Back to photostream

First Glasgow BYD D8-UR/ Alexander Dennis Enviro 400EV

From expensive niche to expensive mainstream….

 

Seen here is one of First Glasgow’s expanding fleet of electric buses, 38441 (LG22AVR). Unlike other such similar buses which are branded for the 38 and 75 services, this one is in standard First Glasgow livery meaning in theory it can be used on any of the routes run out of Caledonia depot. This one is on the 61 route heading for Sandyhills in Glasgow’s East End. This route is actually one of the branded routes, home to the light-blue branded Volvo’s B9TLs but increasingly the electric buses are appearing on it with the Volvo’s turning up on other routes.

 

Of course electric buses are not a new idea and some ‘horseless carriages’ for passengers were electric powered as we entered the twentieth century. However battery technology was still very much in its infancy at that time and with no such thing as a National Grid, charging facilities were, at best, hit and miss to say the least. In the end, simpler and more effective Petrol and Diesel powered Internal Combustion Engined won out. They were cheaper to operate, had better range and gave good passenger capacity. Eventually, diesel - or heavy oil as it was called then - reigned supreme, as it was cheaper, buses could run longer and has none of the drawbacks of the other systems.

 

Although electric buses seemed to have died off, this was still an era of electric traction. However this was mainly the electric tram. The tram was proven, it was established and passengers loved it. Plus it was clean although to be fair, that wasn’t the same issue then as it is now. However trams did have drawbacks. Routes were pretty much fixed once the tracks were laid and if you wanted to introduce a new route it meant digging up the road to plonk new rails and overhead wires for it.

 

As traffic levels increased in the 1940s and 1950s, the perceived wisdom amongst so called traffic planning ‘experts’ was that trams were holding up the rest of the traffic. So in an almost indecent haste, cities and towns got rid of their trams, mainly replacing them with diesel buses. Only Blackpool held out retaining part of its original tram network along its famous prom.

 

Some though went for the halfway house of the trolley bus. There was some method in this. The overhead wiring for the trams could be retained and unlike the trams, they could pull into pavements and so didn’t obstruct other traffic. However the same issue that impacted the trans was also the issue here as they could only go where the overhead infrastructure was. Eventually, the last trolley bus network in the UK, in Bradford, ended in 1972, with the vehicles replaced by diesel buses.

 

In the 1970s some tentative steps were made back into the field of pure electric buses. These were mainly single-deckers such as the ‘Silent Rider’, based on a converted Seddon Pennine bus. Two were built for SELNEC - later the Greater Manchester Passenger Transport. Executive. However they were based on then lead acid battery technology and so the range was incredibly limited.

 

A similar project but this time with the National Bus Company saw one of its Leyland National buses converted to run to battery power for its Ribble subsidiary. Again heavy lead acid batteries - effectively car batteries - were used but this time the batteries were loaded on to a trailer towed behind the bus. It was intended to be used in the Runcorn busway where the addition of the trailer wouldn’t be an issue. It remained a one-off, as like the Manchester these buses were hideously expensive and again suffered from poor range.

 

However the impetus for buses for electric buses then died for around forty years. There were the odd ones, such as converted mini-buses and an electric Optare MetroRider for Oxford and a couple of electric buses that were supposed to be used on the Glasgow City Rail Link. Although delivered, these buses never turned a wheel in revenue earning service. But little development of electric buses took place. Until the first decade of the 21st Century.

 

It was only following the development of hybrid buses, that electric buses became a viable proposition. With increasing concerns about emissions from petrol and diesel vehicles, hybrids were seen as a way of driving down emissions. In buses, they married a Diesel engine with an electric motor. A small battery back, charged by engine, ran the electric motor. The motor reduced the load on the engine when it was working the hardest, as it was moving off for example. Hybrids were at a premium compared to standard buses but the were cleaner as they reduced emissions.

 

However, with the success of hybrids, the desire to reduce emissions further saw battery buses rethought, as at this point lithium ion batteries had brought the weight of batteries down. Increasingly, they were chosen by cities and towns as a way to reduce emissions. Indeed sales of electric buses have been increasing year on year., They’re still more expensive and in most cases they’ve been purchased with the support of a grant from Government. However we’re soon to reach the tipping point where electric buses go mainstream. FirstGroup and National Express have already stated that they’ll never purchase another diesel bus. So it’s close. But diesel is now very clean and electric buses still are hampered by range issues. They’re fine for city journeys but put them on longer routes and you need extra buses to cover them. So electric buses, at the moment don’t suit everyone.

5,327 views
16 faves
0 comments
Uploaded on July 22, 2022
Taken on July 22, 2022