, indicating that Stuart did indeed struggle with the challenge inherent in a full-length, a size he rarely agreed to use again in his long career.

 

EGM

 

Notes

 

1.The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke 1956, 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Glinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Glinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

2.According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

3.Royal Academy 1878, unpaginated; Graves 1913, 1:383,3:1275; Graves 1905,71296. For a discussion of the attribution of the portrait in 1878 to Gainsborough, and the Grant family’s research to determine Stuart’s authorship, see Whitley 1932,33-36.

4.Quincy 1883,84, who does not identify the picture.

5.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Fraser heard the story from Stuart. John Gait had by then published his story about Benjamin West as a skater; see Gait 1820, 2:26-31. Gait told how, when West was a young artist in London in the 17605, his skating skills had brought him to the attention of the English aristocracy. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the similarity of the two anecdotes.

6.Hayes 1990, 64.

7.Button 1973, 354.

8.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87; since Jouett never saw the portrait, his description must be a quotation from Stuart.

9.Faculty of Advocates 1944, 90, courtesy of Dr. Louise Yeoman, Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh.

10.Alexander Grant is mentioned in Stuart 1877, 642; see also Stuart 1967,14.

11.Ward and Roberts 1904, 2:63-64. The earlier portrait of Grant by Romney was sold by Georgiana Bordewich, former owner of The Skater, at Christie’s on 22 March 1974 (lot 96) and bought by Léger Galleries; see Léger Galleries 1975, unpaginated, no. 5. Mrs. Bordewich also sold a portrait said to be of Grant by Thomas Hudson (lot 94), 127 by 101.6 cm (50 by 40 inches), and the portrait of his four eldest children, attributed to Opie (lot 95). The portrait of Mrs. Grant remained in Romney’s studio and was sold at Romney’s sale in 1807.

12.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Jouett referred to Baretti’s “mistaking it for Wests best production” when he recorded Stuart’s comments about painting in 1816; see Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87.

13.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

14.Whitley 1932,32.

15.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

16.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, and Pressly 1986, 44, from Childe-Pemberton 1925,1:284.

17.“Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition,” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser, 30 April 1782, 3.

18.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

19.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

20.The letter from the correspondent, identified as “Candid,” was published in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser on 9 May 1782, 2.

21.Quoted in Whitley 1932, 33, from an unidentified issue.

22.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, from an unidentified source.

23.Pearson 1987, 59.

24.Pressly 1986, 48; Pearson 1987, 60, 62, fig. 8.

25.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 86.

26.For three of these paintings see Hayes 1990, 64-66, no. 19, color repro.; and Pearson 1987, 57 fig. 2 and 61 fig. 7.

27.de Loutherbourg 1973, unpaginated, cat. no. 22. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the significance of this image for Stuart’s and West’s works.

28.Pressly 1986, 42-51.

29.Prown 1969, 48.

30.Quoted in Button 1973, 355, fig. 4.

 

References

 

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 30 April: 3.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post. 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 9 May: 2.

•1816—Jouett: 86, 87.

•1834—Dunlap: 1:183-184.

•1846—Lester: 126.

•1877—Stuart: 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (12 January): 50.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (19 January): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (26 January): 91.

•1879—Mason: 187-190.

•1880—MFA: 41, no.268.

•1883—Quincy: 84.

•1926—Park: 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley: 15, 31-36.

•1961—Oswald: 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount: 69-74.

•1969—Prown: 47-48.

•1973—Button: 351-3 62, color cover repro.

•1980—Evans: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding: 50, color repro .51.

•1981—Waterson: 872 repro.

•1981—Williams: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986—Pressly: 42-51, fig.1.

•1986—McLanathan: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1987—Pearson: 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding: 58-59, color repro.

•1990—Crean: 55-62.

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

West Building, Main Floor—Gallery 59

 

•Date: 1782

•Medium: Oil on Canvas

•Dimensions:

oOverall: 245.5 × 147.4 cm (96⅝ × 58 1/16 in.)

oFramed: 274.3 × 177.2 × 9.5 cm (108 × 69¾ × 3¾ in.)

•Credit Line: Andrew W. Mellon Collection

•Accession Number: 1950.18.1

•Artists/Makers

oPainter: Gilbert Stuart, American, 1755-1828

 

Overview

 

In 1775, Gilbert Stuart set sail for London where Benjamin West welcomed the destitute young man into his home. The Skater marks the end of his five-year apprenticeship to West. Stuart’s first effort at full-length portraiture, its originality brought the artist so much notice at the 1782 Royal Academy exhibition that he soon set up his own studio.

 

The unorthodox motif of skating—indeed, any presentation of vigorous movement at all—had absolutely no precedent in Britain’s “Grand Manner” tradition of life-size society portraiture. The painter recalled that when William Grant, from Congalton near Edinburgh, arrived to have his picture painted, the Scottish sitter remarked that, “on account of the excessive coldness of the weather … the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait.” Thus artist and sitter went off to skate on the Serpentine River in Hyde Park. When he returned to West’s studio with Grant, Stuart conceived the idea of portraying his subject on ice skates in a winter landscape, with the twin towers of Westminster Abbey far in the distance.

 

In this innovative design, Grant glides effortlessly forward with arms crossed over his chest in typical eighteenth-century skating form. Except for his folded arms, the figure’s stance derives from an ancient Roman statue, the Apollo Belvedere, a cast of which stood in the corner of West’s studio.

 

Provenance

 

The sitter, William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son, William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter, Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];[1] her son, Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;[2] his widow, Elizabeth Pelham-Clinton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter, Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Clinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913] London; sold 1950 to the NGA.

 

[1]The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke’s Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Peerage, Baronetage and Knightage, Privy Council and Order of Precedence, 101st ed., London, 1956: 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Clinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Clinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

[2]According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA curatorial file), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

 

Associated Names

 

•Clinton, Pelham, Miss

•Grant, William

•Grant, William

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton, Mrs.

•Pelham-Clinton, Elizabeth

 

Exhibition History

 

•1782—Royal Academy, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating

•1878—Exhibition of Works by Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough

•1946—American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206

•1963—Style, Truth, and the Portrait, Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38

•1967—Gilbert Stuart, Portraitist of the Young Republic, 1755-1828, National Gallery of Art; Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design, Providence, 1967, no. 8

•1976—American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44

•1981—American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; National Portrait Gallery, Washington, D.C., 1981-1982, no. 21.

•2001—Great British Paintings from American Collections: Holbein to Hockney, Yale Center for British Art, New Haven; The Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens, San Marino, 2001-2002, no. 35, repro.

•2004—Gilbert Stuart, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; National Gallery of Art (for the National Portrait Gallery), Washington, D.C., 2004-2005, no. 6, repro.

 

Bibliography

 

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (9 May 1782): 2.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (30 April 1782): 3.

•1816—Jouett, Matthew Harris. “Notes Taken by M. H. Jouett while in Boston from Conversations on painting with Gilbert Stuart Esqr.” Manuscript, published in Gilbert Stuart and His Pupils, by John Hill Morgan. New York, 1816: 86, 87.

•1846—Lester, C. Edwards. The Artists of America. New York, 1846: 126.

•1869—Dunlap, William. A History of the Rise and Progress of The Arts of Design in the United States. 2 vols. Reprinted in 3. New York, 1969 (1834): 1:183-184.

•1877—Stuart, Jane. “The Youth of Gilbert Stuart.” Scribner’s Monthly 13, no. 5 (March 1877): 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (January 19, 1878): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (January 26, 1878): 91.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (January 12, 1878): 50.

•1879—Mason, George C. The Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1879: 187-190.

•1880—”Portraits Painted by Stuart...taken from Mason’s Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart.” In Exhibition of Portraits Painted by Gilbert Stuart. Exh. cat. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 1880: 41, no. 268.

•1883—Quincy, Josiah. Figures of the Past from the Leaves of Old Journals. 4th ed. Boston, 1883: 84.

•1926—Park 1926, 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley, William T. Artists and Their Friends in England, 1700-1800. 2 vols. London and Boston, 1928: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley, William T. Gilbert Stuart. Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1932: 15, 31-36.

•1952 Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds., Great Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1952: 138, color repro., as The Skater.

•1956 Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1956: 50, color repro., as The Skater.

•1957—Shapley, Fern Rusk. Comparisons in Art: A Companion to the National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. London, 1957 (reprinted 1959): pl. 91.

•1961—Oswald, Arthur. “Our Ancestors on the Ice.” Country Life 129 (9 February 1961): 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount, Charles Merrill. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1964: 69-74.

•1966—Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds. A Pageant of Painting from the National Gallery of Art. 2 vols. New York, 1966: 2:380, color repro.

•1969—Novak, Barbara. American Painting of the Nineteenth Century: Realism, Idealism, and the American Experience. 2nd ed. New York, 1979: 32, fig. 1.17.

•1969—Prown, Jules David. American Painting, From its Beginnings to the Armory Show. Geneva, 1969: 47-48.

•1970—American Paintings and Sculpture: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1970: 106, repro., as The Skater.

•1973—Button, Dick. “The Art of Skating.” Antiques 103, no. 2 (February 1973): 351-362, color repro. on cover.

•1973—Finley, David Edward. A Standard of Excellence: Andrew W. Mellon Founds the National Gallery of Art at Washington. Washington, 1973: 135.

•1975—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1975: 380, color repro. 381.

•1978—King, Marian. Adventures in Art: National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C. New York, 1978: 54, pl. 31.

•1980—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1980: 234, repro.

•1980—Evans, Dorinda. Benjamin West and His American Students. Exh. cat. National Portrait Gallery, Washington; Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, Philadelphia. Washington, 1980: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1980: 10, no. 6, color repro.

•1981—Waterson, Merlin. “Hissing Along the Polished Ice.” Country Life 169 (2 April 1981): repro. 872.

•1981—Williams, William James. A Heritage of American Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1981: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. Rev. ed. New York, 1984: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986 McLanathan, Richard. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1986: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1986—Pressly, William L. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater: An Essay in Romantic Melancholy.” American Art Journal 18, no. 1, 1986: 42-51, fig. 1.

•1987—Pearson, Andrea G. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater (Portrait of William Grant) and Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker, D.D., Skating on Duddington Loch: A Study of Sources.” Rutgers Art Review 8 (1987): 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. Rev. ed. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1988: 58-59, no. 6, color repro.

•1990—Crean, Hugh R. Gilbert Stuart and the politics of fine arts patronage in Ireland, 1787-1793; A social and cultural study. Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1990: 55-62.

•1992—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 345, repro.

•1992—National Gallery of Art, Washington. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 214, repro.

•1995—Miles, Ellen G. American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century. The Collections of the National Gallery of Art Systematic Catalogue. Washington, D.C., 1995: 162-169, color repro. 165.

•1997—Hughes, Robert. American Visions: The Epic History of Art in America. New York, 1997: 128, color fig. 81.

•1997—Thomson, Duncan. Raeburn: The Art of Sir Henry Raeburn 1756-1823, Exh. cat. Scottish National Portrait Gallery at the Royal Scottish Academy, Edinburgh; National Portrait Gallery, London, 1997-1998, p. 90, no. 61, repro.

•1998—Mandel, Corinne. “Melancholy.” In Encyclopedia of Comparative Iconography: Themes Depicted in Works of Art, edited by Helene E. Roberts. 2 vols. Chicago, 1998: 2:586-588.

•2004—Hand, John Oliver. National Gallery of Art: Master Paintings from the Collection. Washington and New York, 2004: 294-295, no. 240, color repro.

•2011—Gopnik, Adam. Winter: Four Windows on the Season. Toronto, 2011: 142-143, color repro.

•2013—Evans, Dorinda. Gilbert Stuart and the Impact of Manic Depression. Burlington, 2013: 162-164, 168 nn. 36 and 37, fig. 11.

•2016—Rather, Susan. The American School: Artists and Status in the Late Colonial and Early National Era. New Haven, 2016: 171-172, color fig. 125.

  

From American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century:

 

1950.18.1 (1051)

 

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

•1782

•Oil on Canvas, 244.5 × 147.4 (96¼ × 58)

•Andrew W. Mellon Collection

 

Technical Notes

 

The support is a finely woven twill fabric. The top and bottom tacking edges have been unfolded and add about 6 cm to the painting’s height. The lateral tacking margins have been cropped, but cusping remains along these edges. The thin white ground extends to cover the tacking margins, suggesting that the canvas was pre-primed. Much of the preliminary drawing, done loosely with paint and brush, is visible on the surface, having been incorporated into the painting. The paint is thinly applied, except in the sitter’s upper body, face, and collar, and in the sky around his head, where the paint is thicker and its handling more controlled. Many pentimenti are evident, including changes in the figure’s hat, shoulders, tail of the coat on the viewer’s right, and the sitter’s right leg.

 

Abrasion is found in the ice at the sitter’s feet. Crackle is more pronounced near the head, where the paint is thicker, and is especially pronounced to the right of the skater’s thigh. There are pinpoint losses throughout. The painting was lined prior to 1950.

 

Provenance

 

William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];1 her son Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;2 his widow Elizabeth Pelham-Clin ton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Glinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913], London.

 

Exhibited

 

Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating. Exhibition of Works by the Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James3s Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough.3 American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206. Style, Truth and the Portrait, The Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38. Gilbert Stuart, NGA; RISD, 1967, no. 8. American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, YUAG; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44. American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; NGA, 1981-1982, no. 21.

 

In 1782 Gilbert Stuart, a young painter in London, was “suddenly lifted into fame by the exhibition of a single picture,”4 his full-length of William Grant called Portrait of a Gentleman Skating. (The painting was given its present title of The Skater m 1946.) Stuart devised the theme after an outing on the Serpentine river in Hyde Park with Grant, a young Scottish lawyer, who had come for a sitting for a full-length portrait. According to American artist William Dunlap, who heard the story from miniaturist Charles Fraser,

 

Stuart said that he felt great diffidence in undertaking a whole length; but that there must be a beginning, and a day was accordingly appointed for Mr. Grant to sit. On entering the artist’s room, he regretted the appointment, on account of the excessive coldness of the weather, and observed to Stuart, that the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait. To this the painter assented, and they both sallied out to their morning’s amusement. Stuart said that early practice had made him very expert in skating. His celerity and activity accordingly attracted crowds on the Serpentine river—which was the scene of their sport. His companion, although a well-made and graceful man, was not as active as himself; and there being a crack in the ice, which made it dangerous to continue their amusement, he told Mr. Grant to hold the skirt of his coat, and follow him off the field. They returned to Mr. Stuart’s rooms, where it occurred to him to paint Mr. Grant in the attitude of skating, with the appendage of a winter scene, in the back ground.5

 

The setting for the portrait is the Serpentine, a popular skating spot in London that was created when Kensington Gardens was landscaped during the reign of George II.6 Grant is dressed completely in black, from his hat and the fur-lined lapels of his coat to his breeches, stockings, and shoes. Behind him to the right two skaters sit at the edge of the ice, putting on their skates, while two other men stand under a tree. In the left background two skaters perform the Salutation, also known as the Serpentine Greeting, while others watch.7 The painting offers a balance of black, gray, and off-white, with slight touches of red on the clothing of the background figures. Stuart’s pupil Matthew Harris Jouett later described the portrait as a “fine contrast of Grant in full black to the snow & grey chilly background.”8 The young lawyer William Grant (d. 1821) was the son of Ludovick Grant of Edinburgh.9 Why he chose Stuart to paint his portrait is not known ; perhaps he was a friend or a distant relative of Stuart’s early London patron Alexander Grant, also a Scot.10 Moderately wealthy, Grant was fond of portraits. George Romney painted him in 1781 and again in 1787, and in 1794 he painted “ Mrs. Grant, “ perhaps Grant’s wife Dorothea Dalrymple, whom he married that year. Grant’s children were painted by John Opie (LaSalle University Art Museum, Philadelphia).11 At his death in 1821, Grant left his heirs a large estate called Congalton, in Scotland, as well as stock in the Bank of England and the Royal Bank of Scotland.

 

The portrait, Stuart’s first full-length, showed his ability to invent new compositions within the tradition of English portraiture, in which standing cross-legged poses had been popular for men’s portraits since the 17405. Its success made it possible for Stuart to move from West’s studio into one of his own. Comparisons between the two American artists by contemporaries were inevitable. When Giuseppi Baretti, an Italian-born lexicographer, author, and friend of Sir Joshua Reynolds, saw the painting at West’s before its exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts, he commented, according to Dunlap, “What a charming picture ! Who but the great West could have painted such a one ! “ Later, seeing Stuart at work on the painting, he exclaimed, “What, young man, does Mr. West permit you to touch his pictures?” Stuart replied that it was his own painting. Baretti is supposed to have said, “Why, it is almost as good as Mr. West can paint.”12 The close association of the two men’s work is revealed by an undated chalk drawing by West titled Skateing. West, like Stuart, enjoyed a reputation as a good skater, and in this chalk drawing depicted skaters and spectators on the ice at the Serpentine. A skater in the center foreground turns toward the man behind him, who lies on the ice after a fall. To the left, two figures who perform the Serpentine Greeting are virtually identical to the two skaters in the background of Stuart’s portrait of Grant. To the right is a small figure whose pose seems similar to Grant’s; the figure is very sketchy.

 

A reviewer noted Stuart’s relationship to Benjamin West when Stuart exhibited the painting with three others at the Royal Academy of Arts in 1782.

 

Mr. Stuart is in Partnership with Mr. West; where it is not uncommon for Wits to divert themselves with Applications for Things they do not immediately want; because they are told by Mr. West that Mr. Stuart is the only Portrait Painter in the World; and by Mr. Stuart that no Man has any Pretensions in History Painting but Mr. West. After such Authority what can we say of Mr. Stuart’s Painting.13

 

The portrait enchanted visitors who attended the Academy’s exhibition. Horace Walpole, author of Anecdotes of Painting in England (1762-1771), the first history of British art, wrote “very good” next to the entry for the portrait in his copy of the catalogue.14 Stuart overheard the Duke of Rutland on opening day, urging Sir Joshua Reynolds, “I wish you would go to the exhibition with me, for there is a portrait there which you must see, every body is enchanted with it.” When Sir Joshua asked who painted it, the Duke replied, “A young man by the name of Stuart. “15 Visitors and reviewers praised the portrait’s unusual pose and Stuart’s ability with likeness. Sir John Cullum commented on the novelty of the theme in his letter of 1 May 1782 to Frederick Hervey, Bishop of Derry and Earl of Bristol. “One would have thought that almost every attitude of a single Figure had long been exhausted in this land of portrait painting but one is now exhibited which I recollect not before—it is that of Skating. There is a noble portrait large as life thus exhibited and which produces the most powerful effect.”16 A reviewer for the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser commented on 30 April that “Stuart and Opie, whose merits were not so generally known, have proved themselves able artists” and praised Stuart for his “striking likenesses.”17 Stuart’s ability to capture a likeness was borne out by Charles Fraser’s later comment to artist William Dunlap that the picture attracted so much comment that Stuart was “afraid to go to the academy to meet the looks and answer the inquiries of the multitude. Mr. Grant went one day to the exhibition, dressed as his portrait represented him; the original was immediately recognized, when the crowd followed him so closely that he was compelled to make his retreat, for every one was exclaiming, ‘There he is, there is the gentleman.’”18

 

Opinion was divided on the technique of the painting. One reviewer said that “Mr. Stuart seldom fails of a Likeness; but wants Freedom of Pencil, and Elegance of Taste.”19 However, the author of a letter in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser noted, “ Mr. Stuart… may be said to be an acquisition to the public; his Gentleman seating, No. 190, is reposed, animated and well drawn.”20 And a critic in the London Courant commented on the portrait as Stuart’s first attempt at a full-length. “If we have been informed aright this is the gentleman’s first essay in this branch of the art ; at all events it does honour to his pencil, from the novelty of the design and the neatness of the execution.”21 A commentator in 1795 wrote about Stuart’s early difficulty with a portrait of this size.

 

It is now some years since Stuart the portrait painter … painted a portrait of a Mr. Grant in the action of skating; this portrait was given in so spirited an attitude and with so appropriate a character that when it was exhibited, it established the fame of the artist, of whom his brethren had before that time said he made a tolerable likeness of a face, but as to the figure he could not get below the fifth button.22

 

The combination of the full-length portrait with the act of skating was indeed a novel theme. Stuart appropriately portrayed Grant as a figure skater, the version of the sport popular in England, which emphasized graceful and refined movements, instead of as a Scottish speed skater, which encouraged skill, speed, and competition. Grant wears skates designed for the “small pivots and graceful maneuvers which were essential to the art of figure skating.”23 Robert Jones, in his influential Treatise on Skating (London, 1772), recommended a similar crossedarm pose as “a proper attitude for genteel rolling” (Figure 2).24 Matthew HarrisJouett in 1816 quoted Stuart on “the importance of keeping the figure in its circle of motion, “ giving the example of “his famous skaiting picture of Grant as contrasted with Buckminster Preble who turns his body one way his neck another and his eyes another…. “25

 

The painting is unlike other images of skaters, which belong to the tradition of sporting scenes. They include Irish painter Robert Healy’s Tom Conolly and his Friends Skating (1768, private collection, Ireland), Sir Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker Skating on Duddingston Loch (c. 1784, National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh), Thomas Rowlandson’s watercolor Skaters on the Serpentine of 1784 (National Museum of Wales, Cardiff), and a view by Julius Caesar Ibbetson engraved in 1787 as Winter Amusement; A View in Hyde Park from the Moated Housed Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg’s A Winter Morning, with a Party Skating of 1776 is particularly close to Stuart’s and West’s images in that it shows skating figures similar to those who perform the Serpentine Greeting. And like de Loutherbourg’s scene, Benjamin West’s undated drawing Skateing focuses its action on the popular Serpentine river. In the background is a structure similar to the Cheesecake House, a refreshment lodge that is also seen in the images by Rowlandson and Ibbetson. De Loutherbourg’s scene, which includes portraits of the artist and his wife, the artist’s partner V.M. Picot and others, was the best known of the various images of skaters made before or at the time that Stuart painted his portrait of Grant. It was reproduced by Matthew Boulton’s picture manufactory in Birmingham, England, between 1776 and 1780 by an unusual reproductive process that replicated paintings with their original coloring. In the mid-1780s a cloth merchant and amateur painter named Joseph Booth revived the idea of reproducing the painting by using a “polygraph process.” Numerous color reproductions of de Loutherbourg’s Winter Morning survive.27

 

Art historian William Pressly has proposed an interpretation of The Skater as expressing the theme of melancholy. To Pressly, the “recently revived tradition of the melancholy hero” explains the somber coloration of the painting, the darkly shaded eyes of the skater, and the use of a crossed-arm pose. In this view the painting becomes a self-portrait of Stuart’s own tendency toward melancholy. The snowy setting is appropriate in this theory, since winter was traditionally associated with melancholia.28 One might even suggest that Stuart included himself as the man on the right who stands under a tree. The physiognomy of this spectator, with his long nose and angular chin, closely resembles Stuart’s self-portrait of around 1786. Whether the association of the mood and the season necessarily points to melancholy as the subject of the painting is uncertain, even though the connection of the two was well known at the time and had been developed in verse many years earlier by the English poet James Thomson in his poem “Winter” in The Seasons (1730). “Winter” itself could be the theme, rather than “melancholy.” As Jules Prown has pointed out, “The skater evokes an allegorical image of Winter as one of the Four Seasons. “29 Lines from Thomson’s “Winter” form the caption for a late eighteenth-century English mezzotint titled “Winter,” which shows three warmly dressed figures walking near the Serpentine, where skaters can be seen in the background. “While every work of man is laid at rest, “ they “swoop on sounding skates a thousand different ways” and the “land is madden’d all to joy” (“Winter,” verses 761, 769, 771).30 The allusion to the mood of the season indicates that Stuart had absorbed the highly sophisticated London practice of borrowing from literary works for the subject matter of portraits.

 

Stuart was also absorbing lessons on technique. The portrait is a masterpiece of the late eighteenth-century British style of portraiture, which focuses on the figure, particularly the face, by painting the background with less detail. X-radiography shows that Stuart, when painting Grant’s face, had not yet developed the fully calligraphic brushwork for which he is known in his later paintings. Here he shaped the eyes, nose, mouth, and shadow of the nose by drawing the features with the brush. Later he would not follow the outline of the individual features as closely. Stuart also used more white pigment in the transitional flesh tones than he would in later works. X-radiography suggests, not surprisingly, that Stuart painted the background after completing the figure; the brushstrokes of the clouds mark the outer edges of the hat, face, and shoulders, which were already blocked out and painted. In addition, close examination of the painting reveals changes, or pentimenti, in the hat, shoulders, tail of the coat, and sitter’s right leg, indicating that Stuart did indeed struggle with the challenge inherent in a full-length, a size he rarely agreed to use again in his long career.

 

EGM

 

Notes

 

1.The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke 1956, 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Glinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Glinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

2.According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

3.Royal Academy 1878, unpaginated; Graves 1913, 1:383,3:1275; Graves 1905,71296. For a discussion of the attribution of the portrait in 1878 to Gainsborough, and the Grant family’s research to determine Stuart’s authorship, see Whitley 1932,33-36.

4.Quincy 1883,84, who does not identify the picture.

5.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Fraser heard the story from Stuart. John Gait had by then published his story about Benjamin West as a skater; see Gait 1820, 2:26-31. Gait told how, when West was a young artist in London in the 17605, his skating skills had brought him to the attention of the English aristocracy. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the similarity of the two anecdotes.

6.Hayes 1990, 64.

7.Button 1973, 354.

8.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87; since Jouett never saw the portrait, his description must be a quotation from Stuart.

9.Faculty of Advocates 1944, 90, courtesy of Dr. Louise Yeoman, Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh.

10.Alexander Grant is mentioned in Stuart 1877, 642; see also Stuart 1967,14.

11.Ward and Roberts 1904, 2:63-64. The earlier portrait of Grant by Romney was sold by Georgiana Bordewich, former owner of The Skater, at Christie’s on 22 March 1974 (lot 96) and bought by Léger Galleries; see Léger Galleries 1975, unpaginated, no. 5. Mrs. Bordewich also sold a portrait said to be of Grant by Thomas Hudson (lot 94), 127 by 101.6 cm (50 by 40 inches), and the portrait of his four eldest children, attributed to Opie (lot 95). The portrait of Mrs. Grant remained in Romney’s studio and was sold at Romney’s sale in 1807.

12.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Jouett referred to Baretti’s “mistaking it for Wests best production” when he recorded Stuart’s comments about painting in 1816; see Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87.

13.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

14.Whitley 1932,32.

15.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

16.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, and Pressly 1986, 44, from Childe-Pemberton 1925,1:284.

17.“Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition,” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser, 30 April 1782, 3.

18.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

19.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

20.The letter from the correspondent, identified as “Candid,” was published in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser on 9 May 1782, 2.

21.Quoted in Whitley 1932, 33, from an unidentified issue.

22.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, from an unidentified source.

23.Pearson 1987, 59.

24.Pressly 1986, 48; Pearson 1987, 60, 62, fig. 8.

25.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 86.

26.For three of these paintings see Hayes 1990, 64-66, no. 19, color repro.; and Pearson 1987, 57 fig. 2 and 61 fig. 7.

27.de Loutherbourg 1973, unpaginated, cat. no. 22. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the significance of this image for Stuart’s and West’s works.

28.Pressly 1986, 42-51.

29.Prown 1969, 48.

30.Quoted in Button 1973, 355, fig. 4.

 

References

 

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 30 April: 3.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post. 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 9 May: 2.

•1816—Jouett: 86, 87.

•1834—Dunlap: 1:183-184.

•1846—Lester: 126.

•1877—Stuart: 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (12 January): 50.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (19 January): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (26 January): 91.

•1879—Mason: 187-190.

•1880—MFA: 41, no.268.

•1883—Quincy: 84.

•1926—Park: 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley: 15, 31-36.

•1961—Oswald: 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount: 69-74.

•1969—Prown: 47-48.

•1973—Button: 351-3 62, color cover repro.

•1980—Evans: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding: 50, color repro .51.

•1981—Waterson: 872 repro.

•1981—Williams: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986—Pressly: 42-51, fig.1.

•1986—McLanathan: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1987—Pearson: 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding: 58-59, color repro.

•1990—Crean: 55-62.

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

West Building, Main Floor—Gallery 59

 

•Date: 1782

•Medium: Oil on Canvas

•Dimensions:

oOverall: 245.5 × 147.4 cm (96⅝ × 58 1/16 in.)

oFramed: 274.3 × 177.2 × 9.5 cm (108 × 69¾ × 3¾ in.)

•Credit Line: Andrew W. Mellon Collection

•Accession Number: 1950.18.1

•Artists/Makers

oPainter: Gilbert Stuart, American, 1755-1828

 

Overview

 

In 1775, Gilbert Stuart set sail for London where Benjamin West welcomed the destitute young man into his home. The Skater marks the end of his five-year apprenticeship to West. Stuart’s first effort at full-length portraiture, its originality brought the artist so much notice at the 1782 Royal Academy exhibition that he soon set up his own studio.

 

The unorthodox motif of skating—indeed, any presentation of vigorous movement at all—had absolutely no precedent in Britain’s “Grand Manner” tradition of life-size society portraiture. The painter recalled that when William Grant, from Congalton near Edinburgh, arrived to have his picture painted, the Scottish sitter remarked that, “on account of the excessive coldness of the weather … the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait.” Thus artist and sitter went off to skate on the Serpentine River in Hyde Park. When he returned to West’s studio with Grant, Stuart conceived the idea of portraying his subject on ice skates in a winter landscape, with the twin towers of Westminster Abbey far in the distance.

 

In this innovative design, Grant glides effortlessly forward with arms crossed over his chest in typical eighteenth-century skating form. Except for his folded arms, the figure’s stance derives from an ancient Roman statue, the Apollo Belvedere, a cast of which stood in the corner of West’s studio.

 

Provenance

 

The sitter, William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son, William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter, Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];[1] her son, Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;[2] his widow, Elizabeth Pelham-Clinton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter, Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Clinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913] London; sold 1950 to the NGA.

 

[1]The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke’s Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Peerage, Baronetage and Knightage, Privy Council and Order of Precedence, 101st ed., London, 1956: 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Clinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Clinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

[2]According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA curatorial file), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

 

Associated Names

 

•Clinton, Pelham, Miss

•Grant, William

•Grant, William

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton, Mrs.

•Pelham-Clinton, Elizabeth

 

Exhibition History

 

•1782—Royal Academy, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating

•1878—Exhibition of Works by Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough

•1946—American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206

•1963—Style, Truth, and the Portrait, Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38

•1967—Gilbert Stuart, Portraitist of the Young Republic, 1755-1828, National Gallery of Art; Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design, Providence, 1967, no. 8

•1976—American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44

•1981—American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; National Portrait Gallery, Washington, D.C., 1981-1982, no. 21.

•2001—Great British Paintings from American Collections: Holbein to Hockney, Yale Center for British Art, New Haven; The Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens, San Marino, 2001-2002, no. 35, repro.

•2004—Gilbert Stuart, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; National Gallery of Art (for the National Portrait Gallery), Washington, D.C., 2004-2005, no. 6, repro.

 

Bibliography

 

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (9 May 1782): 2.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (30 April 1782): 3.

•1816—Jouett, Matthew Harris. “Notes Taken by M. H. Jouett while in Boston from Conversations on painting with Gilbert Stuart Esqr.” Manuscript, published in Gilbert Stuart and His Pupils, by John Hill Morgan. New York, 1816: 86, 87.

•1846—Lester, C. Edwards. The Artists of America. New York, 1846: 126.

•1869—Dunlap, William. A History of the Rise and Progress of The Arts of Design in the United States. 2 vols. Reprinted in 3. New York, 1969 (1834): 1:183-184.

•1877—Stuart, Jane. “The Youth of Gilbert Stuart.” Scribner’s Monthly 13, no. 5 (March 1877): 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (January 19, 1878): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (January 26, 1878): 91.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (January 12, 1878): 50.

•1879—Mason, George C. The Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1879: 187-190.

•1880—”Portraits Painted by Stuart...taken from Mason’s Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart.” In Exhibition of Portraits Painted by Gilbert Stuart. Exh. cat. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 1880: 41, no. 268.

•1883—Quincy, Josiah. Figures of the Past from the Leaves of Old Journals. 4th ed. Boston, 1883: 84.

•1926—Park 1926, 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley, William T. Artists and Their Friends in England, 1700-1800. 2 vols. London and Boston, 1928: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley, William T. Gilbert Stuart. Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1932: 15, 31-36.

•1952 Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds., Great Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1952: 138, color repro., as The Skater.

•1956 Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1956: 50, color repro., as The Skater.

•1957—Shapley, Fern Rusk. Comparisons in Art: A Companion to the National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. London, 1957 (reprinted 1959): pl. 91.

•1961—Oswald, Arthur. “Our Ancestors on the Ice.” Country Life 129 (9 February 1961): 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount, Charles Merrill. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1964: 69-74.

•1966—Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds. A Pageant of Painting from the National Gallery of Art. 2 vols. New York, 1966: 2:380, color repro.

•1969—Novak, Barbara. American Painting of the Nineteenth Century: Realism, Idealism, and the American Experience. 2nd ed. New York, 1979: 32, fig. 1.17.

•1969—Prown, Jules David. American Painting, From its Beginnings to the Armory Show. Geneva, 1969: 47-48.

•1970—American Paintings and Sculpture: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1970: 106, repro., as The Skater.

•1973—Button, Dick. “The Art of Skating.” Antiques 103, no. 2 (February 1973): 351-362, color repro. on cover.

•1973—Finley, David Edward. A Standard of Excellence: Andrew W. Mellon Founds the National Gallery of Art at Washington. Washington, 1973: 135.

•1975—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1975: 380, color repro. 381.

•1978—King, Marian. Adventures in Art: National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C. New York, 1978: 54, pl. 31.

•1980—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1980: 234, repro.

•1980—Evans, Dorinda. Benjamin West and His American Students. Exh. cat. National Portrait Gallery, Washington; Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, Philadelphia. Washington, 1980: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1980: 10, no. 6, color repro.

•1981—Waterson, Merlin. “Hissing Along the Polished Ice.” Country Life 169 (2 April 1981): repro. 872.

•1981—Williams, William James. A Heritage of American Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1981: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. Rev. ed. New York, 1984: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986 McLanathan, Richard. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1986: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1986—Pressly, William L. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater: An Essay in Romantic Melancholy.” American Art Journal 18, no. 1, 1986: 42-51, fig. 1.

•1987—Pearson, Andrea G. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater (Portrait of William Grant) and Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker, D.D., Skating on Duddington Loch: A Study of Sources.” Rutgers Art Review 8 (1987): 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. Rev. ed. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1988: 58-59, no. 6, color repro.

•1990—Crean, Hugh R. Gilbert Stuart and the politics of fine arts patronage in Ireland, 1787-1793; A social and cultural study. Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1990: 55-62.

•1992—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 345, repro.

•1992—National Gallery of Art, Washington. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 214, repro.

•1995—Miles, Ellen G. American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century. The Collections of the National Gallery of Art Systematic Catalogue. Washington, D.C., 1995: 162-169, color repro. 165.

•1997—Hughes, Robert. American Visions: The Epic History of Art in America. New York, 1997: 128, color fig. 81.

•1997—Thomson, Duncan. Raeburn: The Art of Sir Henry Raeburn 1756-1823, Exh. cat. Scottish National Portrait Gallery at the Royal Scottish Academy, Edinburgh; National Portrait Gallery, London, 1997-1998, p. 90, no. 61, repro.

•1998—Mandel, Corinne. “Melancholy.” In Encyclopedia of Comparative Iconography: Themes Depicted in Works of Art, edited by Helene E. Roberts. 2 vols. Chicago, 1998: 2:586-588.

•2004—Hand, John Oliver. National Gallery of Art: Master Paintings from the Collection. Washington and New York, 2004: 294-295, no. 240, color repro.

•2011—Gopnik, Adam. Winter: Four Windows on the Season. Toronto, 2011: 142-143, color repro.

•2013—Evans, Dorinda. Gilbert Stuart and the Impact of Manic Depression. Burlington, 2013: 162-164, 168 nn. 36 and 37, fig. 11.

•2016—Rather, Susan. The American School: Artists and Status in the Late Colonial and Early National Era. New Haven, 2016: 171-172, color fig. 125.

  

From American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century:

 

1950.18.1 (1051)

 

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

•1782

•Oil on Canvas, 244.5 × 147.4 (96¼ × 58)

•Andrew W. Mellon Collection

 

Technical Notes

 

The support is a finely woven twill fabric. The top and bottom tacking edges have been unfolded and add about 6 cm to the painting’s height. The lateral tacking margins have been cropped, but cusping remains along these edges. The thin white ground extends to cover the tacking margins, suggesting that the canvas was pre-primed. Much of the preliminary drawing, done loosely with paint and brush, is visible on the surface, having been incorporated into the painting. The paint is thinly applied, except in the sitter’s upper body, face, and collar, and in the sky around his head, where the paint is thicker and its handling more controlled. Many pentimenti are evident, including changes in the figure’s hat, shoulders, tail of the coat on the viewer’s right, and the sitter’s right leg.

 

Abrasion is found in the ice at the sitter’s feet. Crackle is more pronounced near the head, where the paint is thicker, and is especially pronounced to the right of the skater’s thigh. There are pinpoint losses throughout. The painting was lined prior to 1950.

 

Provenance

 

William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];1 her son Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;2 his widow Elizabeth Pelham-Clin ton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Glinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913], London.

 

Exhibited

 

Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating. Exhibition of Works by the Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James3s Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough.3 American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206. Style, Truth and the Portrait, The Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38. Gilbert Stuart, NGA; RISD, 1967, no. 8. American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, YUAG; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44. American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; NGA, 1981-1982, no. 21.

 

In 1782 Gilbert Stuart, a young painter in London, was “suddenly lifted into fame by the exhibition of a single picture,”4 his full-length of William Grant called Portrait of a Gentleman Skating. (The painting was given its present title of The Skater m 1946.) Stuart devised the theme after an outing on the Serpentine river in Hyde Park with Grant, a young Scottish lawyer, who had come for a sitting for a full-length portrait. According to American artist William Dunlap, who heard the story from miniaturist Charles Fraser,

 

Stuart said that he felt great diffidence in undertaking a whole length; but that there must be a beginning, and a day was accordingly appointed for Mr. Grant to sit. On entering the artist’s room, he regretted the appointment, on account of the excessive coldness of the weather, and observed to Stuart, that the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait. To this the painter assented, and they both sallied out to their morning’s amusement. Stuart said that early practice had made him very expert in skating. His celerity and activity accordingly attracted crowds on the Serpentine river—which was the scene of their sport. His companion, although a well-made and graceful man, was not as active as himself; and there being a crack in the ice, which made it dangerous to continue their amusement, he told Mr. Grant to hold the skirt of his coat, and follow him off the field. They returned to Mr. Stuart’s rooms, where it occurred to him to paint Mr. Grant in the attitude of skating, with the appendage of a winter scene, in the back ground.5

 

The setting for the portrait is the Serpentine, a popular skating spot in London that was created when Kensington Gardens was landscaped during the reign of George II.6 Grant is dressed completely in black, from his hat and the fur-lined lapels of his coat to his breeches, stockings, and shoes. Behind him to the right two skaters sit at the edge of the ice, putting on their skates, while two other men stand under a tree. In the left background two skaters perform the Salutation, also known as the Serpentine Greeting, while others watch.7 The painting offers a balance of black, gray, and off-white, with slight touches of red on the clothing of the background figures. Stuart’s pupil Matthew Harris Jouett later described the portrait as a “fine contrast of Grant in full black to the snow & grey chilly background.”8 The young lawyer William Grant (d. 1821) was the son of Ludovick Grant of Edinburgh.9 Why he chose Stuart to paint his portrait is not known ; perhaps he was a friend or a distant relative of Stuart’s early London patron Alexander Grant, also a Scot.10 Moderately wealthy, Grant was fond of portraits. George Romney painted him in 1781 and again in 1787, and in 1794 he painted “ Mrs. Grant, “ perhaps Grant’s wife Dorothea Dalrymple, whom he married that year. Grant’s children were painted by John Opie (LaSalle University Art Museum, Philadelphia).11 At his death in 1821, Grant left his heirs a large estate called Congalton, in Scotland, as well as stock in the Bank of England and the Royal Bank of Scotland.

 

The portrait, Stuart’s first full-length, showed his ability to invent new compositions within the tradition of English portraiture, in which standing cross-legged poses had been popular for men’s portraits since the 17405. Its success made it possible for Stuart to move from West’s studio into one of his own. Comparisons between the two American artists by contemporaries were inevitable. When Giuseppi Baretti, an Italian-born lexicographer, author, and friend of Sir Joshua Reynolds, saw the painting at West’s before its exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts, he commented, according to Dunlap, “What a charming picture ! Who but the great West could have painted such a one ! “ Later, seeing Stuart at work on the painting, he exclaimed, “What, young man, does Mr. West permit you to touch his pictures?” Stuart replied that it was his own painting. Baretti is supposed to have said, “Why, it is almost as good as Mr. West can paint.”12 The close association of the two men’s work is revealed by an undated chalk drawing by West titled Skateing. West, like Stuart, enjoyed a reputation as a good skater, and in this chalk drawing depicted skaters and spectators on the ice at the Serpentine. A skater in the center foreground turns toward the man behind him, who lies on the ice after a fall. To the left, two figures who perform the Serpentine Greeting are virtually identical to the two skaters in the background of Stuart’s portrait of Grant. To the right is a small figure whose pose seems similar to Grant’s; the figure is very sketchy.

 

A reviewer noted Stuart’s relationship to Benjamin West when Stuart exhibited the painting with three others at the Royal Academy of Arts in 1782.

 

Mr. Stuart is in Partnership with Mr. West; where it is not uncommon for Wits to divert themselves with Applications for Things they do not immediately want; because they are told by Mr. West that Mr. Stuart is the only Portrait Painter in the World; and by Mr. Stuart that no Man has any Pretensions in History Painting but Mr. West. After such Authority what can we say of Mr. Stuart’s Painting.13

 

The portrait enchanted visitors who attended the Academy’s exhibition. Horace Walpole, author of Anecdotes of Painting in England (1762-1771), the first history of British art, wrote “very good” next to the entry for the portrait in his copy of the catalogue.14 Stuart overheard the Duke of Rutland on opening day, urging Sir Joshua Reynolds, “I wish you would go to the exhibition with me, for there is a portrait there which you must see, every body is enchanted with it.” When Sir Joshua asked who painted it, the Duke replied, “A young man by the name of Stuart. “15 Visitors and reviewers praised the portrait’s unusual pose and Stuart’s ability with likeness. Sir John Cullum commented on the novelty of the theme in his letter of 1 May 1782 to Frederick Hervey, Bishop of Derry and Earl of Bristol. “One would have thought that almost every attitude of a single Figure had long been exhausted in this land of portrait painting but one is now exhibited which I recollect not before—it is that of Skating. There is a noble portrait large as life thus exhibited and which produces the most powerful effect.”16 A reviewer for the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser commented on 30 April that “Stuart and Opie, whose merits were not so generally known, have proved themselves able artists” and praised Stuart for his “striking likenesses.”17 Stuart’s ability to capture a likeness was borne out by Charles Fraser’s later comment to artist William Dunlap that the picture attracted so much comment that Stuart was “afraid to go to the academy to meet the looks and answer the inquiries of the multitude. Mr. Grant went one day to the exhibition, dressed as his portrait represented him; the original was immediately recognized, when the crowd followed him so closely that he was compelled to make his retreat, for every one was exclaiming, ‘There he is, there is the gentleman.’”18

 

Opinion was divided on the technique of the painting. One reviewer said that “Mr. Stuart seldom fails of a Likeness; but wants Freedom of Pencil, and Elegance of Taste.”19 However, the author of a letter in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser noted, “ Mr. Stuart… may be said to be an acquisition to the public; his Gentleman seating, No. 190, is reposed, animated and well drawn.”20 And a critic in the London Courant commented on the portrait as Stuart’s first attempt at a full-length. “If we have been informed aright this is the gentleman’s first essay in this branch of the art ; at all events it does honour to his pencil, from the novelty of the design and the neatness of the execution.”21 A commentator in 1795 wrote about Stuart’s early difficulty with a portrait of this size.

 

It is now some years since Stuart the portrait painter … painted a portrait of a Mr. Grant in the action of skating; this portrait was given in so spirited an attitude and with so appropriate a character that when it was exhibited, it established the fame of the artist, of whom his brethren had before that time said he made a tolerable likeness of a face, but as to the figure he could not get below the fifth button.22

 

The combination of the full-length portrait with the act of skating was indeed a novel theme. Stuart appropriately portrayed Grant as a figure skater, the version of the sport popular in England, which emphasized graceful and refined movements, instead of as a Scottish speed skater, which encouraged skill, speed, and competition. Grant wears skates designed for the “small pivots and graceful maneuvers which were essential to the art of figure skating.”23 Robert Jones, in his influential Treatise on Skating (London, 1772), recommended a similar crossedarm pose as “a proper attitude for genteel rolling” (Figure 2).24 Matthew HarrisJouett in 1816 quoted Stuart on “the importance of keeping the figure in its circle of motion, “ giving the example of “his famous skaiting picture of Grant as contrasted with Buckminster Preble who turns his body one way his neck another and his eyes another…. “25

 

The painting is unlike other images of skaters, which belong to the tradition of sporting scenes. They include Irish painter Robert Healy’s Tom Conolly and his Friends Skating (1768, private collection, Ireland), Sir Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker Skating on Duddingston Loch (c. 1784, National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh), Thomas Rowlandson’s watercolor Skaters on the Serpentine of 1784 (National Museum of Wales, Cardiff), and a view by Julius Caesar Ibbetson engraved in 1787 as Winter Amusement; A View in Hyde Park from the Moated Housed Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg’s A Winter Morning, with a Party Skating of 1776 is particularly close to Stuart’s and West’s images in that it shows skating figures similar to those who perform the Serpentine Greeting. And like de Loutherbourg’s scene, Benjamin West’s undated drawing Skateing focuses its action on the popular Serpentine river. In the background is a structure similar to the Cheesecake House, a refreshment lodge that is also seen in the images by Rowlandson and Ibbetson. De Loutherbourg’s scene, which includes portraits of the artist and his wife, the artist’s partner V.M. Picot and others, was the best known of the various images of skaters made before or at the time that Stuart painted his portrait of Grant. It was reproduced by Matthew Boulton’s picture manufactory in Birmingham, England, between 1776 and 1780 by an unusual reproductive process that replicated paintings with their original coloring. In the mid-1780s a cloth merchant and amateur painter named Joseph Booth revived the idea of reproducing the painting by using a “polygraph process.” Numerous color reproductions of de Loutherbourg’s Winter Morning survive.27

 

Art historian William Pressly has proposed an interpretation of The Skater as expressing the theme of melancholy. To Pressly, the “recently revived tradition of the melancholy hero” explains the somber coloration of the painting, the darkly shaded eyes of the skater, and the use of a crossed-arm pose. In this view the painting becomes a self-portrait of Stuart’s own tendency toward melancholy. The snowy setting is appropriate in this theory, since winter was traditionally associated with melancholia.28 One might even suggest that Stuart included himself as the man on the right who stands under a tree. The physiognomy of this spectator, with his long nose and angular chin, closely resembles Stuart’s self-portrait of around 1786. Whether the association of the mood and the season necessarily points to melancholy as the subject of the painting is uncertain, even though the connection of the two was well known at the time and had been developed in verse many years earlier by the English poet James Thomson in his poem “Winter” in The Seasons (1730). “Winter” itself could be the theme, rather than “melancholy.” As Jules Prown has pointed out, “The skater evokes an allegorical image of Winter as one of the Four Seasons. “29 Lines from Thomson’s “Winter” form the caption for a late eighteenth-century English mezzotint titled “Winter,” which shows three warmly dressed figures walking near the Serpentine, where skaters can be seen in the background. “While every work of man is laid at rest, “ they “swoop on sounding skates a thousand different ways” and the “land is madden’d all to joy” (“Winter,” verses 761, 769, 771).30 The allusion to the mood of the season indicates that Stuart had absorbed the highly sophisticated London practice of borrowing from literary works for the subject matter of portraits.

 

Stuart was also absorbing lessons on technique. The portrait is a masterpiece of the late eighteenth-century British style of portraiture, which focuses on the figure, particularly the face, by painting the background with less detail. X-radiography shows that Stuart, when painting Grant’s face, had not yet developed the fully calligraphic brushwork for which he is known in his later paintings. Here he shaped the eyes, nose, mouth, and shadow of the nose by drawing the features with the brush. Later he would not follow the outline of the individual features as closely. Stuart also used more white pigment in the transitional flesh tones than he would in later works. X-radiography suggests, not surprisingly, that Stuart painted the background after completing the figure; the brushstrokes of the clouds mark the outer edges of the hat, face, and shoulders, which were already blocked out and painted. In addition, close examination of the painting reveals changes, or pentimenti, in the hat, shoulders, tail of the coat, and sitter’s right leg, indicating that Stuart did indeed struggle with the challenge inherent in a full-length, a size he rarely agreed to use again in his long career.

 

EGM

 

Notes

 

1.The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke 1956, 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Glinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Glinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

2.According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

3.Royal Academy 1878, unpaginated; Graves 1913, 1:383,3:1275; Graves 1905,71296. For a discussion of the attribution of the portrait in 1878 to Gainsborough, and the Grant family’s research to determine Stuart’s authorship, see Whitley 1932,33-36.

4.Quincy 1883,84, who does not identify the picture.

5.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Fraser heard the story from Stuart. John Gait had by then published his story about Benjamin West as a skater; see Gait 1820, 2:26-31. Gait told how, when West was a young artist in London in the 17605, his skating skills had brought him to the attention of the English aristocracy. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the similarity of the two anecdotes.

6.Hayes 1990, 64.

7.Button 1973, 354.

8.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87; since Jouett never saw the portrait, his description must be a quotation from Stuart.

9.Faculty of Advocates 1944, 90, courtesy of Dr. Louise Yeoman, Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh.

10.Alexander Grant is mentioned in Stuart 1877, 642; see also Stuart 1967,14.

11.Ward and Roberts 1904, 2:63-64. The earlier portrait of Grant by Romney was sold by Georgiana Bordewich, former owner of The Skater, at Christie’s on 22 March 1974 (lot 96) and bought by Léger Galleries; see Léger Galleries 1975, unpaginated, no. 5. Mrs. Bordewich also sold a portrait said to be of Grant by Thomas Hudson (lot 94), 127 by 101.6 cm (50 by 40 inches), and the portrait of his four eldest children, attributed to Opie (lot 95). The portrait of Mrs. Grant remained in Romney’s studio and was sold at Romney’s sale in 1807.

12.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Jouett referred to Baretti’s “mistaking it for Wests best production” when he recorded Stuart’s comments about painting in 1816; see Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87.

13.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

14.Whitley 1932,32.

15.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

16.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, and Pressly 1986, 44, from Childe-Pemberton 1925,1:284.

17.“Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition,” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser, 30 April 1782, 3.

18.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

19.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

20.The letter from the correspondent, identified as “Candid,” was published in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser on 9 May 1782, 2.

21.Quoted in Whitley 1932, 33, from an unidentified issue.

22.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, from an unidentified source.

23.Pearson 1987, 59.

24.Pressly 1986, 48; Pearson 1987, 60, 62, fig. 8.

25.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 86.

26.For three of these paintings see Hayes 1990, 64-66, no. 19, color repro.; and Pearson 1987, 57 fig. 2 and 61 fig. 7.

27.de Loutherbourg 1973, unpaginated, cat. no. 22. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the significance of this image for Stuart’s and West’s works.

28.Pressly 1986, 42-51.

29.Prown 1969, 48.

30.Quoted in Button 1973, 355, fig. 4.

 

References

 

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 30 April: 3.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post. 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 9 May: 2.

•1816—Jouett: 86, 87.

•1834—Dunlap: 1:183-184.

•1846—Lester: 126.

•1877—Stuart: 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (12 January): 50.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (19 January): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (26 January): 91.

•1879—Mason: 187-190.

•1880—MFA: 41, no.268.

•1883—Quincy: 84.

•1926—Park: 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley: 15, 31-36.

•1961—Oswald: 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount: 69-74.

•1969—Prown: 47-48.

•1973—Button: 351-3 62, color cover repro.

•1980—Evans: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding: 50, color repro .51.

•1981—Waterson: 872 repro.

•1981—Williams: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986—Pressly: 42-51, fig.1.

•1986—McLanathan: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1987—Pearson: 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding: 58-59, color repro.

•1990—Crean: 55-62.

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

West Building, Main Floor—Gallery 59

 

•Date: 1782

•Medium: Oil on Canvas

•Dimensions:

oOverall: 245.5 × 147.4 cm (96⅝ × 58 1/16 in.)

oFramed: 274.3 × 177.2 × 9.5 cm (108 × 69¾ × 3¾ in.)

•Credit Line: Andrew W. Mellon Collection

•Accession Number: 1950.18.1

•Artists/Makers

oPainter: Gilbert Stuart, American, 1755-1828

 

Overview

 

In 1775, Gilbert Stuart set sail for London where Benjamin West welcomed the destitute young man into his home. The Skater marks the end of his five-year apprenticeship to West. Stuart’s first effort at full-length portraiture, its originality brought the artist so much notice at the 1782 Royal Academy exhibition that he soon set up his own studio.

 

The unorthodox motif of skating—indeed, any presentation of vigorous movement at all—had absolutely no precedent in Britain’s “Grand Manner” tradition of life-size society portraiture. The painter recalled that when William Grant, from Congalton near Edinburgh, arrived to have his picture painted, the Scottish sitter remarked that, “on account of the excessive coldness of the weather … the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait.” Thus artist and sitter went off to skate on the Serpentine River in Hyde Park. When he returned to West’s studio with Grant, Stuart conceived the idea of portraying his subject on ice skates in a winter landscape, with the twin towers of Westminster Abbey far in the distance.

 

In this innovative design, Grant glides effortlessly forward with arms crossed over his chest in typical eighteenth-century skating form. Except for his folded arms, the figure’s stance derives from an ancient Roman statue, the Apollo Belvedere, a cast of which stood in the corner of West’s studio.

 

Provenance

 

The sitter, William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son, William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter, Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];[1] her son, Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;[2] his widow, Elizabeth Pelham-Clinton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter, Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Clinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913] London; sold 1950 to the NGA.

 

[1]The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke’s Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Peerage, Baronetage and Knightage, Privy Council and Order of Precedence, 101st ed., London, 1956: 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Clinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Clinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

[2]According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA curatorial file), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

 

Associated Names

 

•Clinton, Pelham, Miss

•Grant, William

•Grant, William

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton, Mrs.

•Pelham-Clinton, Elizabeth

 

Exhibition History

 

•1782—Royal Academy, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating

•1878—Exhibition of Works by Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough

•1946—American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206

•1963—Style, Truth, and the Portrait, Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38

•1967—Gilbert Stuart, Portraitist of the Young Republic, 1755-1828, National Gallery of Art; Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design, Providence, 1967, no. 8

•1976—American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44

•1981—American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; National Portrait Gallery, Washington, D.C., 1981-1982, no. 21.

•2001—Great British Paintings from American Collections: Holbein to Hockney, Yale Center for British Art, New Haven; The Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens, San Marino, 2001-2002, no. 35, repro.

•2004—Gilbert Stuart, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; National Gallery of Art (for the National Portrait Gallery), Washington, D.C., 2004-2005, no. 6, repro.

 

Bibliography

 

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (9 May 1782): 2.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (30 April 1782): 3.

•1816—Jouett, Matthew Harris. “Notes Taken by M. H. Jouett while in Boston from Conversations on painting with Gilbert Stuart Esqr.” Manuscript, published in Gilbert Stuart and His Pupils, by John Hill Morgan. New York, 1816: 86, 87.

•1846—Lester, C. Edwards. The Artists of America. New York, 1846: 126.

•1869—Dunlap, William. A History of the Rise and Progress of The Arts of Design in the United States. 2 vols. Reprinted in 3. New York, 1969 (1834): 1:183-184.

•1877—Stuart, Jane. “The Youth of Gilbert Stuart.” Scribner’s Monthly 13, no. 5 (March 1877): 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (January 19, 1878): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (January 26, 1878): 91.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (January 12, 1878): 50.

•1879—Mason, George C. The Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1879: 187-190.

•1880—”Portraits Painted by Stuart...taken from Mason’s Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart.” In Exhibition of Portraits Painted by Gilbert Stuart. Exh. cat. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 1880: 41, no. 268.

•1883—Quincy, Josiah. Figures of the Past from the Leaves of Old Journals. 4th ed. Boston, 1883: 84.

•1926—Park 1926, 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley, William T. Artists and Their Friends in England, 1700-1800. 2 vols. London and Boston, 1928: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley, William T. Gilbert Stuart. Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1932: 15, 31-36.

•1952 Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds., Great Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1952: 138, color repro., as The Skater.

•1956 Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1956: 50, color repro., as The Skater.

•1957—Shapley, Fern Rusk. Comparisons in Art: A Companion to the National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. London, 1957 (reprinted 1959): pl. 91.

•1961—Oswald, Arthur. “Our Ancestors on the Ice.” Country Life 129 (9 February 1961): 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount, Charles Merrill. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1964: 69-74.

•1966—Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds. A Pageant of Painting from the National Gallery of Art. 2 vols. New York, 1966: 2:380, color repro.

•1969—Novak, Barbara. American Painting of the Nineteenth Century: Realism, Idealism, and the American Experience. 2nd ed. New York, 1979: 32, fig. 1.17.

•1969—Prown, Jules David. American Painting, From its Beginnings to the Armory Show. Geneva, 1969: 47-48.

•1970—American Paintings and Sculpture: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1970: 106, repro., as The Skater.

•1973—Button, Dick. “The Art of Skating.” Antiques 103, no. 2 (February 1973): 351-362, color repro. on cover.

•1973—Finley, David Edward. A Standard of Excellence: Andrew W. Mellon Founds the National Gallery of Art at Washington. Washington, 1973: 135.

•1975—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1975: 380, color repro. 381.

•1978—King, Marian. Adventures in Art: National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C. New York, 1978: 54, pl. 31.

•1980—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1980: 234, repro.

•1980—Evans, Dorinda. Benjamin West and His American Students. Exh. cat. National Portrait Gallery, Washington; Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, Philadelphia. Washington, 1980: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1980: 10, no. 6, color repro.

•1981—Waterson, Merlin. “Hissing Along the Polished Ice.” Country Life 169 (2 April 1981): repro. 872.

•1981—Williams, William James. A Heritage of American Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1981: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. Rev. ed. New York, 1984: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986 McLanathan, Richard. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1986: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1986—Pressly, William L. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater: An Essay in Romantic Melancholy.” American Art Journal 18, no. 1, 1986: 42-51, fig. 1.

•1987—Pearson, Andrea G. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater (Portrait of William Grant) and Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker, D.D., Skating on Duddington Loch: A Study of Sources.” Rutgers Art Review 8 (1987): 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. Rev. ed. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1988: 58-59, no. 6, color repro.

•1990—Crean, Hugh R. Gilbert Stuart and the politics of fine arts patronage in Ireland, 1787-1793; A social and cultural study. Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1990: 55-62.

•1992—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 345, repro.

•1992—National Gallery of Art, Washington. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 214, repro.

•1995—Miles, Ellen G. American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century. The Collections of the National Gallery of Art Systematic Catalogue. Washington, D.C., 1995: 162-169, color repro. 165.

•1997—Hughes, Robert. American Visions: The Epic History of Art in America. New York, 1997: 128, color fig. 81.

•1997—Thomson, Duncan. Raeburn: The Art of Sir Henry Raeburn 1756-1823, Exh. cat. Scottish National Portrait Gallery at the Royal Scottish Academy, Edinburgh; National Portrait Gallery, London, 1997-1998, p. 90, no. 61, repro.

•1998—Mandel, Corinne. “Melancholy.” In Encyclopedia of Comparative Iconography: Themes Depicted in Works of Art, edited by Helene E. Roberts. 2 vols. Chicago, 1998: 2:586-588.

•2004—Hand, John Oliver. National Gallery of Art: Master Paintings from the Collection. Washington and New York, 2004: 294-295, no. 240, color repro.

•2011—Gopnik, Adam. Winter: Four Windows on the Season. Toronto, 2011: 142-143, color repro.

•2013—Evans, Dorinda. Gilbert Stuart and the Impact of Manic Depression. Burlington, 2013: 162-164, 168 nn. 36 and 37, fig. 11.

•2016—Rather, Susan. The American School: Artists and Status in the Late Colonial and Early National Era. New Haven, 2016: 171-172, color fig. 125.

  

From American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century:

 

1950.18.1 (1051)

 

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

•1782

•Oil on Canvas, 244.5 × 147.4 (96¼ × 58)

•Andrew W. Mellon Collection

 

Technical Notes

 

The support is a finely woven twill fabric. The top and bottom tacking edges have been unfolded and add about 6 cm to the painting’s height. The lateral tacking margins have been cropped, but cusping remains along these edges. The thin white ground extends to cover the tacking margins, suggesting that the canvas was pre-primed. Much of the preliminary drawing, done loosely with paint and brush, is visible on the surface, having been incorporated into the painting. The paint is thinly applied, except in the sitter’s upper body, face, and collar, and in the sky around his head, where the paint is thicker and its handling more controlled. Many pentimenti are evident, including changes in the figure’s hat, shoulders, tail of the coat on the viewer’s right, and the sitter’s right leg.

 

Abrasion is found in the ice at the sitter’s feet. Crackle is more pronounced near the head, where the paint is thicker, and is especially pronounced to the right of the skater’s thigh. There are pinpoint losses throughout. The painting was lined prior to 1950.

 

Provenance

 

William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];1 her son Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;2 his widow Elizabeth Pelham-Clin ton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Glinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913], London.

 

Exhibited

 

Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating. Exhibition of Works by the Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James3s Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough.3 American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206. Style, Truth and the Portrait, The Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38. Gilbert Stuart, NGA; RISD, 1967, no. 8. American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, YUAG; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44. American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; NGA, 1981-1982, no. 21.

 

In 1782 Gilbert Stuart, a young painter in London, was “suddenly lifted into fame by the exhibition of a single picture,”4 his full-length of William Grant called Portrait of a Gentleman Skating. (The painting was given its present title of The Skater m 1946.) Stuart devised the theme after an outing on the Serpentine river in Hyde Park with Grant, a young Scottish lawyer, who had come for a sitting for a full-length portrait. According to American artist William Dunlap, who heard the story from miniaturist Charles Fraser,

 

Stuart said that he felt great diffidence in undertaking a whole length; but that there must be a beginning, and a day was accordingly appointed for Mr. Grant to sit. On entering the artist’s room, he regretted the appointment, on account of the excessive coldness of the weather, and observed to Stuart, that the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait. To this the painter assented, and they both sallied out to their morning’s amusement. Stuart said that early practice had made him very expert in skating. His celerity and activity accordingly attracted crowds on the Serpentine river—which was the scene of their sport. His companion, although a well-made and graceful man, was not as active as himself; and there being a crack in the ice, which made it dangerous to continue their amusement, he told Mr. Grant to hold the skirt of his coat, and follow him off the field. They returned to Mr. Stuart’s rooms, where it occurred to him to paint Mr. Grant in the attitude of skating, with the appendage of a winter scene, in the back ground.5

 

The setting for the portrait is the Serpentine, a popular skating spot in London that was created when Kensington Gardens was landscaped during the reign of George II.6 Grant is dressed completely in black, from his hat and the fur-lined lapels of his coat to his breeches, stockings, and shoes. Behind him to the right two skaters sit at the edge of the ice, putting on their skates, while two other men stand under a tree. In the left background two skaters perform the Salutation, also known as the Serpentine Greeting, while others watch.7 The painting offers a balance of black, gray, and off-white, with slight touches of red on the clothing of the background figures. Stuart’s pupil Matthew Harris Jouett later described the portrait as a “fine contrast of Grant in full black to the snow & grey chilly background.”8 The young lawyer William Grant (d. 1821) was the son of Ludovick Grant of Edinburgh.9 Why he chose Stuart to paint his portrait is not known ; perhaps he was a friend or a distant relative of Stuart’s early London patron Alexander Grant, also a Scot.10 Moderately wealthy, Grant was fond of portraits. George Romney painted him in 1781 and again in 1787, and in 1794 he painted “ Mrs. Grant, “ perhaps Grant’s wife Dorothea Dalrymple, whom he married that year. Grant’s children were painted by John Opie (LaSalle University Art Museum, Philadelphia).11 At his death in 1821, Grant left his heirs a large estate called Congalton, in Scotland, as well as stock in the Bank of England and the Royal Bank of Scotland.

 

The portrait, Stuart’s first full-length, showed his ability to invent new compositions within the tradition of English portraiture, in which standing cross-legged poses had been popular for men’s portraits since the 17405. Its success made it possible for Stuart to move from West’s studio into one of his own. Comparisons between the two American artists by contemporaries were inevitable. When Giuseppi Baretti, an Italian-born lexicographer, author, and friend of Sir Joshua Reynolds, saw the painting at West’s before its exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts, he commented, according to Dunlap, “What a charming picture ! Who but the great West could have painted such a one ! “ Later, seeing Stuart at work on the painting, he exclaimed, “What, young man, does Mr. West permit you to touch his pictures?” Stuart replied that it was his own painting. Baretti is supposed to have said, “Why, it is almost as good as Mr. West can paint.”12 The close association of the two men’s work is revealed by an undated chalk drawing by West titled Skateing. West, like Stuart, enjoyed a reputation as a good skater, and in this chalk drawing depicted skaters and spectators on the ice at the Serpentine. A skater in the center foreground turns toward the man behind him, who lies on the ice after a fall. To the left, two figures who perform the Serpentine Greeting are virtually identical to the two skaters in the background of Stuart’s portrait of Grant. To the right is a small figure whose pose seems similar to Grant’s; the figure is very sketchy.

 

A reviewer noted Stuart’s relationship to Benjamin West when Stuart exhibited the painting with three others at the Royal Academy of Arts in 1782.

 

Mr. Stuart is in Partnership with Mr. West; where it is not uncommon for Wits to divert themselves with Applications for Things they do not immediately want; because they are told by Mr. West that Mr. Stuart is the only Portrait Painter in the World; and by Mr. Stuart that no Man has any Pretensions in History Painting but Mr. West. After such Authority what can we say of Mr. Stuart’s Painting.13

 

The portrait enchanted visitors who attended the Academy’s exhibition. Horace Walpole, author of Anecdotes of Painting in England (1762-1771), the first history of British art, wrote “very good” next to the entry for the portrait in his copy of the catalogue.14 Stuart overheard the Duke of Rutland on opening day, urging Sir Joshua Reynolds, “I wish you would go to the exhibition with me, for there is a portrait there which you must see, every body is enchanted with it.” When Sir Joshua asked who painted it, the Duke replied, “A young man by the name of Stuart. “15 Visitors and reviewers praised the portrait’s unusual pose and Stuart’s ability with likeness. Sir John Cullum commented on the novelty of the theme in his letter of 1 May 1782 to Frederick Hervey, Bishop of Derry and Earl of Bristol. “One would have thought that almost every attitude of a single Figure had long been exhausted in this land of portrait painting but one is now exhibited which I recollect not before—it is that of Skating. There is a noble portrait large as life thus exhibited and which produces the most powerful effect.”16 A reviewer for the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser commented on 30 April that “Stuart and Opie, whose merits were not so generally known, have proved themselves able artists” and praised Stuart for his “striking likenesses.”17 Stuart’s ability to capture a likeness was borne out by Charles Fraser’s later comment to artist William Dunlap that the picture attracted so much comment that Stuart was “afraid to go to the academy to meet the looks and answer the inquiries of the multitude. Mr. Grant went one day to the exhibition, dressed as his portrait represented him; the original was immediately recognized, when the crowd followed him so closely that he was compelled to make his retreat, for every one was exclaiming, ‘There he is, there is the gentleman.’”18

 

Opinion was divided on the technique of the painting. One reviewer said that “Mr. Stuart seldom fails of a Likeness; but wants Freedom of Pencil, and Elegance of Taste.”19 However, the author of a letter in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser noted, “ Mr. Stuart… may be said to be an acquisition to the public; his Gentleman seating, No. 190, is reposed, animated and well drawn.”20 And a critic in the London Courant commented on the portrait as Stuart’s first attempt at a full-length. “If we have been informed aright this is the gentleman’s first essay in this branch of the art ; at all events it does honour to his pencil, from the novelty of the design and the neatness of the execution.”21 A commentator in 1795 wrote about Stuart’s early difficulty with a portrait of this size.

 

It is now some years since Stuart the portrait painter … painted a portrait of a Mr. Grant in the action of skating; this portrait was given in so spirited an attitude and with so appropriate a character that when it was exhibited, it established the fame of the artist, of whom his brethren had before that time said he made a tolerable likeness of a face, but as to the figure he could not get below the fifth button.22

 

The combination of the full-length portrait with the act of skating was indeed a novel theme. Stuart appropriately portrayed Grant as a figure skater, the version of the sport popular in England, which emphasized graceful and refined movements, instead of as a Scottish speed skater, which encouraged skill, speed, and competition. Grant wears skates designed for the “small pivots and graceful maneuvers which were essential to the art of figure skating.”23 Robert Jones, in his influential Treatise on Skating (London, 1772), recommended a similar crossedarm pose as “a proper attitude for genteel rolling” (Figure 2).24 Matthew HarrisJouett in 1816 quoted Stuart on “the importance of keeping the figure in its circle of motion, “ giving the example of “his famous skaiting picture of Grant as contrasted with Buckminster Preble who turns his body one way his neck another and his eyes another…. “25

 

The painting is unlike other images of skaters, which belong to the tradition of sporting scenes. They include Irish painter Robert Healy’s Tom Conolly and his Friends Skating (1768, private collection, Ireland), Sir Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker Skating on Duddingston Loch (c. 1784, National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh), Thomas Rowlandson’s watercolor Skaters on the Serpentine of 1784 (National Museum of Wales, Cardiff), and a view by Julius Caesar Ibbetson engraved in 1787 as Winter Amusement; A View in Hyde Park from the Moated Housed Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg’s A Winter Morning, with a Party Skating of 1776 is particularly close to Stuart’s and West’s images in that it shows skating figures similar to those who perform the Serpentine Greeting. And like de Loutherbourg’s scene, Benjamin West’s undated drawing Skateing focuses its action on the popular Serpentine river. In the background is a structure similar to the Cheesecake House, a refreshment lodge that is also seen in the images by Rowlandson and Ibbetson. De Loutherbourg’s scene, which includes portraits of the artist and his wife, the artist’s partner V.M. Picot and others, was the best known of the various images of skaters made before or at the time that Stuart painted his portrait of Grant. It was reproduced by Matthew Boulton’s picture manufactory in Birmingham, England, between 1776 and 1780 by an unusual reproductive process that replicated paintings with their original coloring. In the mid-1780s a cloth merchant and amateur painter named Joseph Booth revived the idea of reproducing the painting by using a “polygraph process.” Numerous color reproductions of de Loutherbourg’s Winter Morning survive.27

 

Art historian William Pressly has proposed an interpretation of The Skater as expressing the theme of melancholy. To Pressly, the “recently revived tradition of the melancholy hero” explains the somber coloration of the painting, the darkly shaded eyes of the skater, and the use of a crossed-arm pose. In this view the painting becomes a self-portrait of Stuart’s own tendency toward melancholy. The snowy setting is appropriate in this theory, since winter was traditionally associated with melancholia.28 One might even suggest that Stuart included himself as the man on the right who stands under a tree. The physiognomy of this spectator, with his long nose and angular chin, closely resembles Stuart’s self-portrait of around 1786. Whether the association of the mood and the season necessarily points to melancholy as the subject of the painting is uncertain, even though the connection of the two was well known at the time and had been developed in verse many years earlier by the English poet James Thomson in his poem “Winter” in The Seasons (1730). “Winter” itself could be the theme, rather than “melancholy.” As Jules Prown has pointed out, “The skater evokes an allegorical image of Winter as one of the Four Seasons. “29 Lines from Thomson’s “Winter” form the caption for a late eighteenth-century English mezzotint titled “Winter,” which shows three warmly dressed figures walking near the Serpentine, where skaters can be seen in the background. “While every work of man is laid at rest, “ they “swoop on sounding skates a thousand different ways” and the “land is madden’d all to joy” (“Winter,” verses 761, 769, 771).30 The allusion to the mood of the season indicates that Stuart had absorbed the highly sophisticated London practice of borrowing from literary works for the subject matter of portraits.

 

Stuart was also absorbing lessons on technique. The portrait is a masterpiece of the late eighteenth-century British style of portraiture, which focuses on the figure, particularly the face, by painting the background with less detail. X-radiography shows that Stuart, when painting Grant’s face, had not yet developed the fully calligraphic brushwork for which he is known in his later paintings. Here he shaped the eyes, nose, mouth, and shadow of the nose by drawing the features with the brush. Later he would not follow the outline of the individual features as closely. Stuart also used more white pigment in the transitional flesh tones than he would in later works. X-radiography suggests, not surprisingly, that Stuart painted the background after completing the figure; the brushstrokes of the clouds mark the outer edges of the hat, face, and shoulders, which were already blocked out and painted. In addition, close examination of the painting reveals changes, or pentimenti, in the hat, shoulders, tail of the coat, and sitter’s right leg, indicating that Stuart did indeed struggle with the challenge inherent in a full-length, a size he rarely agreed to use again in his long career.

 

EGM

 

Notes

 

1.The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke 1956, 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Glinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Glinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

2.According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

3.Royal Academy 1878, unpaginated; Graves 1913, 1:383,3:1275; Graves 1905,71296. For a discussion of the attribution of the portrait in 1878 to Gainsborough, and the Grant family’s research to determine Stuart’s authorship, see Whitley 1932,33-36.

4.Quincy 1883,84, who does not identify the picture.

5.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Fraser heard the story from Stuart. John Gait had by then published his story about Benjamin West as a skater; see Gait 1820, 2:26-31. Gait told how, when West was a young artist in London in the 17605, his skating skills had brought him to the attention of the English aristocracy. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the similarity of the two anecdotes.

6.Hayes 1990, 64.

7.Button 1973, 354.

8.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87; since Jouett never saw the portrait, his description must be a quotation from Stuart.

9.Faculty of Advocates 1944, 90, courtesy of Dr. Louise Yeoman, Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh.

10.Alexander Grant is mentioned in Stuart 1877, 642; see also Stuart 1967,14.

11.Ward and Roberts 1904, 2:63-64. The earlier portrait of Grant by Romney was sold by Georgiana Bordewich, former owner of The Skater, at Christie’s on 22 March 1974 (lot 96) and bought by Léger Galleries; see Léger Galleries 1975, unpaginated, no. 5. Mrs. Bordewich also sold a portrait said to be of Grant by Thomas Hudson (lot 94), 127 by 101.6 cm (50 by 40 inches), and the portrait of his four eldest children, attributed to Opie (lot 95). The portrait of Mrs. Grant remained in Romney’s studio and was sold at Romney’s sale in 1807.

12.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Jouett referred to Baretti’s “mistaking it for Wests best production” when he recorded Stuart’s comments about painting in 1816; see Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87.

13.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

14.Whitley 1932,32.

15.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

16.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, and Pressly 1986, 44, from Childe-Pemberton 1925,1:284.

17.“Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition,” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser, 30 April 1782, 3.

18.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

19.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

20.The letter from the correspondent, identified as “Candid,” was published in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser on 9 May 1782, 2.

21.Quoted in Whitley 1932, 33, from an unidentified issue.

22.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, from an unidentified source.

23.Pearson 1987, 59.

24.Pressly 1986, 48; Pearson 1987, 60, 62, fig. 8.

25.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 86.

26.For three of these paintings see Hayes 1990, 64-66, no. 19, color repro.; and Pearson 1987, 57 fig. 2 and 61 fig. 7.

27.de Loutherbourg 1973, unpaginated, cat. no. 22. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the significance of this image for Stuart’s and West’s works.

28.Pressly 1986, 42-51.

29.Prown 1969, 48.

30.Quoted in Button 1973, 355, fig. 4.

 

References

 

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 30 April: 3.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post. 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 9 May: 2.

•1816—Jouett: 86, 87.

•1834—Dunlap: 1:183-184.

•1846—Lester: 126.

•1877—Stuart: 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (12 January): 50.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (19 January): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (26 January): 91.

•1879—Mason: 187-190.

•1880—MFA: 41, no.268.

•1883—Quincy: 84.

•1926—Park: 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley: 15, 31-36.

•1961—Oswald: 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount: 69-74.

•1969—Prown: 47-48.

•1973—Button: 351-3 62, color cover repro.

•1980—Evans: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding: 50, color repro .51.

•1981—Waterson: 872 repro.

•1981—Williams: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986—Pressly: 42-51, fig.1.

•1986—McLanathan: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1987—Pearson: 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding: 58-59, color repro.

•1990—Crean: 55-62.

AFTER ACTION REPORT:

Sgt. Baretti returned to base after her daily patrol with GPS coordinates where she found the skull and partial skeleton of a massive predator. Also reported encounter with a small but very loud herd of large herbivorous dinosaurs.

 

Sgt. Baretti punched duty Sgt. Carter upon her return, knocking him out. Sgt. Carter is still unconscious. Sgt. Baretti released on her own recognizance because nobody likes Sgt. Carter anyway.

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

West Building, Main Floor—Gallery 59

 

•Date: 1782

•Medium: Oil on Canvas

•Dimensions:

oOverall: 245.5 × 147.4 cm (96⅝ × 58 1/16 in.)

oFramed: 274.3 × 177.2 × 9.5 cm (108 × 69¾ × 3¾ in.)

•Credit Line: Andrew W. Mellon Collection

•Accession Number: 1950.18.1

•Artists/Makers

oPainter: Gilbert Stuart, American, 1755-1828

 

Overview

 

In 1775, Gilbert Stuart set sail for London where Benjamin West welcomed the destitute young man into his home. The Skater marks the end of his five-year apprenticeship to West. Stuart’s first effort at full-length portraiture, its originality brought the artist so much notice at the 1782 Royal Academy exhibition that he soon set up his own studio.

 

The unorthodox motif of skating—indeed, any presentation of vigorous movement at all—had absolutely no precedent in Britain’s “Grand Manner” tradition of life-size society portraiture. The painter recalled that when William Grant, from Congalton near Edinburgh, arrived to have his picture painted, the Scottish sitter remarked that, “on account of the excessive coldness of the weather … the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait.” Thus artist and sitter went off to skate on the Serpentine River in Hyde Park. When he returned to West’s studio with Grant, Stuart conceived the idea of portraying his subject on ice skates in a winter landscape, with the twin towers of Westminster Abbey far in the distance.

 

In this innovative design, Grant glides effortlessly forward with arms crossed over his chest in typical eighteenth-century skating form. Except for his folded arms, the figure’s stance derives from an ancient Roman statue, the Apollo Belvedere, a cast of which stood in the corner of West’s studio.

 

Provenance

 

The sitter, William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son, William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter, Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];[1] her son, Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;[2] his widow, Elizabeth Pelham-Clinton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter, Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Clinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913] London; sold 1950 to the NGA.

 

[1]The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke’s Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Peerage, Baronetage and Knightage, Privy Council and Order of Precedence, 101st ed., London, 1956: 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Clinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Clinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

[2]According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA curatorial file), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

 

Associated Names

 

•Clinton, Pelham, Miss

•Grant, William

•Grant, William

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton, Mrs.

•Pelham-Clinton, Elizabeth

 

Exhibition History

 

•1782—Royal Academy, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating

•1878—Exhibition of Works by Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough

•1946—American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206

•1963—Style, Truth, and the Portrait, Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38

•1967—Gilbert Stuart, Portraitist of the Young Republic, 1755-1828, National Gallery of Art; Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design, Providence, 1967, no. 8

•1976—American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44

•1981—American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; National Portrait Gallery, Washington, D.C., 1981-1982, no. 21.

•2001—Great British Paintings from American Collections: Holbein to Hockney, Yale Center for British Art, New Haven; The Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens, San Marino, 2001-2002, no. 35, repro.

•2004—Gilbert Stuart, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; National Gallery of Art (for the National Portrait Gallery), Washington, D.C., 2004-2005, no. 6, repro.

 

Bibliography

 

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (9 May 1782): 2.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (30 April 1782): 3.

•1816—Jouett, Matthew Harris. “Notes Taken by M. H. Jouett while in Boston from Conversations on painting with Gilbert Stuart Esqr.” Manuscript, published in Gilbert Stuart and His Pupils, by John Hill Morgan. New York, 1816: 86, 87.

•1846—Lester, C. Edwards. The Artists of America. New York, 1846: 126.

•1869—Dunlap, William. A History of the Rise and Progress of The Arts of Design in the United States. 2 vols. Reprinted in 3. New York, 1969 (1834): 1:183-184.

•1877—Stuart, Jane. “The Youth of Gilbert Stuart.” Scribner’s Monthly 13, no. 5 (March 1877): 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (January 19, 1878): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (January 26, 1878): 91.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (January 12, 1878): 50.

•1879—Mason, George C. The Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1879: 187-190.

•1880—”Portraits Painted by Stuart...taken from Mason’s Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart.” In Exhibition of Portraits Painted by Gilbert Stuart. Exh. cat. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 1880: 41, no. 268.

•1883—Quincy, Josiah. Figures of the Past from the Leaves of Old Journals. 4th ed. Boston, 1883: 84.

•1926—Park 1926, 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley, William T. Artists and Their Friends in England, 1700-1800. 2 vols. London and Boston, 1928: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley, William T. Gilbert Stuart. Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1932: 15, 31-36.

•1952 Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds., Great Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1952: 138, color repro., as The Skater.

•1956 Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1956: 50, color repro., as The Skater.

•1957—Shapley, Fern Rusk. Comparisons in Art: A Companion to the National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. London, 1957 (reprinted 1959): pl. 91.

•1961—Oswald, Arthur. “Our Ancestors on the Ice.” Country Life 129 (9 February 1961): 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount, Charles Merrill. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1964: 69-74.

•1966—Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds. A Pageant of Painting from the National Gallery of Art. 2 vols. New York, 1966: 2:380, color repro.

•1969—Novak, Barbara. American Painting of the Nineteenth Century: Realism, Idealism, and the American Experience. 2nd ed. New York, 1979: 32, fig. 1.17.

•1969—Prown, Jules David. American Painting, From its Beginnings to the Armory Show. Geneva, 1969: 47-48.

•1970—American Paintings and Sculpture: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1970: 106, repro., as The Skater.

•1973—Button, Dick. “The Art of Skating.” Antiques 103, no. 2 (February 1973): 351-362, color repro. on cover.

•1973—Finley, David Edward. A Standard of Excellence: Andrew W. Mellon Founds the National Gallery of Art at Washington. Washington, 1973: 135.

•1975—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1975: 380, color repro. 381.

•1978—King, Marian. Adventures in Art: National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C. New York, 1978: 54, pl. 31.

•1980—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1980: 234, repro.

•1980—Evans, Dorinda. Benjamin West and His American Students. Exh. cat. National Portrait Gallery, Washington; Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, Philadelphia. Washington, 1980: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1980: 10, no. 6, color repro.

•1981—Waterson, Merlin. “Hissing Along the Polished Ice.” Country Life 169 (2 April 1981): repro. 872.

•1981—Williams, William James. A Heritage of American Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1981: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. Rev. ed. New York, 1984: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986 McLanathan, Richard. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1986: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1986—Pressly, William L. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater: An Essay in Romantic Melancholy.” American Art Journal 18, no. 1, 1986: 42-51, fig. 1.

•1987—Pearson, Andrea G. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater (Portrait of William Grant) and Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker, D.D., Skating on Duddington Loch: A Study of Sources.” Rutgers Art Review 8 (1987): 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. Rev. ed. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1988: 58-59, no. 6, color repro.

•1990—Crean, Hugh R. Gilbert Stuart and the politics of fine arts patronage in Ireland, 1787-1793; A social and cultural study. Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1990: 55-62.

•1992—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 345, repro.

•1992—National Gallery of Art, Washington. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 214, repro.

•1995—Miles, Ellen G. American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century. The Collections of the National Gallery of Art Systematic Catalogue. Washington, D.C., 1995: 162-169, color repro. 165.

•1997—Hughes, Robert. American Visions: The Epic History of Art in America. New York, 1997: 128, color fig. 81.

•1997—Thomson, Duncan. Raeburn: The Art of Sir Henry Raeburn 1756-1823, Exh. cat. Scottish National Portrait Gallery at the Royal Scottish Academy, Edinburgh; National Portrait Gallery, London, 1997-1998, p. 90, no. 61, repro.

•1998—Mandel, Corinne. “Melancholy.” In Encyclopedia of Comparative Iconography: Themes Depicted in Works of Art, edited by Helene E. Roberts. 2 vols. Chicago, 1998: 2:586-588.

•2004—Hand, John Oliver. National Gallery of Art: Master Paintings from the Collection. Washington and New York, 2004: 294-295, no. 240, color repro.

•2011—Gopnik, Adam. Winter: Four Windows on the Season. Toronto, 2011: 142-143, color repro.

•2013—Evans, Dorinda. Gilbert Stuart and the Impact of Manic Depression. Burlington, 2013: 162-164, 168 nn. 36 and 37, fig. 11.

•2016—Rather, Susan. The American School: Artists and Status in the Late Colonial and Early National Era. New Haven, 2016: 171-172, color fig. 125.

  

From American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century:

 

1950.18.1 (1051)

 

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

•1782

•Oil on Canvas, 244.5 × 147.4 (96¼ × 58)

•Andrew W. Mellon Collection

 

Technical Notes

 

The support is a finely woven twill fabric. The top and bottom tacking edges have been unfolded and add about 6 cm to the painting’s height. The lateral tacking margins have been cropped, but cusping remains along these edges. The thin white ground extends to cover the tacking margins, suggesting that the canvas was pre-primed. Much of the preliminary drawing, done loosely with paint and brush, is visible on the surface, having been incorporated into the painting. The paint is thinly applied, except in the sitter’s upper body, face, and collar, and in the sky around his head, where the paint is thicker and its handling more controlled. Many pentimenti are evident, including changes in the figure’s hat, shoulders, tail of the coat on the viewer’s right, and the sitter’s right leg.

 

Abrasion is found in the ice at the sitter’s feet. Crackle is more pronounced near the head, where the paint is thicker, and is especially pronounced to the right of the skater’s thigh. There are pinpoint losses throughout. The painting was lined prior to 1950.

 

Provenance

 

William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];1 her son Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;2 his widow Elizabeth Pelham-Clin ton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Glinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913], London.

 

Exhibited

 

Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating. Exhibition of Works by the Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James3s Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough.3 American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206. Style, Truth and the Portrait, The Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38. Gilbert Stuart, NGA; RISD, 1967, no. 8. American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, YUAG; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44. American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; NGA, 1981-1982, no. 21.

 

In 1782 Gilbert Stuart, a young painter in London, was “suddenly lifted into fame by the exhibition of a single picture,”4 his full-length of William Grant called Portrait of a Gentleman Skating. (The painting was given its present title of The Skater m 1946.) Stuart devised the theme after an outing on the Serpentine river in Hyde Park with Grant, a young Scottish lawyer, who had come for a sitting for a full-length portrait. According to American artist William Dunlap, who heard the story from miniaturist Charles Fraser,

 

Stuart said that he felt great diffidence in undertaking a whole length; but that there must be a beginning, and a day was accordingly appointed for Mr. Grant to sit. On entering the artist’s room, he regretted the appointment, on account of the excessive coldness of the weather, and observed to Stuart, that the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait. To this the painter assented, and they both sallied out to their morning’s amusement. Stuart said that early practice had made him very expert in skating. His celerity and activity accordingly attracted crowds on the Serpentine river—which was the scene of their sport. His companion, although a well-made and graceful man, was not as active as himself; and there being a crack in the ice, which made it dangerous to continue their amusement, he told Mr. Grant to hold the skirt of his coat, and follow him off the field. They returned to Mr. Stuart’s rooms, where it occurred to him to paint Mr. Grant in the attitude of skating, with the appendage of a winter scene, in the back ground.5

 

The setting for the portrait is the Serpentine, a popular skating spot in London that was created when Kensington Gardens was landscaped during the reign of George II.6 Grant is dressed completely in black, from his hat and the fur-lined lapels of his coat to his breeches, stockings, and shoes. Behind him to the right two skaters sit at the edge of the ice, putting on their skates, while two other men stand under a tree. In the left background two skaters perform the Salutation, also known as the Serpentine Greeting, while others watch.7 The painting offers a balance of black, gray, and off-white, with slight touches of red on the clothing of the background figures. Stuart’s pupil Matthew Harris Jouett later described the portrait as a “fine contrast of Grant in full black to the snow & grey chilly background.”8 The young lawyer William Grant (d. 1821) was the son of Ludovick Grant of Edinburgh.9 Why he chose Stuart to paint his portrait is not known ; perhaps he was a friend or a distant relative of Stuart’s early London patron Alexander Grant, also a Scot.10 Moderately wealthy, Grant was fond of portraits. George Romney painted him in 1781 and again in 1787, and in 1794 he painted “ Mrs. Grant, “ perhaps Grant’s wife Dorothea Dalrymple, whom he married that year. Grant’s children were painted by John Opie (LaSalle University Art Museum, Philadelphia).11 At his death in 1821, Grant left his heirs a large estate called Congalton, in Scotland, as well as stock in the Bank of England and the Royal Bank of Scotland.

 

The portrait, Stuart’s first full-length, showed his ability to invent new compositions within the tradition of English portraiture, in which standing cross-legged poses had been popular for men’s portraits since the 17405. Its success made it possible for Stuart to move from West’s studio into one of his own. Comparisons between the two American artists by contemporaries were inevitable. When Giuseppi Baretti, an Italian-born lexicographer, author, and friend of Sir Joshua Reynolds, saw the painting at West’s before its exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts, he commented, according to Dunlap, “What a charming picture ! Who but the great West could have painted such a one ! “ Later, seeing Stuart at work on the painting, he exclaimed, “What, young man, does Mr. West permit you to touch his pictures?” Stuart replied that it was his own painting. Baretti is supposed to have said, “Why, it is almost as good as Mr. West can paint.”12 The close association of the two men’s work is revealed by an undated chalk drawing by West titled Skateing. West, like Stuart, enjoyed a reputation as a good skater, and in this chalk drawing depicted skaters and spectators on the ice at the Serpentine. A skater in the center foreground turns toward the man behind him, who lies on the ice after a fall. To the left, two figures who perform the Serpentine Greeting are virtually identical to the two skaters in the background of Stuart’s portrait of Grant. To the right is a small figure whose pose seems similar to Grant’s; the figure is very sketchy.

 

A reviewer noted Stuart’s relationship to Benjamin West when Stuart exhibited the painting with three others at the Royal Academy of Arts in 1782.

 

Mr. Stuart is in Partnership with Mr. West; where it is not uncommon for Wits to divert themselves with Applications for Things they do not immediately want; because they are told by Mr. West that Mr. Stuart is the only Portrait Painter in the World; and by Mr. Stuart that no Man has any Pretensions in History Painting but Mr. West. After such Authority what can we say of Mr. Stuart’s Painting.13

 

The portrait enchanted visitors who attended the Academy’s exhibition. Horace Walpole, author of Anecdotes of Painting in England (1762-1771), the first history of British art, wrote “very good” next to the entry for the portrait in his copy of the catalogue.14 Stuart overheard the Duke of Rutland on opening day, urging Sir Joshua Reynolds, “I wish you would go to the exhibition with me, for there is a portrait there which you must see, every body is enchanted with it.” When Sir Joshua asked who painted it, the Duke replied, “A young man by the name of Stuart. “15 Visitors and reviewers praised the portrait’s unusual pose and Stuart’s ability with likeness. Sir John Cullum commented on the novelty of the theme in his letter of 1 May 1782 to Frederick Hervey, Bishop of Derry and Earl of Bristol. “One would have thought that almost every attitude of a single Figure had long been exhausted in this land of portrait painting but one is now exhibited which I recollect not before—it is that of Skating. There is a noble portrait large as life thus exhibited and which produces the most powerful effect.”16 A reviewer for the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser commented on 30 April that “Stuart and Opie, whose merits were not so generally known, have proved themselves able artists” and praised Stuart for his “striking likenesses.”17 Stuart’s ability to capture a likeness was borne out by Charles Fraser’s later comment to artist William Dunlap that the picture attracted so much comment that Stuart was “afraid to go to the academy to meet the looks and answer the inquiries of the multitude. Mr. Grant went one day to the exhibition, dressed as his portrait represented him; the original was immediately recognized, when the crowd followed him so closely that he was compelled to make his retreat, for every one was exclaiming, ‘There he is, there is the gentleman.’”18

 

Opinion was divided on the technique of the painting. One reviewer said that “Mr. Stuart seldom fails of a Likeness; but wants Freedom of Pencil, and Elegance of Taste.”19 However, the author of a letter in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser noted, “ Mr. Stuart… may be said to be an acquisition to the public; his Gentleman seating, No. 190, is reposed, animated and well drawn.”20 And a critic in the London Courant commented on the portrait as Stuart’s first attempt at a full-length. “If we have been informed aright this is the gentleman’s first essay in this branch of the art ; at all events it does honour to his pencil, from the novelty of the design and the neatness of the execution.”21 A commentator in 1795 wrote about Stuart’s early difficulty with a portrait of this size.

 

It is now some years since Stuart the portrait painter … painted a portrait of a Mr. Grant in the action of skating; this portrait was given in so spirited an attitude and with so appropriate a character that when it was exhibited, it established the fame of the artist, of whom his brethren had before that time said he made a tolerable likeness of a face, but as to the figure he could not get below the fifth button.22

 

The combination of the full-length portrait with the act of skating was indeed a novel theme. Stuart appropriately portrayed Grant as a figure skater, the version of the sport popular in England, which emphasized graceful and refined movements, instead of as a Scottish speed skater, which encouraged skill, speed, and competition. Grant wears skates designed for the “small pivots and graceful maneuvers which were essential to the art of figure skating.”23 Robert Jones, in his influential Treatise on Skating (London, 1772), recommended a similar crossedarm pose as “a proper attitude for genteel rolling” (Figure 2).24 Matthew HarrisJouett in 1816 quoted Stuart on “the importance of keeping the figure in its circle of motion, “ giving the example of “his famous skaiting picture of Grant as contrasted with Buckminster Preble who turns his body one way his neck another and his eyes another…. “25

 

The painting is unlike other images of skaters, which belong to the tradition of sporting scenes. They include Irish painter Robert Healy’s Tom Conolly and his Friends Skating (1768, private collection, Ireland), Sir Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker Skating on Duddingston Loch (c. 1784, National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh), Thomas Rowlandson’s watercolor Skaters on the Serpentine of 1784 (National Museum of Wales, Cardiff), and a view by Julius Caesar Ibbetson engraved in 1787 as Winter Amusement; A View in Hyde Park from the Moated Housed Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg’s A Winter Morning, with a Party Skating of 1776 is particularly close to Stuart’s and West’s images in that it shows skating figures similar to those who perform the Serpentine Greeting. And like de Loutherbourg’s scene, Benjamin West’s undated drawing Skateing focuses its action on the popular Serpentine river. In the background is a structure similar to the Cheesecake House, a refreshment lodge that is also seen in the images by Rowlandson and Ibbetson. De Loutherbourg’s scene, which includes portraits of the artist and his wife, the artist’s partner V.M. Picot and others, was the best known of the various images of skaters made before or at the time that Stuart painted his portrait of Grant. It was reproduced by Matthew Boulton’s picture manufactory in Birmingham, England, between 1776 and 1780 by an unusual reproductive process that replicated paintings with their original coloring. In the mid-1780s a cloth merchant and amateur painter named Joseph Booth revived the idea of reproducing the painting by using a “polygraph process.” Numerous color reproductions of de Loutherbourg’s Winter Morning survive.27

 

Art historian William Pressly has proposed an interpretation of The Skater as expressing the theme of melancholy. To Pressly, the “recently revived tradition of the melancholy hero” explains the somber coloration of the painting, the darkly shaded eyes of the skater, and the use of a crossed-arm pose. In this view the painting becomes a self-portrait of Stuart’s own tendency toward melancholy. The snowy setting is appropriate in this theory, since winter was traditionally associated with melancholia.28 One might even suggest that Stuart included himself as the man on the right who stands under a tree. The physiognomy of this spectator, with his long nose and angular chin, closely resembles Stuart’s self-portrait of around 1786. Whether the association of the mood and the season necessarily points to melancholy as the subject of the painting is uncertain, even though the connection of the two was well known at the time and had been developed in verse many years earlier by the English poet James Thomson in his poem “Winter” in The Seasons (1730). “Winter” itself could be the theme, rather than “melancholy.” As Jules Prown has pointed out, “The skater evokes an allegorical image of Winter as one of the Four Seasons. “29 Lines from Thomson’s “Winter” form the caption for a late eighteenth-century English mezzotint titled “Winter,” which shows three warmly dressed figures walking near the Serpentine, where skaters can be seen in the background. “While every work of man is laid at rest, “ they “swoop on sounding skates a thousand different ways” and the “land is madden’d all to joy” (“Winter,” verses 761, 769, 771).30 The allusion to the mood of the season indicates that Stuart had absorbed the highly sophisticated London practice of borrowing from literary works for the subject matter of portraits.

 

Stuart was also absorbing lessons on technique. The portrait is a masterpiece of the late eighteenth-century British style of portraiture, which focuses on the figure, particularly the face, by painting the background with less detail. X-radiography shows that Stuart, when painting Grant’s face, had not yet developed the fully calligraphic brushwork for which he is known in his later paintings. Here he shaped the eyes, nose, mouth, and shadow of the nose by drawing the features with the brush. Later he would not follow the outline of the individual features as closely. Stuart also used more white pigment in the transitional flesh tones than he would in later works. X-radiography suggests, not surprisingly, that Stuart painted the background after completing the figure; the brushstrokes of the clouds mark the outer edges of the hat, face, and shoulders, which were already blocked out and painted. In addition, close examination of the painting reveals changes, or pentimenti, in the hat, shoulders, tail of the coat, and sitter’s right leg, indicating that Stuart did indeed struggle with the challenge inherent in a full-length, a size he rarely agreed to use again in his long career.

 

EGM

 

Notes

 

1.The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke 1956, 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Glinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Glinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

2.According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

3.Royal Academy 1878, unpaginated; Graves 1913, 1:383,3:1275; Graves 1905,71296. For a discussion of the attribution of the portrait in 1878 to Gainsborough, and the Grant family’s research to determine Stuart’s authorship, see Whitley 1932,33-36.

4.Quincy 1883,84, who does not identify the picture.

5.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Fraser heard the story from Stuart. John Gait had by then published his story about Benjamin West as a skater; see Gait 1820, 2:26-31. Gait told how, when West was a young artist in London in the 17605, his skating skills had brought him to the attention of the English aristocracy. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the similarity of the two anecdotes.

6.Hayes 1990, 64.

7.Button 1973, 354.

8.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87; since Jouett never saw the portrait, his description must be a quotation from Stuart.

9.Faculty of Advocates 1944, 90, courtesy of Dr. Louise Yeoman, Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh.

10.Alexander Grant is mentioned in Stuart 1877, 642; see also Stuart 1967,14.

11.Ward and Roberts 1904, 2:63-64. The earlier portrait of Grant by Romney was sold by Georgiana Bordewich, former owner of The Skater, at Christie’s on 22 March 1974 (lot 96) and bought by Léger Galleries; see Léger Galleries 1975, unpaginated, no. 5. Mrs. Bordewich also sold a portrait said to be of Grant by Thomas Hudson (lot 94), 127 by 101.6 cm (50 by 40 inches), and the portrait of his four eldest children, attributed to Opie (lot 95). The portrait of Mrs. Grant remained in Romney’s studio and was sold at Romney’s sale in 1807.

12.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Jouett referred to Baretti’s “mistaking it for Wests best production” when he recorded Stuart’s comments about painting in 1816; see Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87.

13.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

14.Whitley 1932,32.

15.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

16.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, and Pressly 1986, 44, from Childe-Pemberton 1925,1:284.

17.“Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition,” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser, 30 April 1782, 3.

18.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

19.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

20.The letter from the correspondent, identified as “Candid,” was published in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser on 9 May 1782, 2.

21.Quoted in Whitley 1932, 33, from an unidentified issue.

22.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, from an unidentified source.

23.Pearson 1987, 59.

24.Pressly 1986, 48; Pearson 1987, 60, 62, fig. 8.

25.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 86.

26.For three of these paintings see Hayes 1990, 64-66, no. 19, color repro.; and Pearson 1987, 57 fig. 2 and 61 fig. 7.

27.de Loutherbourg 1973, unpaginated, cat. no. 22. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the significance of this image for Stuart’s and West’s works.

28.Pressly 1986, 42-51.

29.Prown 1969, 48.

30.Quoted in Button 1973, 355, fig. 4.

 

References

 

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 30 April: 3.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post. 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 9 May: 2.

•1816—Jouett: 86, 87.

•1834—Dunlap: 1:183-184.

•1846—Lester: 126.

•1877—Stuart: 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (12 January): 50.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (19 January): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (26 January): 91.

•1879—Mason: 187-190.

•1880—MFA: 41, no.268.

•1883—Quincy: 84.

•1926—Park: 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley: 15, 31-36.

•1961—Oswald: 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount: 69-74.

•1969—Prown: 47-48.

•1973—Button: 351-3 62, color cover repro.

•1980—Evans: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding: 50, color repro .51.

•1981—Waterson: 872 repro.

•1981—Williams: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986—Pressly: 42-51, fig.1.

•1986—McLanathan: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1987—Pearson: 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding: 58-59, color repro.

•1990—Crean: 55-62.

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

West Building, Main Floor—Gallery 59

 

•Date: 1782

•Medium: Oil on Canvas

•Dimensions:

oOverall: 245.5 × 147.4 cm (96⅝ × 58 1/16 in.)

oFramed: 274.3 × 177.2 × 9.5 cm (108 × 69¾ × 3¾ in.)

•Credit Line: Andrew W. Mellon Collection

•Accession Number: 1950.18.1

•Artists/Makers

oPainter: Gilbert Stuart, American, 1755-1828

 

Overview

 

In 1775, Gilbert Stuart set sail for London where Benjamin West welcomed the destitute young man into his home. The Skater marks the end of his five-year apprenticeship to West. Stuart’s first effort at full-length portraiture, its originality brought the artist so much notice at the 1782 Royal Academy exhibition that he soon set up his own studio.

 

The unorthodox motif of skating—indeed, any presentation of vigorous movement at all—had absolutely no precedent in Britain’s “Grand Manner” tradition of life-size society portraiture. The painter recalled that when William Grant, from Congalton near Edinburgh, arrived to have his picture painted, the Scottish sitter remarked that, “on account of the excessive coldness of the weather … the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait.” Thus artist and sitter went off to skate on the Serpentine River in Hyde Park. When he returned to West’s studio with Grant, Stuart conceived the idea of portraying his subject on ice skates in a winter landscape, with the twin towers of Westminster Abbey far in the distance.

 

In this innovative design, Grant glides effortlessly forward with arms crossed over his chest in typical eighteenth-century skating form. Except for his folded arms, the figure’s stance derives from an ancient Roman statue, the Apollo Belvedere, a cast of which stood in the corner of West’s studio.

 

Provenance

 

The sitter, William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son, William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter, Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];[1] her son, Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;[2] his widow, Elizabeth Pelham-Clinton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter, Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Clinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913] London; sold 1950 to the NGA.

 

[1]The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke’s Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Peerage, Baronetage and Knightage, Privy Council and Order of Precedence, 101st ed., London, 1956: 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Clinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Clinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

[2]According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA curatorial file), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

 

Associated Names

 

•Clinton, Pelham, Miss

•Grant, William

•Grant, William

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton

•Pelham-Clinton, Charles Stapleton, Mrs.

•Pelham-Clinton, Elizabeth

 

Exhibition History

 

•1782—Royal Academy, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating

•1878—Exhibition of Works by Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough

•1946—American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206

•1963—Style, Truth, and the Portrait, Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38

•1967—Gilbert Stuart, Portraitist of the Young Republic, 1755-1828, National Gallery of Art; Museum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design, Providence, 1967, no. 8

•1976—American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44

•1981—American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; National Portrait Gallery, Washington, D.C., 1981-1982, no. 21.

•2001—Great British Paintings from American Collections: Holbein to Hockney, Yale Center for British Art, New Haven; The Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens, San Marino, 2001-2002, no. 35, repro.

•2004—Gilbert Stuart, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York; National Gallery of Art (for the National Portrait Gallery), Washington, D.C., 2004-2005, no. 6, repro.

 

Bibliography

 

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (9 May 1782): 2.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” The Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser (30 April 1782): 3.

•1816—Jouett, Matthew Harris. “Notes Taken by M. H. Jouett while in Boston from Conversations on painting with Gilbert Stuart Esqr.” Manuscript, published in Gilbert Stuart and His Pupils, by John Hill Morgan. New York, 1816: 86, 87.

•1846—Lester, C. Edwards. The Artists of America. New York, 1846: 126.

•1869—Dunlap, William. A History of the Rise and Progress of The Arts of Design in the United States. 2 vols. Reprinted in 3. New York, 1969 (1834): 1:183-184.

•1877—Stuart, Jane. “The Youth of Gilbert Stuart.” Scribner’s Monthly 13, no. 5 (March 1877): 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (January 19, 1878): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” The Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (January 26, 1878): 91.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (January 12, 1878): 50.

•1879—Mason, George C. The Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1879: 187-190.

•1880—”Portraits Painted by Stuart...taken from Mason’s Life and Works of Gilbert Stuart.” In Exhibition of Portraits Painted by Gilbert Stuart. Exh. cat. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 1880: 41, no. 268.

•1883—Quincy, Josiah. Figures of the Past from the Leaves of Old Journals. 4th ed. Boston, 1883: 84.

•1926—Park 1926, 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley, William T. Artists and Their Friends in England, 1700-1800. 2 vols. London and Boston, 1928: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley, William T. Gilbert Stuart. Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1932: 15, 31-36.

•1952 Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds., Great Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1952: 138, color repro., as The Skater.

•1956 Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1956: 50, color repro., as The Skater.

•1957—Shapley, Fern Rusk. Comparisons in Art: A Companion to the National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC. London, 1957 (reprinted 1959): pl. 91.

•1961—Oswald, Arthur. “Our Ancestors on the Ice.” Country Life 129 (9 February 1961): 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount, Charles Merrill. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1964: 69-74.

•1966—Cairns, Huntington, and John Walker, eds. A Pageant of Painting from the National Gallery of Art. 2 vols. New York, 1966: 2:380, color repro.

•1969—Novak, Barbara. American Painting of the Nineteenth Century: Realism, Idealism, and the American Experience. 2nd ed. New York, 1979: 32, fig. 1.17.

•1969—Prown, Jules David. American Painting, From its Beginnings to the Armory Show. Geneva, 1969: 47-48.

•1970—American Paintings and Sculpture: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1970: 106, repro., as The Skater.

•1973—Button, Dick. “The Art of Skating.” Antiques 103, no. 2 (February 1973): 351-362, color repro. on cover.

•1973—Finley, David Edward. A Standard of Excellence: Andrew W. Mellon Founds the National Gallery of Art at Washington. Washington, 1973: 135.

•1975—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1975: 380, color repro. 381.

•1978—King, Marian. Adventures in Art: National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C. New York, 1978: 54, pl. 31.

•1980—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1980: 234, repro.

•1980—Evans, Dorinda. Benjamin West and His American Students. Exh. cat. National Portrait Gallery, Washington; Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, Philadelphia. Washington, 1980: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1980: 10, no. 6, color repro.

•1981—Waterson, Merlin. “Hissing Along the Polished Ice.” Country Life 169 (2 April 1981): repro. 872.

•1981—Williams, William James. A Heritage of American Paintings from the National Gallery of Art. New York, 1981: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. Rev. ed. New York, 1984: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986 McLanathan, Richard. Gilbert Stuart. New York, 1986: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1986—Pressly, William L. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater: An Essay in Romantic Melancholy.” American Art Journal 18, no. 1, 1986: 42-51, fig. 1.

•1987—Pearson, Andrea G. “Gilbert Stuart’s The Skater (Portrait of William Grant) and Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker, D.D., Skating on Duddington Loch: A Study of Sources.” Rutgers Art Review 8 (1987): 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding, John. American Masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art. Rev. ed. National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1988: 58-59, no. 6, color repro.

•1990—Crean, Hugh R. Gilbert Stuart and the politics of fine arts patronage in Ireland, 1787-1793; A social and cultural study. Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1990: 55-62.

•1992—American Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 345, repro.

•1992—National Gallery of Art, Washington. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1992: 214, repro.

•1995—Miles, Ellen G. American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century. The Collections of the National Gallery of Art Systematic Catalogue. Washington, D.C., 1995: 162-169, color repro. 165.

•1997—Hughes, Robert. American Visions: The Epic History of Art in America. New York, 1997: 128, color fig. 81.

•1997—Thomson, Duncan. Raeburn: The Art of Sir Henry Raeburn 1756-1823, Exh. cat. Scottish National Portrait Gallery at the Royal Scottish Academy, Edinburgh; National Portrait Gallery, London, 1997-1998, p. 90, no. 61, repro.

•1998—Mandel, Corinne. “Melancholy.” In Encyclopedia of Comparative Iconography: Themes Depicted in Works of Art, edited by Helene E. Roberts. 2 vols. Chicago, 1998: 2:586-588.

•2004—Hand, John Oliver. National Gallery of Art: Master Paintings from the Collection. Washington and New York, 2004: 294-295, no. 240, color repro.

•2011—Gopnik, Adam. Winter: Four Windows on the Season. Toronto, 2011: 142-143, color repro.

•2013—Evans, Dorinda. Gilbert Stuart and the Impact of Manic Depression. Burlington, 2013: 162-164, 168 nn. 36 and 37, fig. 11.

•2016—Rather, Susan. The American School: Artists and Status in the Late Colonial and Early National Era. New Haven, 2016: 171-172, color fig. 125.

  

From American Paintings of the Eighteenth Century:

 

1950.18.1 (1051)

 

The Skater (Portrait of William Grant)

 

•1782

•Oil on Canvas, 244.5 × 147.4 (96¼ × 58)

•Andrew W. Mellon Collection

 

Technical Notes

 

The support is a finely woven twill fabric. The top and bottom tacking edges have been unfolded and add about 6 cm to the painting’s height. The lateral tacking margins have been cropped, but cusping remains along these edges. The thin white ground extends to cover the tacking margins, suggesting that the canvas was pre-primed. Much of the preliminary drawing, done loosely with paint and brush, is visible on the surface, having been incorporated into the painting. The paint is thinly applied, except in the sitter’s upper body, face, and collar, and in the sky around his head, where the paint is thicker and its handling more controlled. Many pentimenti are evident, including changes in the figure’s hat, shoulders, tail of the coat on the viewer’s right, and the sitter’s right leg.

 

Abrasion is found in the ice at the sitter’s feet. Crackle is more pronounced near the head, where the paint is thicker, and is especially pronounced to the right of the skater’s thigh. There are pinpoint losses throughout. The painting was lined prior to 1950.

 

Provenance

 

William Grant [d. 1821], Congalton, Scotland, and Cheltenham, England; his son William Grant [d. 1827], Congalton, Scotland, and London; his daughter Elizabeth Grant [Mrs. Charles Pelham-Clinton, d. 1899];1 her son Charles Stapleton Pelham-Clinton [1857-1911], Moor Park, Stroud, Gloucestershire;2 his widow Elizabeth Pelham-Clin ton [d. 1946], London and Holmes Green, Buckinghamshire; her niece and adopted daughter Georgiana Elizabeth May Pelham-Glinton [Mrs. John Stuart Bordewich, b. 1913], London.

 

Exhibited

 

Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1782, no. 190, as Portrait of a gentleman skating. Exhibition of Works by the Old Masters, and by Deceased Masters of the British School, Royal Academy of Arts, London, 1878, no. 128, as Portrait of W. Grant, Esq., of Congalton, Skating in St. James3s Park, attributed to Thomas Gainsborough.3 American Painting from the Eighteenth Century to the Present Day, Tate Gallery, London, 1946, no. 206. Style, Truth and the Portrait, The Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio, 1963, no. 38. Gilbert Stuart, NGA; RISD, 1967, no. 8. American Art: 1750-1800, Towards Independence, YUAG; The Victoria and Albert Museum, London, 1976, no. 44. American Portraiture in the Grand Manner: 1720-1920, Los Angeles County Museum of Art; NGA, 1981-1982, no. 21.

 

In 1782 Gilbert Stuart, a young painter in London, was “suddenly lifted into fame by the exhibition of a single picture,”4 his full-length of William Grant called Portrait of a Gentleman Skating. (The painting was given its present title of The Skater m 1946.) Stuart devised the theme after an outing on the Serpentine river in Hyde Park with Grant, a young Scottish lawyer, who had come for a sitting for a full-length portrait. According to American artist William Dunlap, who heard the story from miniaturist Charles Fraser,

 

Stuart said that he felt great diffidence in undertaking a whole length; but that there must be a beginning, and a day was accordingly appointed for Mr. Grant to sit. On entering the artist’s room, he regretted the appointment, on account of the excessive coldness of the weather, and observed to Stuart, that the day was better suited for skating than sitting for one’s portrait. To this the painter assented, and they both sallied out to their morning’s amusement. Stuart said that early practice had made him very expert in skating. His celerity and activity accordingly attracted crowds on the Serpentine river—which was the scene of their sport. His companion, although a well-made and graceful man, was not as active as himself; and there being a crack in the ice, which made it dangerous to continue their amusement, he told Mr. Grant to hold the skirt of his coat, and follow him off the field. They returned to Mr. Stuart’s rooms, where it occurred to him to paint Mr. Grant in the attitude of skating, with the appendage of a winter scene, in the back ground.5

 

The setting for the portrait is the Serpentine, a popular skating spot in London that was created when Kensington Gardens was landscaped during the reign of George II.6 Grant is dressed completely in black, from his hat and the fur-lined lapels of his coat to his breeches, stockings, and shoes. Behind him to the right two skaters sit at the edge of the ice, putting on their skates, while two other men stand under a tree. In the left background two skaters perform the Salutation, also known as the Serpentine Greeting, while others watch.7 The painting offers a balance of black, gray, and off-white, with slight touches of red on the clothing of the background figures. Stuart’s pupil Matthew Harris Jouett later described the portrait as a “fine contrast of Grant in full black to the snow & grey chilly background.”8 The young lawyer William Grant (d. 1821) was the son of Ludovick Grant of Edinburgh.9 Why he chose Stuart to paint his portrait is not known ; perhaps he was a friend or a distant relative of Stuart’s early London patron Alexander Grant, also a Scot.10 Moderately wealthy, Grant was fond of portraits. George Romney painted him in 1781 and again in 1787, and in 1794 he painted “ Mrs. Grant, “ perhaps Grant’s wife Dorothea Dalrymple, whom he married that year. Grant’s children were painted by John Opie (LaSalle University Art Museum, Philadelphia).11 At his death in 1821, Grant left his heirs a large estate called Congalton, in Scotland, as well as stock in the Bank of England and the Royal Bank of Scotland.

 

The portrait, Stuart’s first full-length, showed his ability to invent new compositions within the tradition of English portraiture, in which standing cross-legged poses had been popular for men’s portraits since the 17405. Its success made it possible for Stuart to move from West’s studio into one of his own. Comparisons between the two American artists by contemporaries were inevitable. When Giuseppi Baretti, an Italian-born lexicographer, author, and friend of Sir Joshua Reynolds, saw the painting at West’s before its exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts, he commented, according to Dunlap, “What a charming picture ! Who but the great West could have painted such a one ! “ Later, seeing Stuart at work on the painting, he exclaimed, “What, young man, does Mr. West permit you to touch his pictures?” Stuart replied that it was his own painting. Baretti is supposed to have said, “Why, it is almost as good as Mr. West can paint.”12 The close association of the two men’s work is revealed by an undated chalk drawing by West titled Skateing. West, like Stuart, enjoyed a reputation as a good skater, and in this chalk drawing depicted skaters and spectators on the ice at the Serpentine. A skater in the center foreground turns toward the man behind him, who lies on the ice after a fall. To the left, two figures who perform the Serpentine Greeting are virtually identical to the two skaters in the background of Stuart’s portrait of Grant. To the right is a small figure whose pose seems similar to Grant’s; the figure is very sketchy.

 

A reviewer noted Stuart’s relationship to Benjamin West when Stuart exhibited the painting with three others at the Royal Academy of Arts in 1782.

 

Mr. Stuart is in Partnership with Mr. West; where it is not uncommon for Wits to divert themselves with Applications for Things they do not immediately want; because they are told by Mr. West that Mr. Stuart is the only Portrait Painter in the World; and by Mr. Stuart that no Man has any Pretensions in History Painting but Mr. West. After such Authority what can we say of Mr. Stuart’s Painting.13

 

The portrait enchanted visitors who attended the Academy’s exhibition. Horace Walpole, author of Anecdotes of Painting in England (1762-1771), the first history of British art, wrote “very good” next to the entry for the portrait in his copy of the catalogue.14 Stuart overheard the Duke of Rutland on opening day, urging Sir Joshua Reynolds, “I wish you would go to the exhibition with me, for there is a portrait there which you must see, every body is enchanted with it.” When Sir Joshua asked who painted it, the Duke replied, “A young man by the name of Stuart. “15 Visitors and reviewers praised the portrait’s unusual pose and Stuart’s ability with likeness. Sir John Cullum commented on the novelty of the theme in his letter of 1 May 1782 to Frederick Hervey, Bishop of Derry and Earl of Bristol. “One would have thought that almost every attitude of a single Figure had long been exhausted in this land of portrait painting but one is now exhibited which I recollect not before—it is that of Skating. There is a noble portrait large as life thus exhibited and which produces the most powerful effect.”16 A reviewer for the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser commented on 30 April that “Stuart and Opie, whose merits were not so generally known, have proved themselves able artists” and praised Stuart for his “striking likenesses.”17 Stuart’s ability to capture a likeness was borne out by Charles Fraser’s later comment to artist William Dunlap that the picture attracted so much comment that Stuart was “afraid to go to the academy to meet the looks and answer the inquiries of the multitude. Mr. Grant went one day to the exhibition, dressed as his portrait represented him; the original was immediately recognized, when the crowd followed him so closely that he was compelled to make his retreat, for every one was exclaiming, ‘There he is, there is the gentleman.’”18

 

Opinion was divided on the technique of the painting. One reviewer said that “Mr. Stuart seldom fails of a Likeness; but wants Freedom of Pencil, and Elegance of Taste.”19 However, the author of a letter in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser noted, “ Mr. Stuart… may be said to be an acquisition to the public; his Gentleman seating, No. 190, is reposed, animated and well drawn.”20 And a critic in the London Courant commented on the portrait as Stuart’s first attempt at a full-length. “If we have been informed aright this is the gentleman’s first essay in this branch of the art ; at all events it does honour to his pencil, from the novelty of the design and the neatness of the execution.”21 A commentator in 1795 wrote about Stuart’s early difficulty with a portrait of this size.

 

It is now some years since Stuart the portrait painter … painted a portrait of a Mr. Grant in the action of skating; this portrait was given in so spirited an attitude and with so appropriate a character that when it was exhibited, it established the fame of the artist, of whom his brethren had before that time said he made a tolerable likeness of a face, but as to the figure he could not get below the fifth button.22

 

The combination of the full-length portrait with the act of skating was indeed a novel theme. Stuart appropriately portrayed Grant as a figure skater, the version of the sport popular in England, which emphasized graceful and refined movements, instead of as a Scottish speed skater, which encouraged skill, speed, and competition. Grant wears skates designed for the “small pivots and graceful maneuvers which were essential to the art of figure skating.”23 Robert Jones, in his influential Treatise on Skating (London, 1772), recommended a similar crossedarm pose as “a proper attitude for genteel rolling” (Figure 2).24 Matthew HarrisJouett in 1816 quoted Stuart on “the importance of keeping the figure in its circle of motion, “ giving the example of “his famous skaiting picture of Grant as contrasted with Buckminster Preble who turns his body one way his neck another and his eyes another…. “25

 

The painting is unlike other images of skaters, which belong to the tradition of sporting scenes. They include Irish painter Robert Healy’s Tom Conolly and his Friends Skating (1768, private collection, Ireland), Sir Henry Raeburn’s The Reverend Robert Walker Skating on Duddingston Loch (c. 1784, National Gallery of Scotland, Edinburgh), Thomas Rowlandson’s watercolor Skaters on the Serpentine of 1784 (National Museum of Wales, Cardiff), and a view by Julius Caesar Ibbetson engraved in 1787 as Winter Amusement; A View in Hyde Park from the Moated Housed Philippe Jacques de Loutherbourg’s A Winter Morning, with a Party Skating of 1776 is particularly close to Stuart’s and West’s images in that it shows skating figures similar to those who perform the Serpentine Greeting. And like de Loutherbourg’s scene, Benjamin West’s undated drawing Skateing focuses its action on the popular Serpentine river. In the background is a structure similar to the Cheesecake House, a refreshment lodge that is also seen in the images by Rowlandson and Ibbetson. De Loutherbourg’s scene, which includes portraits of the artist and his wife, the artist’s partner V.M. Picot and others, was the best known of the various images of skaters made before or at the time that Stuart painted his portrait of Grant. It was reproduced by Matthew Boulton’s picture manufactory in Birmingham, England, between 1776 and 1780 by an unusual reproductive process that replicated paintings with their original coloring. In the mid-1780s a cloth merchant and amateur painter named Joseph Booth revived the idea of reproducing the painting by using a “polygraph process.” Numerous color reproductions of de Loutherbourg’s Winter Morning survive.27

 

Art historian William Pressly has proposed an interpretation of The Skater as expressing the theme of melancholy. To Pressly, the “recently revived tradition of the melancholy hero” explains the somber coloration of the painting, the darkly shaded eyes of the skater, and the use of a crossed-arm pose. In this view the painting becomes a self-portrait of Stuart’s own tendency toward melancholy. The snowy setting is appropriate in this theory, since winter was traditionally associated with melancholia.28 One might even suggest that Stuart included himself as the man on the right who stands under a tree. The physiognomy of this spectator, with his long nose and angular chin, closely resembles Stuart’s self-portrait of around 1786. Whether the association of the mood and the season necessarily points to melancholy as the subject of the painting is uncertain, even though the connection of the two was well known at the time and had been developed in verse many years earlier by the English poet James Thomson in his poem “Winter” in The Seasons (1730). “Winter” itself could be the theme, rather than “melancholy.” As Jules Prown has pointed out, “The skater evokes an allegorical image of Winter as one of the Four Seasons. “29 Lines from Thomson’s “Winter” form the caption for a late eighteenth-century English mezzotint titled “Winter,” which shows three warmly dressed figures walking near the Serpentine, where skaters can be seen in the background. “While every work of man is laid at rest, “ they “swoop on sounding skates a thousand different ways” and the “land is madden’d all to joy” (“Winter,” verses 761, 769, 771).30 The allusion to the mood of the season indicates that Stuart had absorbed the highly sophisticated London practice of borrowing from literary works for the subject matter of portraits.

 

Stuart was also absorbing lessons on technique. The portrait is a masterpiece of the late eighteenth-century British style of portraiture, which focuses on the figure, particularly the face, by painting the background with less detail. X-radiography shows that Stuart, when painting Grant’s face, had not yet developed the fully calligraphic brushwork for which he is known in his later paintings. Here he shaped the eyes, nose, mouth, and shadow of the nose by drawing the features with the brush. Later he would not follow the outline of the individual features as closely. Stuart also used more white pigment in the transitional flesh tones than he would in later works. X-radiography suggests, not surprisingly, that Stuart painted the background after completing the figure; the brushstrokes of the clouds mark the outer edges of the hat, face, and shoulders, which were already blocked out and painted. In addition, close examination of the painting reveals changes, or pentimenti, in the hat, shoulders, tail of the coat, and sitter’s right leg, indicating that Stuart did indeed struggle with the challenge inherent in a full-length, a size he rarely agreed to use again in his long career.

 

EGM

 

Notes

 

1.The wills of William Grant and his son (Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh) do not mention the portrait. Burke 1956, 1611, lists Mrs. Pelham-Glinton, the first owner of record, as her father’s only surviving child at the time of her marriage in 1848. Her husband was the second son of Henry Pelham-Glinton, 4th Duke of Newcastle.

2.According to a file note by William P. Campbell (NGA), a label from the 1878 exhibition at the Royal Academy of Arts is attached to the stretcher and documents this owner and address; see Burke 1956, 1611, for the dates of this and later owners.

3.Royal Academy 1878, unpaginated; Graves 1913, 1:383,3:1275; Graves 1905,71296. For a discussion of the attribution of the portrait in 1878 to Gainsborough, and the Grant family’s research to determine Stuart’s authorship, see Whitley 1932,33-36.

4.Quincy 1883,84, who does not identify the picture.

5.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Fraser heard the story from Stuart. John Gait had by then published his story about Benjamin West as a skater; see Gait 1820, 2:26-31. Gait told how, when West was a young artist in London in the 17605, his skating skills had brought him to the attention of the English aristocracy. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the similarity of the two anecdotes.

6.Hayes 1990, 64.

7.Button 1973, 354.

8.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87; since Jouett never saw the portrait, his description must be a quotation from Stuart.

9.Faculty of Advocates 1944, 90, courtesy of Dr. Louise Yeoman, Scottish Record Office, Edinburgh.

10.Alexander Grant is mentioned in Stuart 1877, 642; see also Stuart 1967,14.

11.Ward and Roberts 1904, 2:63-64. The earlier portrait of Grant by Romney was sold by Georgiana Bordewich, former owner of The Skater, at Christie’s on 22 March 1974 (lot 96) and bought by Léger Galleries; see Léger Galleries 1975, unpaginated, no. 5. Mrs. Bordewich also sold a portrait said to be of Grant by Thomas Hudson (lot 94), 127 by 101.6 cm (50 by 40 inches), and the portrait of his four eldest children, attributed to Opie (lot 95). The portrait of Mrs. Grant remained in Romney’s studio and was sold at Romney’s sale in 1807.

12.Dunlap 1834, 1:183; Jouett referred to Baretti’s “mistaking it for Wests best production” when he recorded Stuart’s comments about painting in 1816; see Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 87.

13.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

14.Whitley 1932,32.

15.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

16.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, and Pressly 1986, 44, from Childe-Pemberton 1925,1:284.

17.“Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition,” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser, 30 April 1782, 3.

18.Dunlap 1834,1:184.

19.“Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy,” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post, 2-4 May 1782, 4.

20.The letter from the correspondent, identified as “Candid,” was published in the Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser on 9 May 1782, 2.

21.Quoted in Whitley 1932, 33, from an unidentified issue.

22.Quoted in Whitley 1932,33, from an unidentified source.

23.Pearson 1987, 59.

24.Pressly 1986, 48; Pearson 1987, 60, 62, fig. 8.

25.Jouett 1816, in Morgan, Stuart, 1939, 86.

26.For three of these paintings see Hayes 1990, 64-66, no. 19, color repro.; and Pearson 1987, 57 fig. 2 and 61 fig. 7.

27.de Loutherbourg 1973, unpaginated, cat. no. 22. Allen Staley kindly pointed out the significance of this image for Stuart’s and West’s works.

28.Pressly 1986, 42-51.

29.Prown 1969, 48.

30.Quoted in Button 1973, 355, fig. 4.

 

References

 

•1782—”Royal Academy, 1782. Fourteenth Exhibition.” Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 30 April: 3.

•1782—”Postscript. Account of the Exhibition of Paintings, &c. at the Royal Academy.” St. James’s Chronicle, or British Evening Post. 2-4 May 1782: 4.

•1782—”Candid.” Letter to the Editor. Morning Chronicle, and London Advertiser. 9 May: 2.

•1816—Jouett: 86, 87.

•1834—Dunlap: 1:183-184.

•1846—Lester: 126.

•1877—Stuart: 642.

•1878—”The Old Masters at the Royal Academy.” Saturday Review 45, no. 1159 (12 January): 50.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Second Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2012 (19 January): 66.

•1878—”The Old Masters at Burlington House. Third Notice.” Illustrated London News 72, no. 2013 (26 January): 91.

•1879—Mason: 187-190.

•1880—MFA: 41, no.268.

•1883—Quincy: 84.

•1926—Park: 34, 358-359, no. 343, repro.

•1928—Whitley: 2:395-396.

•1932—Whitley: 15, 31-36.

•1961—Oswald: 268-270, repro.

•1964—Mount: 69-74.

•1969—Prown: 47-48.

•1973—Button: 351-3 62, color cover repro.

•1980—Evans: 55, 57-58, repro. 59.

•1980—Wilmerding: 50, color repro .51.

•1981—Waterson: 872 repro.

•1981—Williams: color repro. 49, 62, repro. 63.

•1984—Walker: 376, no. 531, color repro.

•1986—Pressly: 42-51, fig.1.

•1986—McLanathan: color repro. 36, 37, 45-47.

•1987—Pearson: 55-70, fig. 1.

•1988—Wilmerding: 58-59, color repro.

•1990—Crean: 55-62.

*Following texts in English and Italian

 

(ESP)

Hola a todos, queridos fixionarios!

Creamos esta nota porque queremos y sentimos la necesidad de agradecerles enormemente a todas estas almas creativas (cada uno de ustedes) que plasmaron su talento y dieron a conocer su arte en el concurso "El Maravilloso País de Fixionaria" (sin dudas este País se volvió maravilloso gracias a ustedes).

 

También estamos felices de saber que gracias a este tipo de iniciativas se conectan artistas, desde los lugares más remotos del mundo. Les permiten a los ilustradores participar y mostrarse con pares, conocer, comparar, aprender. Y sin dudas nosotras desde nuestro lugar vamos aprendiendo de ustedes. Y como dijimos una vez, e insistimos sobre esto: el hecho de crear un espacio construido entre todos con mucho amor, pasión y dedicación.

 

Nuevamente Gracias, infinitas gracias a estas 134 personas partícipes de Fixionaria Historias Ilustradas.

 

----------

 

(ENG)

Hello everyone, dear Fixionairians!

We created this note because we want and feel the need to thank you greatly, to all these caritative souls (each one of you) who capturated your talent and made known your art in the contest "Fixionaria Wonderland" (without a doubt this land became wonderful thanks to all of you).

 

It also pleases us to know that, thanks to these opportunities, artists from the most remote and distant places around the world are connected with one another; they progress as creatives, learn from each other and have the chance to see from the perspective of others.

 

We strongly believe that, within this little community which we have created out of love, passion and dedication, we learn from you as much as you do from us.

 

Once again, thank you infinitely to the 134 people who participated in Fixionaria Illustrated stories.

 

----------

 

(IT)

Ciao a tutti, cari Fixionarios!

Crediamo questa nota perché vogliamo e sentiamo il bisogno di ringraziare fortemente tutte quelle anime creative (ognuno di voi) che ha registrato suo talento e diedero a conoscere la sua arte in "Il Meraviglioso Paese di Fixionaria" (senza dubbio questo paese (Non c'è dubbio che questo paese è diventato grande grazie a voi).

 

Inoltre siamo felici di sapere che grazie a questo tipo di iniziative collegare artisti, dalle parti più remote del mondo. Gli consentite a gli illustratori partecipare e visualizzarsi con i colleghi, imparare, confrontare. E non c'è dubbio noi dal nostro posto stiamo imparando di voi. E come abbiamo detto una volta, e insistiamo su questo: il fatto di creare un insieme costruito con amore, passione e dedizione.

 

Grazie mille a queste 134 persone partecipi di Fixionaria Historias Ilustradas.

 

----------

 

Ellos son // They are // Essi sono:

 

001. Mariana Aguerre

002. Yohanna Etchemendy

003. Lucas Robert

004. Francesca Tesoriere

005. Michael Zhou

006. Emilse Gómez

007. Guadalupe Ruiz de Somavia

008. Alejandro Sordi

009. Matias Ezequiel Liceaga

010. Giulio Rossi

011. Luis Antonio Rivera

012. Alfredo Vullo

013. Marco Scalcione

014. Pilar Criado Maeso

015. Ettore Biondo

016. Eva Gloria Gutiérrez López

017. Josefina Preumayr

018. Jazmín Varela

019. Massimiliano Di Lauro

020. Ana Monticelli

021. Cinthia del Valle Rojas

022. Paola Laurito

023. Adam Oehlers

024. Vivian Ortega Pantoja

025. Ana Arregui

026. Strawberry Style

027. María Jesús Bárcena Rey

028. Angela Perrini

029. Sabina Meschisi

030. Eliana González Herrera

031. Carolina Cativa

032. Jessica Argarate

033. Masazumi Nishina

034. Alessandra Liberato

035. Nancy Andrea Fernández

036. Vannesa Cortés Zamora

037. Juliana Dómina

038. Carla Pandolfo

039. Mora Manuela Vieytes

040. Kyle Chang (INKc)

041. Sara Martínez Leandro

042. Fernando Augusto Perea

043. Gabriel San Martin

044. Franco Viglino

045. Adrian Montenegro

046. Gwenaëlle Doumont

047. Akinori Oishi

048. Rosalia Gardil

049. Federico David Schujman

050. Ariadna Rivera Noguéz

051. Noemí Matos Santisteban

052. Juan Sebastián Rubiano Sánchez

053. Noelia Navarro

054. Fernando Sosa

055. Emanuel Alippi

056. Augusto Belmonte (xgaiax)

057. Johana Dueñas

058. Daniele Ostuni

059. Yesica Pogorzelsky

060. Vanesa Saucedo

061. Jó Rivadulla

062. Angel Benites Aquino

063. Mária Boada Candiotti

064. Maddalena Sodo

065. Nonski

066. Isabel Zabala

067. Emanuela Mannello

068. Antonio Falzetti

069. Baba Robot

070. Ángela Astrid Gallo

071. Vanessa Santos

072. Marta Lorenzon

073. Mariela Aguirre

074. Soledad Willich

075. Marta Ghezzi

076. Carla Miranda

077. Nacrisca

078. Belén Arce

079. Little Scarlet

080. Kopii Zelas

081. Matías Ramallo

082. Nicolás Riera Diaz

083. cereza mecanica

084. CSR

085. Carina Juan

086. Lyosha Svetlana

087. Sonia Baretti

088. La Niña Que Pinta

089. Estrella Mergá

090. Lauri Medina

091. Marita Giampietri

092. Pishier

093. Rey Arlequin

094. Silvina Aguirre

095. Camila Diotima

096. José Pérez Tello

097. Natalia Sabransky

098. Gastón Barros (CHiCHo)

099. Lady Marian

100. Olga Suarez

101. Lara

102. Nani Puspasari

103. Carolina Bello

104. Aldo Deep Red

105. Iván Hernández

106. Daniela Zizzi

107. Thais Petranski

108. Antonella Antonioni

109. Guillermina de la Cal

110. William Pineda

111. Bruno Brandoni

112. KarnEvil

113. Amelia Chieco

114. Bianca

115. Roger Hoyos Paredes

116. Marina S. Kanopliova

117. Fabiola "Lola" Poleggi

118. Luisi Delbianco

119. Maria Luisa Peral Torres

120. Violeta Raffin

121. Deed Tattoo

122. Shan Andrada

123. Revolution Graphic

124. Carlos Rodríguez

125. Marina González Meyer

126. Ceci Ta

127. Agustina Arruebarena

128. Kandelah

129. Mandingha Arte & Diseño

130. Esteban Corva

131. Paulo Villegas

132. Arnold Fernando Arce

133. Marce-Day

134. Danii

_______________________________

 

Un fuerte abrazo y buena vida es nuestro deseo para todos.

We wish you all the best in life and your creative endeavours.

Un grande abbraccio.

 

Ana & Georgina

Fixionaria Historias Ilustradas

 

Marie-Julie Baretti (1838-1872); French soprano at the Théâtre Lyrique and the Opera Comique. She sang in the première of Maillart's "Les pecheurs de Catane" (1860) and "Lara" (1864), Reyer's "La statue" (1861) and David's "Le saphir" (1865).

 

Sir Joshua Reynolds PRA FRS FRSA (/ˈrɛnəldz/; 16 July 1723 – 23 February 1792) was an influential eighteenth-century English painter, specialising in portraits. He promoted the "Grand Style" in painting which depended on idealization of the imperfect. He was a founder and first president of the Royal Academy, and was knighted by George III in 1769.

 

eynolds was born in Plympton, Devon, on 16 July 1723[1] the third son of the Rev. Samuel Reynolds, master of the Free Grammar School in the town. Samuel Reynolds had been a fellow of Balliol College, Oxford, but did not send any of his sons to the university.[2] One of his sisters was Mary Palmer (1716–1794), seven years his senior, author of Devonshire Dialogue, whose fondness for drawing is said to have had much influence on him when a boy. In 1740 she provided £60, half of the premium paid to Thomas Hudson the portrait-painter, for Joshua's pupilage, and nine years later advanced money for his expenses in Italy.[3] His other siblings included Frances Reynolds and Elizabeth Johnson.

 

As a boy, he came under the influence of Zachariah Mudge, whose Platonistic philosophy stayed with him all his life. Reynolds made extracts in his commonplace book from Theophrastus, Plutarch, Seneca, Marcus Antonius, Ovid, William Shakespeare, John Milton, Alexander Pope, John Dryden, Joseph Addison, Richard Steele, Aphra Behn, and passages on art theory by Leonardo da Vinci, Charles Alphonse Du Fresnoy, and André Félibien.[1] The work that came to have the most influential impact on Reynolds was Jonathan Richardson's An Essay on the Theory of Painting (1715). Reynolds' annotated copy was lost for nearly two hundred years until it appeared in a Cambridge bookshop, inscribed with the signature ‘J. Reynolds Pictor’, and is now in the collection of the Royal Academy of Arts, London.

 

Having shown an early interest in art, Reynolds was apprenticed in 1740 to the fashionable London portrait painter Thomas Hudson, who had been born in Devon.[2] Hudson had a collection of old master drawings, including some by Guercino, of which Reynolds made copies.[2] Although apprenticed to Hudson for four years, Reynolds only remained with him until summer 1743.[2] Having left Hudson, Reynolds worked for some time as a portrait-painter in Plymouth Dock (now Devonport). He returned to London before the end of 1744, but following his father's death in late 1745 he shared a house in Plymouth Dock with his sisters.[2]

 

In 1749, Reynolds met Commodore Augustus Keppel, who invited him to join HMS Centurion, of which he had command, on a voyage to the Mediterranean. While with the ship he visited Lisbon, Cadiz, Algiers, and Minorca. From Minorca he travelled to Livorno in Italy, and then to Rome,[4] where he spent two years,[5] studying the Old Masters and acquiring a taste for the "Grand Style".[citation needed] Lord Edgecumbe, who had known Reynolds as a boy and introduced him to Keppel, suggested he should study with Pompeo Batoni, the leading painter in Rome, but Reynolds replied that he had nothing to learn from him.[2] While in Rome he suffered a severe cold, which left him partially deaf, and, as a result, he began to carry a small ear trumpet with which he is often pictured.

 

Reynolds travelled homeward overland via Florence, Bologna, Venice,[6] and Paris.[7] He was accompanied by Giuseppe Marchi, then aged about 17.[8] Apart from a brief interlude in 1770, Marchi remained in Reynolds' employment as a studio assistant for the rest of the artist's career.[8] Following his arrival in England in October 1752, Reynolds spent three months in Devon,[9] before establishing himself in London, where remained for the rest of his life. He took rooms in St Martin's Lane, before moving to Great Newport Street, his sister Frances acted as his housekeeper.[9] He achieved success rapidly, and was extremely prolific.[10] Lord Edgecumbe recommended the Duke of Devonshire and Duke of Grafton to sit for him, and other peers followed, including the Duke of Cumberland, third son of George II,[11] in whose portrait, according to Nicholas Penny "bulk is brilliantly converted into power".[11] In 1760 Reynolds moved into a large house, with space to show his works and accommodate his assistants, on the west side of Leicester Fields (now Leicester Square).

 

Alongside ambitious full-length portraits, Reynolds painted large numbers of smaller works. In the late 1750s, at the height of the social season, he received five or six sitters a day, each for an hour.[11] By 1761 Reynolds could command a fee of 80 guineas for a full-length portrait; in 1764 he was paid 100 guineas for a portrait of Lord Burghersh.[13]

 

The clothing of Reynolds' sitters was usually painted either by one of his pupils,[14] his studio assistant Giuseppe Marchi,[15] or the specialist drapery painter Peter Toms.[14] James Northcote, his pupil, wrote of this arrangement that "the imitation of particular stuffs is not the work of genius, but is to be acquired easily by practice, and this was what his pupils could do by care and time more than he himself chose to bestow; but his own slight and masterly work was still the best."[14] Lay figures were used to model the clothes.

 

Reynolds often adapted the poses of his subjects from the works of earlier artists, a practice mocked by Nathaniel Hone in a painting called The Conjuror submitted to the Royal Academy exhibition of 1775, and now in the collection of the National Gallery of Ireland. It shows a figure representing, though not resembling, Reynolds, seated in front of a cascade of prints from which Reynolds had borrowed with varying degrees of subtlety.[16]>

 

Although not principally known for his landscapes, Reynolds did paint in this genre. He had an excellent vantage from his house, Wick House, on Richmond Hill, and painted the view in about 1780.[17]

 

Reynolds also was recognized for his portraits of children. He emphasized the innocence and natural grace of children when depicting them. His 1788 portrait, Age of Innocence, is his best known character study of a child. The subject of the painting is not known, although conjecture includes Theophila Gwatkin, his great niece, and Lady Anne Spencer, the youngest daughter of the fourth Duke of Marlborough.

 

Reynolds worked long hours in his studio, rarely taking a holiday. He was gregarious and keenly intellectual, with many friends from London's intelligentsia, numbered amongst whom were Dr Samuel Johnson, Oliver Goldsmith, Edmund Burke, Giuseppe Baretti, Henry Thrale, David Garrick, and artist Angelica Kauffman. Johnson said in 1778: "Reynolds is too much under Fox and Burke at present. He is under the Fox star and the Irish constellation [meaning Burke]. He is always under some planet".[18]

 

Because of his popularity as a portrait painter, Reynolds enjoyed constant interaction with the wealthy and famous men and women of the day, and it was he who brought together the figures of "The" Club. It was founded in 1764 and met in a suite of rooms on the first floor of the Turks Head at 9 Gerrard Street, now marked by a plaque. Original members included Burke, Langton, Beauclerk, Goldsmith, Chamier, Hawkins, and Nugent, to be joined by Garrick, Boswell, and Sheridan. In ten years the membership had risen to 35. The Club met every Monday evening for supper and conversation and continued into the early hours of Tuesday morning. In later years, it met fortnightly during Parliamentary sessions. When in 1783 the landlord of the Turks Head died and the property was sold, The Club moved to Sackville Street.

 

Reynolds was one of the earliest members of the Royal Society of Arts, helped found the Society of Artists of Great Britain, and, with Gainsborough, established the Royal Academy of Arts, a spin-off organisation. In 1768 he was made the Royal Academy's first president, a position he held until his death. As a lecturer, his Discourses (delivered between 1769 and 1790) are remembered for their sensitivity and perception. In one lectures he was of the opinion that "invention, strictly speaking, is little more than a new combination of those images which have been previously gathered and deposited in the memory." William Jackson in his contemporary essays said of Reynolds ' there is much ingenuity and originality in all his academic discourses, replete with classical knowledge of his art, acute remarks on the works of others, and general taste and discernment'.[20]

 

Reynolds and the Royal Academy received a mixed reception. Critics include many Pre-Raphaelites, and William Blake who published the vitriolic Annotations to Sir Joshua Reynolds' Discourses in 1808. J. M. W. Turner and James Northcote were fervent acolytes: Turner requested he be laid to rest at Reynolds' side, and Northcote, who spent four years as Reynolds' pupil, wrote to his family "I know him thoroughly, and all his faults, I am sure, and yet almost worship him."

 

In the Battle of Ushant against the French in 1778, Lord Keppel commanded the Channel Fleet and the outcome resulted in no clear winner; Keppel ordered the attack be renewed and was obeyed except by Sir Hugh Palliser, who commanded the rear, and the French escaped bombardment. A dispute between Keppel and Palliser arose and Palliser brought charges of misconduct and neglect of duty against Keppel and the Admiralty decided to court-martial him. On 11 February 1779 Keppel was acquitted of all charges and became a national hero. One of Keppel's lawyers commissioned Sir Nathaniel Dance-Holland to paint a portrait of Keppel but Keppel redirected it to Reynolds. Reynolds alluded to Keppel's trial in the painting by painting his hand on his sword, reflecting the presiding officer's words at the court-martial: "In delivering to you your sword, I am to congratulate you on its being restored to you with so much honour"

 

On 10 August 1784 Allan Ramsay died and the office of Principal Painter in Ordinary to the king became vacant. Gainsborough felt that he had a good chance of securing it, but Reynolds felt he deserved it and threatened to resign the presidency of the Royal Academy if he did not receive it. Reynolds noted in his pocket book: "Sept. 1, 2½, to attend at the Lord Chancellor's Office to be sworn in painter to the King".[22] It did not make Reynolds happy, however, as he wrote to Boswell: "If I had known what a shabby miserable place it is, I would not have asked for it; besides as things have turned out I think a certain person is not worth speaking to, nor speaking of", presumably meaning the king.[23] Reynolds wrote to Jonathan Shipley, Bishop of St Asaph, a few weeks later: "Your Lordship congratulation on my succeeding Mr. Ramsay I take very kindly, but it is a most miserable office, it is reduced from two hundred to thirty-eight pounds per annum, the Kings Rat catcher I believe is a better place, and I am to be paid only a fourth part of what I have from other people, so that the Portraits of their Majesties are not likely to be better done now, than they used to be, I should be ruined if I was to paint them myself".

 

In 1787 Reynolds painted the portrait of Lord Heathfield, who became a national hero for the successful defence of Gibraltar in the Great Siege from 1779 to 1783 against the combined forces of France and Spain. Heathfield is depicted against a background of clouds and cannon smoke, wearing the uniform of the 15th Light Dragoons and clasping the key of the Rock, its chain wrapped twice around his right hand.[24] John Constable said in the 1830s that it was "almost a history of the defence of Gibraltar".[1] Desmond Shawe-Taylor has claimed that the portrait may have a religious meaning, Heathfield holding the key similar to St. Peter (Jesus' "rock") possessing the keys to Heaven, Heathfield "the rock upon which Britannia builds her military interests".

 

In 1789 Reynolds lost the sight of his left eye, which forced him into retirement. In 1791 James Boswell dedicated his Life of Samuel Johnson to Reynolds. Reynolds agreed with Burke's Reflections on the Revolution in France and, writing in early 1791, expressed his belief that the ancien régime of France had fallen due to spending too much time tending, as he puts it;

 

"to the splendor of the foliage, to the neglect of the stirring the earth about the roots. They cultivated only those arts which could add splendor to the nation, to the neglect of those which supported it – They neglected Trade & substantial Manufacture...but does it follow that a total revolution is necessary that because we have given ourselves up too much to the ornaments of life, we will now have none at all".[26]

 

When attending a dinner at Holland House, Fox's niece Caroline was sat next to Reynolds and "burst out into glorification of the Revolution – and was grievously chilled and checked by her neighbour's cautious and unsympathetic tone".[27]

 

On 4 June 1791 at a dinner at the Freemasons' Tavern to mark the king's birthday, Reynolds drank to the toasts "GOD save the KING!" and "May our glorious Constitution under which the arts flourish, be immortal!", in what was reported by the Public Advertiser as "a fervour truly patriotick". Reynolds "filled the chair with a most convivial glee".[28] He returned to town from Burke's house in Beaconsfield and Edmond Malone wrote that "we left his carriage at the Inn at Hayes, and walked five miles on the road, in a warm day, without his complaining of any fatigue".[28]

 

Later that month Reynolds suffered from a swelling over his left eye and had to be purged by a surgeon. In October he was too ill to take the president's chair and in November Fanny Burney recorded that

 

"I had long languished to see that kindly zealous friend, but his ill health had intimidated me from making the attempt": "He had a bandage over one eye, and the other shaded with a green half-bonnet. He seemed serious even to sadness, though extremely kind. ‘I am very glad,’ he said, in a meek voice and dejected accent, ‘to see you again, and I wish I could see you better! but I have only one eye now, and hardly that.’ I was really quite touched".[29]

 

On 5 November Reynolds, fearing he might not have an opportunity to write a will, wrote a memorandum intended to be his last will and testament, with Edmund Burke, Edmond Malone, and Philip Metcalfe named as executors. On 10 November Reynolds wrote to Benjamin West to resign the presidency, but the General Assembly agreed he should be re-elected, with Sir William Chambers and West to deputise for him.[30]

 

Doctors Richard Warren and Sir George Baker believed Reynolds' illness to be psychological and they bled his neck "with a view of drawing the humour from his eyes" but the effect, in the view of his niece, was that it seemed "as if the 'principle of life' were gone" from Reynolds. On New Year's Day 1792 Reynolds became "seized with sickness" and from that point could not keep down food.[30] Reynolds died on 23 February 1792 at his house in Leicester Fields in London between eight and nine in the evening.

 

Burke was present on the night Reynolds died, and was moved within hours to write a eulogy of Reynolds:

 

Sir Joshua Reynolds was on very many accounts one of the most memorable men of his Time. He was the first Englishman who added the praise of the eligant Arts to the other Glories of his Country. In Taste, in grace, in facility, in happy invention, and in the richness and Harmony of colouring, he was equal to the great masters of the renowned Ages. In Pourtrait he went beyond them; for he communicated to that description of the art, in which English artists are the most engaged a variety, a Fancy, and a dignity derived from the higher Branches, which even those who professed them a superior manner, did not always preserve when they delineated individual nature. His Purtraits remind the Spectator of the Invention of History, and the amenity of Landscape. In painting pourtraits, he appeared not to be raised upon that platform; but to descend to it from an higher sphere. his paintings illustrate his Lessons—and his Lessons seem to be derived from his Paintings.

He possessed the Theory as perfectly as the Practice of his Art. To be such a painter, he was a profound and penetrating Philosopher.

In full affluence of foreign and domestick Fame, admired by the expert in art, and by the learned in Science, courted by the great, caressed by Sovereign powers, and celebrated by distinguished Poets, his Native humility, modesty and Candour never forsook him, even on surprise or provocation, nor was the least degree of arrogance or assumption visible to the most scrutinizing eye, in any part of his Conduct or discourse.

His talents of every kind powerful from Nature, and not meanly cultivated by Letters, his social Virtues in all the relations, and all the habitudes of Life renderd him the center of a very great and unparalleled Variety of agreeable Societies, which will be dissipated by his Death. He had too much merit not to excite some Jealously; too much innocence to provoke any Enmity. The loss of no man of his Time can be felt with more sincere, general, and unmixed Sorrow.

HAIL! AND FAREWELL![31]

 

Burke's tribute was well received and one journalist called it "the eulogium of Apelles pronounced by Pericles".[32]

 

Reynolds was buried at St Paul's Cathedral. In 1903, a statue, by Alfred Drury, was erected in his honour in Annenberg Courtyard of Burlington House, home of the Royal Academy.[33] Near the statue are fountains, installed in 2000, arranged in the pattern of the planets at the time of Reynolds' birth.

 

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joshua_Reynolds

Polaroid 636 Closeup

Impossible film: PX 70 Color Shade

When I upload this he has one week to go of his national service; 11 months behind. Military police non-commissioned officer he will be in the Finnish reserve of almost a million soldiers until he turns 60.

During his year he had the opportunity to experience quite a lot and as the cherry on top of the cake we had the national parade on the Flag Day of the Finnish Defence Forces in Hanko this year and Junior was there too!

That green beret is coveted too but you have to earn it!

 

Love of my life, I'm so very proud of you! <3

Marie-Julie Baretti (1838-1872); French soprano at the Théâtre Lyrique and the Opera Comique. She sang in the première of Maillart's "Les pecheurs de Catane" (1860) and "Lara" (1864), Reyer's "La statue" (1861) and David's "Le saphir" (1865).

1 3 4 5 6