LHG Creative Photography
st marys photoshop layers version. (no HDR)
Again tonally superior to the tonemap, and a good deal less grainy. This was 2 images layer together, contrasted , coloured , burned and dodged to suit Personally I think its better than the tonemapped version seen earlier in the stream, so don't think if you aren't tonemapping that your missing much.
Compared like for like, the tonemapped version looks unsubtle, blatent and immature, though obviously liking it over this one is a personal taste issue and open to interpretation, but I guess what i'm saying here relates to how much of what you shoot you want actually to be in the finished image, much as you have to learn to stop editing heavily in photoshop too. You must know when to stop before the integrity of the image is ruined.
An artists hand (or a photoshop techies for that matter) is generally more intuitive, subtle and balanced than HDR or LDR tonemap programs. No logarythm can match it yet! Get control of your right hand and learn layers and tonemapping immediately looks amateurish by comparison. It takes photoshop finishing anyway to sort out your average tonemapped image, lets not kid ourselves here. Most natural tonemaps straight off an HDR look rough to useless.
Once you get past the novelty of overt texture, and also start to realise that looking into the detail of every shadow can be less relevant than seeing a well placed shadow in itself tonemapping starts to indicate its true place in the heirarchy of photographic techniques and adjustment software.
Creating an atmosphere is also about leaving well enough alone, and trusting what your eye saw to love in the first place. If tonemapping isn't subtle enough to help you bring out what you want without overpowering it with the style sense of a computer, then leave well enough alone and go with dodges and burns for enhancement. HDR tonemapping can help you see the world in a different way, especially if one has lazy eyes or needs glasses, but beyond that, its a toy, and its serious uses are for those occassions where its used with real restraint to enhance a reality, rather than dominate it.
I think peoples complaints about others taking perfectly good photo's and ruining them are very well justified. Tonemapping is a tool, let it open your eyes to tonality if you havent tried it before, have fun with it, but don't let it control your tastes, because if you do, you take photography and make it a kids sport. Most images stand the test of time better , hold relevance for longer when the overt style of the age isnt massively applied.
Man Ray may have been a great photographer and will be respected as such for a long time, but he was pioneering the use of techniques, even he can be passe, and many people do take him or leave him and he was but one of a few using such techniques. By comparison HDR is used by millions, so unless you really really want to use it specifically to create a certain image with absolute intention and acceptance of its limits, then leave it be , or just use it as a learning experience, because well.... its a very quick way to make your work look instantly dated, and give things a date and time context that belong to a movement of manufacturing, not to a time a place or an individual, and thusly I believe in most cases it will diminish the importance of the vast majority of images its associated with. This is a conformism , not an individuality, and it only defies that logic when used with the most specific, intentional and valid of specific purposes. The natural take is still the unchallenged god of photography.
HDR tonemapping has put the fun into photography for some, and to be fair, I have been enjoying the experience immensely and will no doubt continue to do so for some time, but it is a product of its time, and if you wan't your photo's to live past that, then keep your RAW files eh. Don't forget to take that perfect manual shot on the day and don't just leave yourself a half dozen badly exposed photos that outside of a tonemapping effort, have no relevance, and suck as stand-alone individual photos.
If you find yourself taking these things all the time, then its time for the alarm bells to ring and for you to remind yourself that its only a 0.000000000001 % aspect of the massive art that is modern photography. Keep a repertoire going at all times, add, but do not diminish. That portfolio of work won't sell to anyone, and never will get genuine artistic acclainm if all you do is HDR. Besides, tech moves on and there will be better things to go for, as camera technology eventually bridges the gap in perception between what we see and what we accurately record.
st marys photoshop layers version. (no HDR)
Again tonally superior to the tonemap, and a good deal less grainy. This was 2 images layer together, contrasted , coloured , burned and dodged to suit Personally I think its better than the tonemapped version seen earlier in the stream, so don't think if you aren't tonemapping that your missing much.
Compared like for like, the tonemapped version looks unsubtle, blatent and immature, though obviously liking it over this one is a personal taste issue and open to interpretation, but I guess what i'm saying here relates to how much of what you shoot you want actually to be in the finished image, much as you have to learn to stop editing heavily in photoshop too. You must know when to stop before the integrity of the image is ruined.
An artists hand (or a photoshop techies for that matter) is generally more intuitive, subtle and balanced than HDR or LDR tonemap programs. No logarythm can match it yet! Get control of your right hand and learn layers and tonemapping immediately looks amateurish by comparison. It takes photoshop finishing anyway to sort out your average tonemapped image, lets not kid ourselves here. Most natural tonemaps straight off an HDR look rough to useless.
Once you get past the novelty of overt texture, and also start to realise that looking into the detail of every shadow can be less relevant than seeing a well placed shadow in itself tonemapping starts to indicate its true place in the heirarchy of photographic techniques and adjustment software.
Creating an atmosphere is also about leaving well enough alone, and trusting what your eye saw to love in the first place. If tonemapping isn't subtle enough to help you bring out what you want without overpowering it with the style sense of a computer, then leave well enough alone and go with dodges and burns for enhancement. HDR tonemapping can help you see the world in a different way, especially if one has lazy eyes or needs glasses, but beyond that, its a toy, and its serious uses are for those occassions where its used with real restraint to enhance a reality, rather than dominate it.
I think peoples complaints about others taking perfectly good photo's and ruining them are very well justified. Tonemapping is a tool, let it open your eyes to tonality if you havent tried it before, have fun with it, but don't let it control your tastes, because if you do, you take photography and make it a kids sport. Most images stand the test of time better , hold relevance for longer when the overt style of the age isnt massively applied.
Man Ray may have been a great photographer and will be respected as such for a long time, but he was pioneering the use of techniques, even he can be passe, and many people do take him or leave him and he was but one of a few using such techniques. By comparison HDR is used by millions, so unless you really really want to use it specifically to create a certain image with absolute intention and acceptance of its limits, then leave it be , or just use it as a learning experience, because well.... its a very quick way to make your work look instantly dated, and give things a date and time context that belong to a movement of manufacturing, not to a time a place or an individual, and thusly I believe in most cases it will diminish the importance of the vast majority of images its associated with. This is a conformism , not an individuality, and it only defies that logic when used with the most specific, intentional and valid of specific purposes. The natural take is still the unchallenged god of photography.
HDR tonemapping has put the fun into photography for some, and to be fair, I have been enjoying the experience immensely and will no doubt continue to do so for some time, but it is a product of its time, and if you wan't your photo's to live past that, then keep your RAW files eh. Don't forget to take that perfect manual shot on the day and don't just leave yourself a half dozen badly exposed photos that outside of a tonemapping effort, have no relevance, and suck as stand-alone individual photos.
If you find yourself taking these things all the time, then its time for the alarm bells to ring and for you to remind yourself that its only a 0.000000000001 % aspect of the massive art that is modern photography. Keep a repertoire going at all times, add, but do not diminish. That portfolio of work won't sell to anyone, and never will get genuine artistic acclainm if all you do is HDR. Besides, tech moves on and there will be better things to go for, as camera technology eventually bridges the gap in perception between what we see and what we accurately record.